Clergy Child Molesters (93) — References/Chronology

• N.M. official removed over ex-cleric's parole [1970s Holley] - Roman Catholic Church (RCC). 8 boys. U.S.A. flag; Mooney's MiniFlags 
   The Boston Globe, www.boston.com/news/local/articles/2004/08/14/nm_official_removed_ over_ex_ clerics_ parole ; Associated Press, August 14, 2004
   SANTA FE, NEW MEXICO -- The New Mexico Parole Board's failure to notify victims when a former Worcester, Mass., priest came up for parole on a molestation conviction has led to the dismissal of the board's director.
   Governor Bill Richardson of New Mexico yesterday removed Bob Martinez, who said Thursday that his office had "screwed up" by not alerting victims of David Holley, 77, who pleaded guilty in 1993 to sexually molesting eight boys in Alamogordo in the 1970s.
   Richardson said the board's failure to notify victims violated the state constitution and was a serious breach of public trust. "The public, especially crime victims, must have complete confidence in the system," he said.
   During Holley's 30-year career, bishops sent him for inpatient psychiatric treatment at least twice, then institutionalized him again when abuse allegations resurfaced in the early 1990s after he retired. Allegations by a Massachusetts bishop in the late 1960s and similar ones forced Holley out of his home diocese of Worcester and led to a series of transfers. [Posted by Kathy Shaw at 02:25 PM] (This is the first of the Clergy Sex Abuse Tracker, www.ncrnews.org/abuse , for Sun August 15, 2004.)
^ ^  CONTENTS 1   14  Translate  Links  Events  Books  HOME  v v
< < Back  ^ ^  Bravehearts  Barnardo's-UK  CTA  Celibacy Crept  Non-marital  REFERENCES 51   91  Overview  Outreach  Books  "Fathers"  Religion  Submit  v v   Next > >
INTENTION: A challenge to RELIGIONS to PROTECT CHILDREN
Series starts: www.multiline.com.au/~johnm/ethicscontents.htm   Visit http://www.ncrnews.org/abuse
   INCOMPLETE LINKS: Refer back to "References 61" for methods of obtaining the URLs.
• Wichita diocese setting up ecumenical group for sex abuse victims
   The Wichita Eagle, www.kansascity.com/mld/kansascity/news/local/9409404.htm , Associated Press, ~ Aug 15, 2004
   WICHITA, Kan. - Saying that sexual abuse by clergy crosses denominational lines, the Catholic Diocese of Wichita is setting up an ecumenical group for victims of such abuse.
   "We're taking the approach, 'Build it and they will come,'" said the Rev. Paul Coakley, vice chancellor of the diocese. "We know that there's a problem, we know that people have been hurt, and we want to help with the healing."
   But in working to establish the new group, the diocese continues to withhold its endorsement of an existing support group for Catholic victims of abuse.
   For the past 18 months, a support group sponsored by the Survivors Network for those Abused by Priests - or SNAP - has met in the Wichita area.
• Priest admits to rape -- of step-daughter. South Africa flag; Mooney's MiniFlags 
   News 24, www.news24.com/News24/South_Africa/News/0,,2-7-1442_1573299,00.html , 20:23, 15/Aug/2004
   PRETORIA, SOUTH AFRICA: A Mpumalanga priest has been arrested for raping his 18-year-old step-daughter, Pretoria police reported on Sunday.
   Captain Piletji Sebola said the 38-year-old man, who has confessed to raping the girl to police, started molesting the girl when she was 13-years of age at their Ekangala location home.
   Sebola said a few years back the girl's mother once caught her husband raping the girl in the house.
   The matter was discussed as a family issue and the priest apologised and promised not to do it again.
• Prosecutors block child sex charges [Ridsdale, Dowlan, Best] -- Priest, Christian Brothers; prosecuting "not in the public interest." Australia flag; Aust. Nat. Flag Assn. 
   The Age, www.theage.com.au/articles/2004/08/15/1092508263548.html , By Ian Munro, Aug 16, 2004
   AUSTRALIA: The Office of Public Prosecutions is refusing to press charges against one of Victoria's most notorious pedophiles, former priest Gerald Francis Ridsdale, despite nine more victims coming forward since his conviction on 46 charges.
   The OPP told a police investigator that although it sympathised with the nine complainants, prosecuting Ridsdale further was "not in the public interest".
   A four-year investigation by Detective Sergeant Kevin Carson of Ballarat CIU uncovered the allegations against Ridsdale, 70, who was sentenced in 1994 to a minimum of 15 years' jail.
   Among the latest complainants is a western Victorian man, 35, whose account of abuse includes 12 instances of rape. He claims he was subjected to oral sex several times a week when he was a child in Edenhope.
   A psychiatrist's report on the man, seen by The Age, notes there were few situations "which would exceed this in terms of the level of cruelty and degradation suffered by the victim".
   Dr William Glaser said it was a tribute to the man that he had been able to achieve even a semblance of a normal life, but he would still be left with chronic, serious psychiatric problems.
   In a letter to victims telling them of the decision not to prosecute, Sergeant Carson said: "While you may well believe that current community standards differ markedly from the view expressed by the OPP, I point out that I cannot take this matter any further for you."
   The man's family, who cannot be identified, released a copy of the letter.
   His mother said Ridsdale's jail sentence was unrelated to the offences against her son. "(My son) doesn't ever want to see Ridsdale out of jail because he will offend again," she said.
   "I know from a mother's point of view it will help them get peace of mind when they know he will not get out of jail."
   Sergeant Carson would not comment on the OPP's refusal to pursue charges.
   A spokesman for the OPP said that even if Ridsdale was found guilty of the new allegations, he would be unlikely to receive an increased sentence.
   The Court of Appeal in 1995 described Ridsdale's sentence as a "virtual life sentence . . . unusually long". At such a late stage of his life it was "harsh punishment and a severe burden". The court said he would not be eligible for parole until he was 75.
   The OPP spokesman said: "Our view is he would not get a substantial increase to his sentence, if any. We are prosecuting all of these cases in the context of limited resources in the criminal justice system. The question becomes 'what's to be gained for the public?'
   "While we understand the concern of the individual victims, and we are concerned for the victims, it's a question of balancing all of the considerations."
   However, the western Victorian man's mother said that while the courts might view Ridsdale's sentence as severe, her son would always carry a burden. "This follows every one of the children (Ridsdale abused) into teenage and into adulthood. They still carry their scars."
   It is also believed that further allegations not to be acted on have been levelled against two of Ridsdale's co-offenders, former Christian Brothers Robert Best and Edward Dowlan, both of whom taught primary classes at St Alipius school, Ballarat.
   At Dowlan's County Court trial in 1996, the prosecution alleged that three St Alipius boys were each sexually abused by Dowlan, Best and Ridsdale.
   Ten complainants are believed to have made further allegations against Dowlan and Best. #
• Preacher accused of statutory rape undergoes psychosexual evaluation [2004 Dobson] -- girls, Baptist. U.S.A. flag; Mooney's MiniFlags 
   Review Appeal, http://reviewappeal.midsouthnews.com/news.ez?viewStory=24380 , By MELISSA N. WARREN, ~ Aug 15, 2004
   TENNESSEE: The review date for a Baptist preacher accused of having sex with two teenage runaways was scheduled for Monday but is now continued pending a psychosexual evaluation.
   Nathaniel Dobson, who agreed to the evaluation, was indicted on two statutory rape charges by Williamson County's grand jury in May. That indictment was filed after an investigation by Franklin's Criminal Investigation Division led to a voluntary confession from Dobson that he did, in fact, have sex with the two girls - ages 14 and 15 - during the early morning hours of March 21.
   "He came into contact with two girls who needed food and shelter and he took advantage of them," Detective Charles Warner said in May. "He met them on the street in Nashville and brought them to the hotel room."
   Dobson, who was previously a senior pastor at New Shiloh Baptist Church in Lebanon, met the girls on the streets of Nashville. However, officials said the preacher drove the duo to the Best Western Motel on Highway 96 East in Franklin, which is where the offense took place.
• Priest named in sex abuse allegations [1970s Mickey]
   Tennessean, www.tennessean.com/local/archives/04/08/55927526.shtml?Element_ID= 55927526 , Associated Press, ~ Aug 15, 2004
   JACKSON, Tenn. - Catholic Church members in Jackson are defending their priest after he was named in a damaging sexual allegation.
   The Rev. Richard Mickey of St. Mary's Catholic Church was placed on administrative leave Thursday after a lawsuit by twin brothers Blain and Blair Chambers alleged the pastor sexually abused them almost 25 years ago  when he worked in Memphis.
   The lawsuit by the brothers, who are now 39 and live in Montana, came to light Wednesday, and says the alleged abuse occurred at Bishop Byrne High School in Memphis in 1980.
   Mickey, who denied the allegations Wednesday, worked as a counselor to one of the teens and a religion instructor to the other, according to the lawsuit.
• Relatives file missing person report for former polygamous church figure, Fred Jessop
   Provo Daily Herald, www.harktheherald.com/modules.php?op=modload&name=News &file=article&sid=31810 &mode=thread&order=0&thold=0 ; by Patty Henetz, THE ASSOCIATED PRESS, ~ Aug 15, 2004
   HURRICANE (UT) -- Relatives of a once promising leader for a polygamous community filed a missing-person report Friday, saying the church elder hasn't been since December and could be dead. Authorities said they would act on the report.
   Fred Jessop, a former bishop of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints, vanished after being excommunicated by the new leader of the fundamentalist faith, which believes polygamy assures a path to heaven and eternal life.
   Jessop, who is 94 or 95, was last seen around town Dec. 20, say several relatives. One of his nephews, Joseph Charles Jessop Jr., told sheriff's deputies on Friday that he fears his uncle is either dead or is being held captive to Warren Jeffs, who took control of the church after the 2002 death of his father, former prophet Rulon Jeffs.
• Judge tosses out clergy sex abuse lawsuits in Pennsylvania [1957-83] -- too late.
   The Hindu, www.hinduonnet.com/thehindu/holnus/003200408150901.htm , Aug 15, 2004
   PHILADELPHIA (PA) (AP):Seventeen adults who sued the Philadelphia archdiocese for alleged child sexual abuse by Roman Catholic clergy waited too long to file suit, a judge ruled.
   In dismissing the lawsuits, Judge Arnold New rejected claims that a cover-up by the archdiocese helped hide the abuse from the victims' families, preventing them from suing within the two-year time limit.
   The alleged abuse dates from 1957 to 1983. Until 1984, child sexual assault victims had two years to file suit; a 2002 law extended the deadline to an alleged victim's 30th birthday. The new law is not retroactive.
   Attorneys for the plaintiffs said they would appeal.
   The judge ruled the archdiocese's assignment of potentially abusive priests did not harm the plaintiffs - at least in legal terms.
   "Although the Archdiocesan defendants' actions may have placed the priests in a position to commit the batteries, it was the actions of the priests which caused the actual injury," he wrote.
   The Archdiocese of Philadelphia, in a statement Friday, reaffirmed its view that "the statute of limitations does apply in all these cases."
• Catholics brace for church closings
   Portland Press Herald, http://pressherald.mainetoday.com/news/state/040815catholic. shtml , By KELLEY BOUCHARD, Aug 15, 2004
   MAINE: Martha Conroy knows the landscape of Maine's Roman Catholic parishes better than most.
   For several years in the late 1980s, the former middle-school math teacher was director of worship for the Diocese of Portland. She traveled the state, from Portland to Fort Kent, helping parishes better understand and improve their celebration of the liturgy.
   So, Conroy was a natural choice to sit on the statewide committee of clergy and laity that is looking at how to revitalize and restructure the state's 135 parishes. The goal of the New Evangelization Planning Committee is to reaffirm the church's mission and deal with changing demographics, dwindling clergy and greater competition for financial resources.  ...
   In recent years, the Wall Street downturn hurt the diocese's investments, whose value dropped from $70.6 million in 2002 to $68.9 million in 2003. Diocesan offices and programs are funded through investment dividends, the annual bishop's appeal and a 5.5 percent assessment of each parish's income.
   The priest sex-abuse scandal led some Catholics to stop attending Mass and reduced contributions in the collection basket. The diocese spent more than $2.7 million for settlements, victim assistance and legal expenses related to sexual-abuse allegations against 60 Maine priests and other church people from 1950 to 2003.
   At the same time, the number of diocesan priests is down from 229 in 1950 to 103 today, with 135 parishes across the state. By 2010, if there are no deaths or severe disabilities among the remaining priests, only 68 will be below the normal retirement age of 70. The diocese has averaged two ordinations a year for several years. [Posted by Kathy Shaw at 08:33 AM]
////////// End of Clergy Sex Abuse Tracker www.ncrnews.org/abuse , Sun August 15, 2004
Abuse Chronology: http://www.multiline.com.au/~johnm/ethics/ethcont93.htm
#### Clergy Sex Abuse Tracker, www.ncrnews.org/abuse, Mon August 16, 2004 edition follows:-
• Camp Counselors Charged With Abusing Children [2004] -- Baptist. U.S.A. flag; Mooney's MiniFlags 
   ABC 7, www.wjla.com/news/stories/0804/166481.html , 5:50pm, Monday Aug 16, 2004
   GAINESVILLE, Va. (AP) - Two counselors and two campers at a church-run summer camp in Gainesville have been charged with sexual abuse.
   Prince William County police say it happened during the week of July 18th at the Northern Virginia Baptist Center. Investigators say it started out as roughhousing and horseplay between male counselors and male campers and escalated into sexual assaults.
   Investigators believe a 17-year-old counselor, a 15-year-old counselor and two 12-year-old campers assaulted three campers while others watched. The victims are ten, eleven and 12. A seven-year-old camper tells investigators he was locked in a room when he tried to run for help. [Posted by Kathy Shaw at 07:54 PM]
• Clergyman Denies Baby Trafficking Charge -- evangelist. Kenya flag; Mooney's MiniFlags  Britain flag; Mooney's MiniFlags 
   AllAFrica.com ; http://allafrica.com/stories/200408160548.html , by Mwangi Githahu, Nairobi, August 15, 2004, Posted to the web August 16, 2004
   NAIROBI, KENYA: The evangelist at the centre of a storm over charges of baby trafficking between Kenya and the UK, yesterday issued a statement from his headquarters in London, denying the allegations.
   Archbishop Gilbert Deya said he was not "involved in trafficking of any sort". Condemning his accusers as "evil, satanic and abnormal",  Pastor Deya said: "I refute the evil allegations against me of trafficking children from Kenya to the United Kingdom."
   Edith Edzedom, a follower of Archbishop Gilbert Deya, holds 10-week-old Joshua, one of the alleged miracle babies, when she and other members called at Nation Centre, Nairobi yesterday.
• Woman Files Lawsuit Against Catholic Leaders -- worked for RCC 22 years. U.S.A. flag; Mooney's MiniFlags 
   WOAI, www.woai.com/news/local/story.aspx?content_id=69A60B3F- 019D-4FE9-A42A-95F2FC8BBCFF ; Posted By Carly Miller, mailto:markpipitone@woai.com , 7:10:08 PM, Aug/16/2004
   SAN ANTONIO (TX): A San Antonio woman has filed a lawsuit against Catholic leaders here in San Antonio, because of abuse she says happened more than 20 years ago.
   The woman who filed the lawsuit, Cynthia Tejeda, worked for the Archdiocese of San Antonio for 22 years.
   The lawsuit filed Friday claims Archbishop Patrick Flores, the entire Archdiocese of San Antonio, and other Catholic leaders, did not do enough to stop the alleged abuse.
   The priest in question has since passed away.
   On Monday afternoon, Cynthia Tejeda spoke out for the first time. She says it's taken her 27 years to find the courage to tell what happened.
   "I slowly realized that continuing to work in, and for a system, that contributed to the abuse and the loss of my adolescence, would only serve to cause more trauma, suffering and pain as I strived to rebuild my life," said Cynthia Tejeda.
   The Archdiocese of San Antonio tells News 4 WOAI it has not had time to look at the suit sufficiently, and did not want to comment at this time.
   Defense lawyers hope to bring it to trial within 9-12 months. #
• Editorial: Due process for priests -- Schreiter.
   Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, www.jsonline.com/news/editorials/aug04/250901.asp , From the Journal Sentinel, Posted Aug. 13, 2004
   WISCONSIN: Parishioners greeted Father John Schreiter with standing ovations, applause, smiles and tears of joy last week when he returned to his church in Dousman after a diocesan review board essentially cleared the priest of an allegation of sexual abuse. The greeting was entirely understandable given Schreiter's popularity and effectiveness in his parish work.
   If it's justified - and there's no reason to believe it isn't - the acquittal shows that the system can work, and that priests wrongly accused will get their day in court, or at least in front of the board. That's important because priests and victims both have to know that everyone will get a fair shake in every case and that due process applies to all.
   At the same time, church authorities could do more to enhance their credibility and bolster the public's faith by explaining the general standards and criteria the Diocesan Review Board uses in determining whether an allegation is substantiated or not. A victims' group has been unsuccessful in its request to meet with the review board to learn how it does its work, and a spokeswoman for the archdiocese was unable to explain the details to a Journal Sentinel reporter.
• Bishop Hubbard reaches out to victims
   Capital News 9, www.capitalnews9.com/content/headlines/?ArID=89344&SecID=33 , By Capital News 9 web staff, 12:11 PM, Aug/16/2004
   ALBANY (NY): The bishop of the Albany Roman Catholic Diocese is reaching out to victims of clergy sexual abuse.
   In a letter released Sunday, Bishop Howard Hubbard said he wants to meet with the victims and let the healing begin.
   The letter is called "Steps Toward Healing and Reconciliation." It was handed out at most Catholic services held in the Capital Region.
   Some are questioning the timing of its release -- including Hubbard's biggest critic -- attorney John Aretakis. He is calling the letter a "puff piece."
• Fitzpatrick Arrested [2000s] -- RC youth club leader.
   WIVB, www.wivb.com/Global/story.asp?S=2179487&nav=0RapPuI6 , August 16, 2004
   TONAWANDA (NY): A man who pleged his trust to young people at a local boys and girls club faces serious charges involving sex crimes. Martin Fitzpatrick is charged with sexual abuse and rape. News 4's Erika Brason has more.
   According to police, a 51 year old man who volunteered for the Northtowns Boys and Girls Club has been arrested and charged with having a sexual relationship with a minor.
   Officials with the Boys and Girls Club tell me Martin Fitzpatrick had been the unit director for the past three years for the Boys and Girls Club program at our Lady of Black Rock School in Buffalo. ...
   Officials with the Catholic Diocese tell me Martin Fitzpatrick was also a volunteer at Our Lady of Black Rock School, however none of the allegations have ties to his work there.
• Former priest faces suit over alleged sex abuse [1978-81 Thiel] -- boys.
   Grand Rapids Press, www.mlive.com/news/grpress/index.ssf?/base/news- 16/1092235783 246200.xml , By Charles Honey, Press Religion Editor, Wednesday, August 11, 2004
   GRAND RAPIDS (MI): A national sex-abuse victims' group came to Grand Rapids Tuesday to ask the Catholic Diocese to alert the public about a former priest and teacher accused of child abuse.
   James Thiel resigned from teaching at Grand Rapids Catholic Central 10 years ago, after allegations of abuse in St. Louis years earlier came to light.
   Thiel denies any misconduct. But leaders of SNAP -- the Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests -- believe he still may pose a threat to children.
   "We want (the diocese) to warn people that Father Thiel is now living here in Grand Rapids, so that they can protect their children," said SNAP President Barbara Blaine of Chicago, in a news conference in front of the diocesan headquarters at 660 Burton St. SE.
   Thiel, who taught religion at Catholic Central from 1986 to 1994, was served Friday with a lawsuit alleging he molested a middle-school boy in St. Louis from 1978 to 1981. Two other St. Louis-area men say they received confidential church settlements of their abuse allegations dating from the 1970s.
• Murder tip hotline established [1972]
   The Republican, www.masslive.com/chicopeeholyoke/republican/index.ssf?/base/news-5/1092428 0328061.xml ; Sunday, August 15, 2004
   SPRINGFIELD (MA): A murder tip hotline has been established by former state police officer R.C. Stevens to help him look into the 1972 unsolved murder of 13-year-old Springfield altar boy Daniel Croteau.
   The toll free number is 1-877-582-0479.
   Stevens is a retired Massachusetts State Police sergeant who operates his own private detective agency, Psychologically Supported Intervention & Investigation Inc., in Northampton.
   He has been hired by The Republican to review the more than 2,000 pages of court documents on the investigation that The Republican successfully had unimpounded. Stevens will also make inquiries into the Croteau murder in the hopes of uncovering a new lead in the case that could be used by law enforcement to solve the murder.
   Stevens will be using some retired police officers as independent contractors for this work. They have already met as a group and individuals have been assigned to interview various people,  including 1972 Croteau murder investigators who are still living.
• Hotline Started In Altar Boy Murder Case [1972]
   TheBostonChannel.com ; www.thebostonchannel.com/news/3655785/detail.html?treets= bos&tid=2652227206813 &tml=bos_12pm&tmi=bos_12pm_7025_11000108162004&ts=H ; POSTED: 6:26 am EDT, August 16, 2004
   SPRINGFIELD, Mass. -- A former state police officer turned private investigator has set up a hot line in hopes of finding new clues in the unsolved 1972 murder of an altar boy.
   R.C. Stevens created a toll-free number for people to phone in tips about the killing of 13-year-old Daniel Croteau, according to The Republican of Springfield.
   The newspaper has hired Stevens to review more than 2,000 pages of recently released court documents on the Croteau investigation. The state Supreme Judicial Court ordered the release of the documents last month.
   Croteau was found bludgeoned to death on April 15, 1972, on the banks of the Chicopee River. The chief suspect in the killing is now-defrocked pedophile priest Richard Lavigne. He has maintained his innocence, and has never been charged with the killing.
   Stevens, a retired Massachusetts State Police sergeant, now operates a private detective agency in Northampton. [...]
   The toll free number is 1-877-582-0479.
• Rape, indecency charges see priest suspended [2003 Nagel] -- girls. Namibia flag; Mooney's MiniFlags 
   The Namibian, www.namibian.com.na/2004/august/national/045D305DA5.html , By LINDSAY DENTLINGER, Monday, August 16, 2004
   NAMIBIA: The Roman Catholic Church has suspended Father Hans-Peter Nagel from service pending Police investigations into alleged rape and indecent assault charges.
   Nagel (78) has been the parish priest at Khorixas for about 10 years.
   He is accused of raping three girls aged between 8 and 13 years early last year at his house and at the church hall.
   The priest appeared in the Khorixas Magistrate's Court on Wednesday on three charges of rape as well as two counts of indecent assault after nude pictures were discovered of one of the girls.
   He was released on bail of N$1 500 a day later.
   Archbishop Liborius Nashenda told The Namibian on Friday that he was "shocked" by the allegations but that the church would not consider taking punitive action against the priest until a court passed judgement on the accusations. [...]
   Warrant Officer James Matengu of the Police Public Relations division said the Police had found nude pictures of one of the victims in the priest's car some time back.
   The father had called the Police to dust his car for fingerprints after it was broken into at Otjiwarongo.
   The discovery was communicated to the Police Women and Child Protection Unit, which pursued investigations into the matter.
   Nashenda said the Khorixas Police had informed him nearly a month ago that they were investigating Nagel.  . . .
• Reaction mixed over Cardinal Law's duties [1962-95 +] Italy flag; Mooney's MiniFlags  Vatican City flag; Mooney's MiniFlags  U.S.A. flag; Mooney's MiniFlags 
   The Washington Times, http://washingtontimes.com/world/20040815-110231-8281r.htm , By John Phillips, August 15, 2004
   ROME - About two months after Cardinal Bernard Law was appointed to run one of the most famous churches in Rome, congregations in the Eternal City are reacting with a mixture of compassion and horror at receiving spiritual guidance from the former archbishop of Boston, the Roman press reports.
   Cardinal Law was forced to resign amid a scandal over his failure to defrock John Geoghan, a priest in his archdiocese accused of abusing more than 100 minors from 1962 to 1995. Pope John Paul II named the American prelate on May 27 to the relatively ceremonial post of archpriest of the basilica of St. Mary Major, a stone's throw from the Colosseum.
   Cardinal Law's new job is largely administrative, running one of the largest and most architecturally imposing churches in the Italian capital. It traditionally has been a recommended place of pilgrimage for Roman Catholics visiting the city.
   But critics of the appointment, especially among the Anglo-Saxon Catholic community in Rome, say the job is more congenial and prestigious than is appropriate. They note that Cardinal Law occupies a comfortable apartment in the basilica that goes with the post.
• Former school director denies inappropriate relationship [2000s Ray] -- girl, Abundant Life Christian Academy. U.S.A. flag; Mooney's MiniFlags 
   The Charleston Gazette, http://wvgazette.com/section/APNews/News/ap0008r , AP-ES, 1517EDT, Aug-15-04; Information from: The Inter-Mountain, http://www.theintermountain.com
   ELKINS, W.Va. (AP) -- A former religious school director who was sued for allegedly having an affair with a 17-year-old girl has asked a Randolph County circuit judge to dismiss the lawsuit and has filed a countersuit seeking damages.
   The original lawsuit filed in July against Curlie Ray Jr., former pastor of the Abundant Life Christian Center in Beverly and director of the Abundant Life Christian Academy, sought $500,000 in damages and alleged the school's trustees were negligent for not conducting a background check of Ray.
   In a motion filed Aug. 4, Ray said he did not have an inappropriate relationship with the girl, who was a student at the academy, and the girl's father, who filed the lawsuit, knew the charges were false.
   Ray cited a letter the student wrote to Randolph Circuit Judge John Henning in which she stated, "The only thing that was going on with Mr. Ray and I was phone conversations. It has never been nothing else, nothing sexual as my father and stepmother are trying to prove."
• Hubbard proposes 'healing' meeting
   Albany Times Union, www.timesunion.com/AspStories/story.asp?storyID=276303& category=REGION&BCCode=HOME&newsdate=8/16/2004 ; By KEN THURMAN, Monday, August 16, 2004
   ALBANY (NY): In an open letter to Catholics in the Albany Diocese, Bishop Howard Hubbard said he wants to meet with victims of clergy abuse so that he can apologize for any harm to them by diocesan clergy.
   The letter, titled "Steps Toward Healing and Reconciliation," appeared in many church bulletins distributed Sunday at parishes throughout the 14-county diocese. Hubbard directs his invitation to those "who as minors were sexually abused by clergy of the Albany Catholic Diocese."
   "I have heard your pain and anguish, and you have helped me better understand the long-term problems associated with sexual abuse," Hubbard wrote, noting that over the last several years he has met with victims of abuse.
   "I have apologized on behalf of our diocese and our church. I have tried to reassure you that you were not at fault for the abuse you suffered," he adds.
• Diocese nears threshold on bankruptcy
   Arizona Daily Star, www.dailystar.com/dailystar/dailystar/34399.php , By Stephanie Innes, Aug.16.2004
Decision may come this week ahead of civil trial in Yuma
   TUCSON (AZ): As he prepares for a yearlong deployment in Iraq, U.S. Army investigator Brandon Croly feels little hope for a resolution to the sexual-molestation lawsuit he filed against the Roman Catholic Diocese of Tucson.
   The diocese is making preparations to declare bankruptcy, and the man accused of molesting Croly, the Rev. Fernando Manzo, has been missing since December, when the Tucson Police Department began investigating the allegations of sexual abuse.
   Croly filed the civil action earlier this year, one of 20 pending lawsuits against the diocese that allege sexual abuse of children by priests. Manzo also is Croly's uncle.
   The diocese could decide as early as this week whether to take the extraordinary step of declaring bankruptcy - a move that could delay for years potentially damaging cases such as Croly's.
   If he decides to file for bankruptcy, Diocese of Tucson Bishop Gerald F. Kicanas would follow the lead of his former Chicago colleague, Archbishop John G. Vlazny of Portland, Ore. Tucson would become the second Catholic diocese in the country to seek federal Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection as a means of meeting the costs of lawsuits alleging sexual abuse of children by priests.
• Catholic school in Pittsfield under pressure from Diocese
   Morning Sentinel, http://morning sentinel.maine today.com/news/ local/894853. shtml , ~ Aug 16, 2004
   PITTSFIELD (ME) -- Officials at the Roman Catholic Diocese of Portland are urging the local Catholic elementary school to quickly boost fund raising and enrollment. The school in Pittsfield is among many Catholic schools in Maine with financial difficulties.
   St. Agnes School, the newest of the state's Catholic schools, recently received notification from the Diocese that its financial stagnation can't continue. It was the only school in the state to receive such a notice.
   "St. Agnes has to look very closely at their enrollment and the financial resources that they have," said Sue Bernard, a spokeswoman for the Diocese. "That's going to determine their future." ...
   Brian Gray, a spokesman for the National Catholic Education Association, said enrollment is declining primarily because many Catholic schools are located in inner-city areas with steadily decreasing populations. Officials say enrollment drops are not related to the priest sexual abuse scandal that embroiled the church for much of last year.
• Report suspected abuse, experts urge -- 300,000 hotline complaints last year.
   Chicago Daily Herald, www.dailyherald.com/kane/main_story.asp?intID=3821543 , By Garrett Ordower, Posted Monday, August 16, 2004
   ILLINOIS: No one pretends reporting suspected child abuse or neglect is easy. Doing so brings worries about retaliation, loss of trust and ruined reputations over what could merely be a rumor.
   But nearly 300,000 times last year, people made the decision to report suspected abuse or neglect to the state's hotline. Some made the call armed with a full accounting of abuse directly from the victim, others heard a story through the grapevine and still others had just a license plate or physical description.
   About 65 percent of those calls came from mandated reporters - including clergy, teachers, police, doctors and firefighters - who are required by state law to report suspected child abuse or neglect to authorities.
   Much has been said and many questions have been asked about the actions of those who knew, or might have known, about the sexual abuse of two teenage girls by former Geneva priest Mark Campobello, who is serving eight years in prison after pleading guilty. Most of those involved in the case fall under the scope of the mandated reporting law, and one teacher recently lost her job because the Rockford Diocese said she didn't follow it.
   Though those who don't report face the possibility of criminal prosecution, it happens rarely. Law enforcement officials have suggested they won't in the Campobello case.
   More often, people are left to toil in the moral straits of their situation, wondering if they should have reported even if it risked negative consequences.
   The message from experts is that they should have. "Once you know of a situation, even if you have the information third- or fourth-hand, you have an obligation to report, legally and morally," said Sharon Doty, a legal expert and consultant with Virtus, which created the Protecting God's Children program in use by more than 80 Catholic dioceses across the country.
   Certain professions like teaching are included in the mandated reporting act because those who work in them often come in close contact with children, and children turn to them in times of need. But that same closeness can cause hesitation when it comes to reporting child abuse, for fear of hurting the child even more. Those fears, Doty said, are unwarranted.
   "Young people will say, 'I need to talk to you, and you can't say anything'," Doty said. "I know to say to them, 'I can't promise that.' Young people will tell anyway because they want to tell, and they want to be supported."
   The publicity that comes with cases of child abuse or neglect also can cause people to pause before carrying out their mandate.
   "We think that making a report causes irreparable harm to someone's reputation," Doty said. "We think that if we report what we saw, it's going to end up on the front page of the paper."
   But in reality, reports to the state Department of Children and Family Services remain largely confidential, especially before investigators deem there to be credible evidence of abuse, according to Linda Everette-Williams, administrator of the state hotline.
   "Our investigations are strictly confidential," Everette-Williams said. Investigators also make every effort to be discreet as they conduct their investigations, she said.
   Many people also fear the retaliation that could come from an "angry pastor or angry uncle," Doty said. While many people can use common sense to identify who reported them, Everette-Williams said, DCFS doesn't disclose that information.
   Those fears are fueled by the false belief that their call will be the final step in the process. However, most reports never make it to the investigation stage. In fiscal 2004, 277,295 calls came in to the hotline, but only 62,749 reports were taken. Of those, credible evidence existed in about 25 percent of the cases.
   Despite the large numbers of reports, Doty said skittishness about reporting rumors still exists, but it shouldn't since the state, not the reporter, sorts out whether there is truth to an allegation.
   "The law says you should make a report," Everette-Williams said. "You shouldn't try to assess it or conduct your own investigation. It's not the role of the mandated reporter to conduct the investigation."
   Though the mechanism to bring criminal charges against someone for failing to report does exist, it's rarely used. The maximum penalty for the misdemeanor crime is up to a year in jail and a fine. Everette-Williams said she only refers about 10 people a year to law enforcement or state licensing boards for breaking the reporting law.
   The DuPage County state's attorney's office launched one of the few prosecutions for failing to report after a mentally disabled 15-year-old boy told a 21-year-old child-care worker he had been beaten by his foster parents, as evidenced by a black eye.
   "The reason it was charged is because she had knowledge the child had been abused and returned the child back into the home," said Laura Pollastrini, a DuPage County state's attorney spokeswoman. "It was blatant. It wasn't like she had questions."
   The woman recently pleaded guilty in exchange for a year of court supervision, and agreed to testify against the foster parents.
   The threat of legal action may carry more weight than the rare prosecutions themselves. People in all of the professions covered by the reporting act must sign a statement acknowledging they understand what the Abused and Neglected Child Reporting Act means and what the penalties are.
   In one form or another, reporting laws have been in place since 1966, with the federal Child Abuse Prevention and Treatment Act enacted in 1974.
   Over time the category of those included as mandated reporters has grown, most notably adding clergy within the past few years. At least 18 states do away with professional categories and simply require anyone over the age of 18 to report, which Doty thinks is a good idea.
   Child-abuse reports shot up 6,000 percent in the decade after mandated reporting laws were enacted in the mid-'60s, according to one published report, and have continued to climb ever since.
   "(Mandated reporters are) the first persons to normally see the abuse and neglect," Everette-Williams said. "They're out there working with families and children every day; children feel comfortable sharing information with them, so they are very important to child protection."
   With the law firmly in place, the emphasis from many of those involved is now on educating those affected by it.
   The law itself requires only that reporters sign a statement acknowledging they know their responsibilities, but it doesn't outline the training they should receive. That training has changed with the recent church sex abuse scandal. Virtus' Protecting God's Children program, started in 2001, is now used at the Rockford and Joliet dioceses, as well as the Chicago Archdiocese.
   "For the past 15 or 20 years we as a society have dealt with child sexual abuse by saying, 'Say no, run away and tell somebody'," Doty said. "The piece that was missing was that we now identify steps to take to prevent abuse."
   But those steps don't always work, Doty said, and when a reporter gets an inkling abuse has taken place, they must act. "When in doubt, report," Doty said. #
• With one voice -- Masses mourn loss of parishes.
   Boston Globe, www.boston.com/news/local/articles/2004/08/16/with_one_voice , By Michael Paulson, August 16, 2004
   BOSTON (MA): In an unusual public celebration of Mass by people protesting the leadership of the Catholic Church, about 2,000 people gathered on Boston Common yesterday to demonstrate through collective worship their unhappiness with the management of the Boston Archdiocese.
   The two-hour, Voice of the Faithful-organized Mass, which was neither authorized nor condemned by archdiocesan officials, was meant, organizers said, to offer a show of strength by parishioners at some of the 82 parishes slated for closure this year by Archbishop Sean P. O'Malley.
   Four priests who lead parishes targeted for closure officiated at the Mass, and along a walkway organizers had arrayed small white placards bearing the names of the closing parishes meant to evoke tombstones: St. Michael, Lynn; Mary Immaculate of Lourdes, Newton; Blessed Kateri Tekakwitha, Plymouth, and so on. [Posted by Kathy Shaw at 08:37 AM]
////////// End of Clergy Sex Abuse Tracker www.ncrnews.org/abuse , Mon August 16, 2004
Abuse Chronology: http://www.multiline.com.au/~johnm/ethics/ethcont93.htm
• Alleged sex offender found dead. [1970-82] -- Anglican. Australia flag; Aust. Nat. Flag Assn. 
   The Australian, http://www.theaustralian.news.com.au/common/story_page/0,5744,1045 9809%255E1702,00.html ; August 16, 2004
   ADELAIDE: A former leader of the Church of England Boys Society who was charged with sex offences had been found dead, South Australian police said today.
   The 69-year-old man, from Adelaide's western suburbs, was due to face the Adelaide Magistrates Court today on 14 counts of indecent assault.
   A police spokesman said the man was found dead yesterday.
   It was understood the man took his own life. There were no suspicious circumstances, the spokesman said.
   The sex offences were allegedly committed between 1970 and 1982, on six victims aged between 12 and 16 years.
   The man was one of 17 people charged by SA's police pedophile taskforce that was established last year to investigate child sex abuse within the Anglican Church in Adelaide, but widened to include other community groups. # (By courtesy of MAKO) [Aug 16, 04 ]
Abuse Chronology: http://www.multiline.com.au/~johnm/ethics/ethcont93.htm
#### Clergy Sex Abuse Tracker, www.ncrnews.org/abuse, Tue August 17, 2004 edition follows:-
• 'Miracle babies' seized in Kenya [2004] -- evangelical. Kenya flag; Mooney's MiniFlags  Britain flag; Mooney's MiniFlags 
   BBC News, http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/africa/3572742.stm , 10:44 GMT, Tuesday, 17 August, 2004,
   KENYA: Police in Kenya have seized 11 "miracle babies" for DNA tests after allegations of child trafficking.
   The children were picked up at the home of a couple who claim to be their parents in the capital, Nairobi.
   UK-based evangelical pastor Archbishop Gilbert Deya claims to be able to make post-menopausal or infertile women pregnant by exorcising their demons.
   But some children's charities say his actions are a front for baby trafficking. [Posted by Kathy Shaw at 06:33 PM]
• Former youth pastor on trial for second-degree statutory sodomy [2002 Horton] -- girl. Assembly of God. U.S.A. flag; Mooney's MiniFlags 
   The Daily Journal, www.mydjconnection.com/articles/2004/08/17/community/news5.txt , Tuesday, August 17, 2004
   FARMINGTON (MO) - A St. Francois County jury will begin listening to the second day of testimony in a trial involving a former youth pastor accused of inappropriately touching a 14-year-old girl.
   Patrick Horton, 33, of Desloge, a former part-time youth pastor at Harvest Assembly of God Church and a former organizer of Liberty Outreach's Fire Escape Youth Center in Park Hills, has been charged with second-degree statutory sodomy.
   On the first day of the trial, jurors heard testimony from five state witnesses and two defense witnesses. The trial was set to resume at 8:30 this morning before Circuit Court Judge Sandra Martinez.
   Among the witnesses who testified was the alleged victim, now 16, who testified about a fund raiser she participated in Aug. 17, 2002 for the former Fire Escape Youth Center.
   The girl said Horton, who gave her a ride to the center, asked her more than once, "What would you do for $5?"
• Diocese faces 20th sex abuse lawsuit [1960s Apt] -- boy.
   Sioux City Journal, www.siouxcityjournal.com/articles/2004/08/17/news/local/8e37a3f5 acff68d 886256 ef300192608.txt ; By Nick Hytrek, Journal staff writer, Aug 17, 2004
   IOWA: The 20th sexual abuse lawsuit filed against the Catholic Diocese of Sioux City is the first to allege abuse by a second priest.
   The lawsuit, filed Monday in Woodbury County District Court, alleges that the Rev. Everett Apt sexually abused William Fisher in the early 1960s while Apt served the parish in Alvord, Iowa. A former altar boy, Fisher alleges Apt committed "repeated, offensive and inappropriate sexual acts of sexual contact" with him when he was alone with Apt.
   The lawsuit claims that the diocese knew Apt had sexual contact with children as early as 1950, but concealed his actions and continued to assign him to parishes. The diocese transferred Apt to a new parish whenever it learned his behavior might become public, the lawsuit said. Apt died in 1985.
   Fisher is suing the diocese for negligent supervision and conspiracy. He said his damages exceed $30,000.
   As a result of the alleged sexual abuse, Fisher said he continues to suffer mental anguish, pain and suffering and loss of enjoyment of life. In the suit, Fisher said his pain and humiliation was renewed on July 27 after he attended a funeral in Larchwood, Iowa, and was told by a priest that he was not welcome on church property because he was complaining of sexual abuse by a priest.
• Priest passes up hearing [2004 Nocinski] -- Franciscan, 2500 pornographic images.
   Green Bay Press-Gazette www.greenbaypressgazette.com/news/archive/local_17366866. shtml , By Andy Nelesen, anelesen@greenbaypressgazette.com , Posted Aug. 17, 2004
   WISCONSIN: A 63-year-old Franciscan priest waived his right to a preliminary hearing on Monday.
   Rudolph Stefan Nocinski was arrested in June and faces one felony count of possession of child pornography after a computer technician found pornographic images on Nocinski's computer while it was in for repair.
   A search of Nocinski's computer and his home in the religious order's Pulaski friary found more than 2,500 pornographic images involving children between the ages of 10 and 17, 33 VHS tapes and DVDs and e-mail messages in which Nocinski asked others for images of young boys.
• Diocese To Begin Educational Program About Sexual Abuse
   WAVE, www.wave3.com/Global/story.asp?S=2186777&nav=0RZFPxvF , 6 p.m., August 17th, 2004
   LOUISVILLE, (KY) The Roman Catholic Diocese of Covington will begin the new school year by implementing a "safe environment" program to educate students and parents about sexual abuse.
   The program was approved by Bishop Roger Foys last month. It meets a requirement of the Charter for the Protection of Children and Young People adopted by American bishops in 2002.
   The diocese is currently engaged in a mediation process to settle the nation's first class-action lawsuit over claims of molestation by priests. The suit, which accuses the diocese of mishandling such allegations, covers victims from the last 50 years.
   The "safe environment" policy requires schools and parish-based religious educational programs to educate all parents and students in preschool through 12th grade. The diocese has about 12-thousand-400 students in its 30 elementary schools and nine high schools.
• Magdalenes among top 10 most anti-Catholic films Northern Ireland flag; Mooney's MiniFlags  U.S.A. flag; Mooney's MiniFlags 
   Belfast Telegraph, www.belfasttelegraph.co.uk/lifestyle/film_tv/story.jsp?story=552486 , By David Quinn, August 17, 2004
   UNITED STATES: The controversial award-winning movie, The Magdalene Sisters, which is set in an institution for "errant" young women run by Irish nuns, has been named in a list of the 10 most anti-Catholic films ever by a panel in the United States.
   The panel, which is inter-religious, included the Jewish film critic, Michael Medved, and Dr Philip Jenkins, an Anglican professor of religious studies at Pennsylvania State University.
   The Magdalene Sisters, which proved popular with cinema audiences when it went on release here in 2002, ranked at number two on their list.
   The film focuses on the severe punishments meted out to four girls, or Magdalenes, who were sent to the institutions run by the nuns where they worked in the laundries and did "penance for their sins".
   The panel was selected by two US Catholic publications, including the National Catholic Register.
• Four at Virginia church camp charged with sexual abuse [2004] -- Baptists. U.S.A. flag; Mooney's MiniFlags 
   The Virginian-Pilot, http://home.hamptonroads.com/stories/story.cfm?story=74456&ran= 204288 , Associated Press, © August 17, 2004
   GAINESVILLE (VA) -- Two counselors and two campers at a church-run summer camp were due in court today on charges of sexual abuse.
   Prince William County police said the incidents occurred during the week of July 18 at the Northern Virginia Baptist Center. Investigators say what started out as roughhousing and horseplay between male counselors and male campers escalated into sexual assaults.
   "One of the kids from the camp ... told his parents" after leaving the camp, said Officer Dennis Mangan, a police spokesman.
   Investigators believe a 17-year-old counselor, a 15-year-old counselor and two 12-year-old campers assaulted three campers while others watched. The victims are 10, 11 and 12. A 7-year-old camper told investigators he was locked in a room when he tried to run for help.
   The four suspects are being held in a juvenile detention center.
• Former Catholic priest Michael Wempe free while awaiting trial [1990s]
   The Tribune, www.sanluisobispo.com/mld/sanluisobispo/news/politics/9419887.htm , Associated Press, Posted on Tue, Aug. 17, 2004
   LOS ANGELES (CA) - A retired Roman Catholic priest who had been jailed since September on charges that he molested a boy in the 1990s is free on bond while awaiting trial.
   Michael Wempe was released from jail Saturday, a day after his bail was reduced from $500,000 to $100,000, authorities said.
   Superior Court Judge Samuel Mayerson ordered the 64-year-old Wempe to wear an electronic tracking device and avoid children under 18 unless they are accompanied by an adult.
   Wempe, who had been living at a Seal Beach retirement home with his mother, will be allowed to shop for groceries and attend medical appointments, court hearings and meetings with attorneys, the judge said.
   The retired priest also will be permitted to attend church, but as a parishioner.
• 18 priests named in settlement [Boudreau, Dranka, O'Malley ++] -- 20 others yet to be named publicly.
   The Republican, www.masslive.com/springfield/republican/index.ssf?/base/news-7/10927348 01304750.xml ; By BILL ZAJAC, wzajac@repub.com , Tuesday, August 17, 2004
   SPRINGFIELD (MA) -- The 45 people who agreed to a settlement with the Roman Catholic Diocese of Springfield after alleging clergy sex abuse had made claims against 18 priests, including three who previously had not been publicly identified as facing accusations.
   The Revs. Paul T. Boudreau, Eugene Dranka and Thomas F. O'Malley were listed among the 18 priests who had allegations made against them. Dranka and O'Malley are deceased. Boudreau has denied any wrongdoing.
   The names of the 18 were released recently by Greenfield lawyer John J. Stobierski, who represents the 45 people who Aug. 5 agreed to settle their claims for about $7.5 million. Twenty or so other claimants represented by other lawyers are awaiting word from the diocese on the method in which their claims may be settled.
   Although the diocese refused to comment about the 18 priests and whether previous allegations have been made against them, Stobierski said identifying accused priests is consistent with the policy U.S. bishops established in Dallas two years ago. [...]
   "To the survivors, each one of these people sat in silence for years believing they were the only one molested and that it was their fault. Each survivors desires to have the name of their abuser made public to give assurance and comfort to other victims who are still suffering in silence," Stobierski said.
   The 14 others who were accused of sexual abuse by the 45 claimants are Richard R. Lavigne and Ronald Malboeuf, who have both been defrocked, and the Revs. John J. Bonzagni, John Corbin, Donald V. Dube, Clarence Forand, Alfred Graves, E. Karl Huller, Roy Jenness, Edward M. Kennedy, John A. Koonz, Francis P. Lavelle, Richard F. Meehan and David Welch. [...]
   Bonzagni is the only priest of the 18 who remains in ministry. He is assigned to St. Vincent de Paul Parish in Lenoxdale. He previously denied a woman's allegation that he had abused her.  . . . [Emphasis added]
• Twentieth abuse lawsuit filed against Sioux City diocese [Apt] - RCC. Altar boy.
   WQAD, www.wqad.com/Global/story.asp?S=2182990 , August 17, 2004
   SIOUX CITY, Iowa: A 20th sexual abuse lawsuit has been filed against the Roman Catholic Diocese of Sioux City, but the first one that did not name the Reverend George McFadden as the abuser.
   The latest lawsuit, filed yesterday in Woodbury County District Court, alleges that the Reverend Everett Apt sexually abused a man who was an altar boy in the early 1960s while Apt served the parish in Alvord.
   The former altar boy, alleges Apt committed "repeated, offensive and inappropriate sexual acts of sexual contact" with him when he was alone with the priest.
• Diocese settlement -- 18 priests, 45 victims, $US 7m settled.
   Republican, www.masslive.com/hampfrank/republican/index.ssf?/base/news- 0/109275128 1111930.xml , Tuesday, August 17, 2004
   SPRINGFIELD (MA): The following are the 18 priests who faced sexual abuse allegations by 45 people who reached an agreement Aug. 5 to settle claims with the Roman Catholic Diocese of Springfield for more than $7 million. The number of people who accused each priest is in parentheses followed by the status of the priest:
   The Rev. Paul T. Boudreau (1) abandoned priesthood
   The Rev. John Corbin (1) abandoned priesthood
   The Rev. Eugene Dranka (2) deceased
   The Rev. Donald V. Dube (1) deceased
   The Rev. Clarence Forand (1) retired
   The Rev. Alfred Graves (1) removed from all ministry
   The Rev. E. Karl Huller (2) deceased
   The Rev. Roy Jenness (1) deceased
   The Rev. Edward M. Kennedy (1) removed from all ministry
   The Rev. John A. Koonz (3) removed from all ministry
   The Rev. Francis P. Lavelle (2) removed from all ministry
   Richard R. Lavigne (24) defrocked
   Ronald Malboeuf (2) defrocked
   The Rev. Richard F. Meehan (2) removed from all ministry
   The Rev. Thomas F. O'Malley (1) deceased
   The Rev. David Welch (1) deceased
   The identity of one priest is pending.
• Three previously unidentified priests named in settlement
   Telegram & Gazette www.telegram.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20040817/APN/4081 70756 , The Associated Press, Tuesday, August 17, 2004
   SPRINGFIELD, Mass. - Three of the priests named in a $7 million settlement between the Springfield Diocese and alleged victims of clergy sex abuse were not publicly identified by church officials prior to the settlement.
   The revs. Paul T. Boudreau, Eugene Dranka and Thomas F. O'Malley were listed among 18 priests who were accused of sexual abuse, The Republican newspaper reported Tuesday. Dranka and O'Malley are dead, and Boudreau has denied any wrongdoing.
   Mark Dupont, a spokesman for the diocese, refused Tuesday to comment on why the diocese hadn't previously named the three priests.
   But John Stobierski, the Greenfield attorney representing 45 people who agreed to settle their sex abuse claims against the diocese, said identifying the accused priests is consistent with a policy established in Dallas two years ago by a conference of U.S. bishops.
   "The Dallas norms set forth the fact that these settlements will not be done in secret any longer. To that end, my clients want the names of priests who allegedly abused them made public," Stobierski said. [Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:36 AM]
////////// End of Clergy Sex Abuse Tracker www.ncrnews.org/abuse , Tue August 17, 2004
Abuse Chronology: http://www.multiline.com.au/~johnm/ethics/ethcont93.htm
#### Clergy Sex Abuse Tracker, www.ncrnews.org/abuse, Wed August 18, 2004 edition follows:-
• Sex scandals, celibacy blamed for fall in vocations Ireland flag; Mooney's MiniFlags 
   Ireland Online, http://breakingnews.iol.ie/news/iestory.asp?j=29520339336&p=z95zx 339638&n=29520339716 ; By Catherine Shanahan, Aug 19, 2004
   IRELAND: Sex scandals and celibacy are the two main reasons why people are not entering the priesthood, according to the preliminary findings of a survey.
   Churchgoers in the 10 Dublin parishes also cited a belief that God has been forgotten and a desire for economic prosperity as a reason for a fall in vocations.
   Respondents to the survey, carried out by the Dublin diocese vocations office, believed celibacy did not "make sense to people".
   A fear of commitment as well as lack of encouragement from parents were further deterrents to a life of the cloth. Of the 750 people who responded to the survey, 143 said peer pressure contributed to the fall in vocations; 137 mentioned poor religious education; 134 blamed the media; and 46 said because Mass was celebrated badly.
   When asked if they thought the ministry of priesthood was important, the majority of all age groups said 'yes'. As many as 233 men and 408 women said they felt the life of a priest was very worthwhile and 580 people said, if a family member considered becoming a priest or joining a religious order, they would support them. [Posted by Kathy Shaw at 10:12 PM]
• Former priest pleads guilty to sex charges [1960s Houston] -- boys, multiple offender, suspended sentence. Canada flag; Mooney's MiniFlags 
   CANADA CBC, http://winnipeg.cbc.ca/regional/servlet/View?filename=mb_priest 20040818 , Aug 18 2004
   INUVIK, N.W.T. - A former priest in Carman has pleaded guilty to sex crimes against three boys dating back to the early 1960s.
   Martin Houston, 67, was charged with sexually assaulting two boys in his care and trying to assault another while he was a supervisor at the now-infamous Grollier Hall residential school in Inuvik, N.W.T. He was given a suspended sentence and three years' probation.
   This is the second time Houston has faced sex charges related to his two years as a supervisor of a boys' dormitory at Grollier Hall. In 1962, he pleaded guilty to assaulting five boys.
   He was declared a dangerous sexual offender and served nine years before being released.
   In 1990, Houston was ordained by the Archdiocese of St. Boniface. He was a priest in Carman at Our Lady of Mount Carmel until 2002, when he resigned after news of his past came to light.
• Hearing to determine whether 1968 drowning lawsuit will proceed [1968 Quinn] U.S.A. flag; Mooney's MiniFlags 
   Newsday, www.newsday.com/news/local/wire/ny-bc-ny--drowninglawsuit0818aug 18,0,979900.story?coll=ny-ap-regional-wire ; By WILLIAM KATES, Associated Press Writer, August 18, 2004
   SYRACUSE, N.Y. -- A judge will hold a fact-finding hearing to determine whether a $150 million lawsuit can proceed against a Catholic priest accused of negligence in the 1968 drowning death of a young boy, the family's attorney said Wednesday.
   No date has been set for the hearing before state Supreme Court Justice Robert Julian, said attorney Frank Policelli.
   The lawsuit was filed in June against the Rev. James Quinn and the Syracuse Catholic Diocese by the victim's mother, Anna Marie Piacentino.
   Piacentino's 12-year-old son, Albert, drowned while on a church picnic for altar boys from St. Agnes Roman Catholic Church in Utica. The family believes new evidence shows Quinn, then the assistant pastor at St. Agnes, was supposed to be supervising the outing but that he was not present when Albert drowned as he swam with the other boys.
   It was not until last year that Piacentino said she learned that Quinn might not have been present when her son died. Quinn has denied any wrongdoing.
• Catholic Schools To Teach Students Difference Between 'Good' And 'Bad' Touching
   WAVE, www.wave3.com/Global/story.asp?S=2192292&nav=0RZFQ0kj , By David McArthur, 6 p.m., August 18th, 2004
   LOUISVILLE, (KY) -- Louisville Catholic students are returning to school with a new item on their curriculum as a result of the fallout from last year's sex abuse crisis settlement when $25 million was awarded to 240 victims. As WAVE 3's David McArthur reports, the church has paid for abuses from decades ago and is now investing in education for future prevention.
   On day one at Holy Trinity Catholic School, the staff sets the tone for another year of academics. But among the supplies and textbooks, one new lesson plan will teach the difference between good touching and bad touching.
   Catholic Schools Superintendent Leisa Speer says the program will expand on what many people already know intuitively. "We all have that internal sensor, that tells us 'uh-oh, this just doesn't seem right.'"
• Diocese targeting sex abuse
   Kentucky Post, www.kypost.com/2004/08/18/dioc081804.html , By Peggy Kreimer, Post staff reporter, Aug 18, 2004
   COVINGTON (KY): The Diocese of Covington is opening its school year with programs to educate students and parents about sexual abuse.
   The programs are part of the "Charter for the Protection of Children and Young People" that American Catholic bishops adopted in 2002 as part of their response to the sex abuse scandal in the Catholic Church.
   The Diocese of Covington is in the midst of the country's first class-action lawsuit that alleges a widespread cover-up of abuse by diocesan officials. That suit is scheduled for trial in January, but parties in the suit are pursuing mediation.
   Plaintiffs' attorneys in the suit claim to have hundreds of victims with claims against more than 50 priests. The decision to implement the in-school education programs are not a response to the suit, said Lawrence Bowman, director of Catholic Education for the 14-county Diocese of Covington
• Archdiocese is sued over alleged abuse [1970s McNulty] -- Society of Mary.
   Express-News, www.mysanantonio.com/news/metro/stories/MYSA081704.5B. priest lawsuit. f61cb73.html , by J. Michael Parker, Aug/17/2004
   SAN ANTONIO (TX): A former employee at two area Catholic parishes is suing the Society of Mary and the Archdiocese of San Antonio for an undetermined amount of money, claiming a priest sexually abused her for three years in the 1970s.
   Cynthia Anne Tejeda, 42, filed the suit last Friday, saying Father Patrick McNulty, a Society of Mary priest and associate pastor of Holy Rosary Parish who died in 1984, repeatedly engaged in inappropriate sexual contact.
   "In the tender years of my adolescence, I was sexually exploited, abused, betrayed, abandoned and traumatized," Tejeda said at a Monday news conference. Brother Stephen Glodek, provincial superior of the Society of Mary, said the province paid for Tejeda's medical treatment, but balked at her demand that it finance her continued education for a master's degree.
   "Since learning of her allegations in 2000, we've acted in good faith and attempted to provide support for Cindy - inpatient and outpatient therapy, medication and educational expenses for the past two years. We had a cap, and she reached that in May 2004," he said.
   Tejeda said she was 12 when the abuse began in 1974, and that she first disclosed the abuse in 1977 to Father David Fleming, then assistant provincial of the Society of Mary's St. Louis Province. McNulty remained at Holy Rosary until 1980 and served at Our Lady of Guadalupe Parish in Helotes from 1980 to 1982. He died at a Marianist facility in Gilville, Wis., in 1984.
• Four who claim sexual abuse demonstrate at nuns meeting
   Newsday, www.newsday.com/news/local/wire/ny-bc-ct--nunabuse0818aug18,0,4741806. story?coll=ny-ap-regional-wire , By BOBBY ROSS JR., AP Religion Writer, August 18, 2004
   FORT WORTH, Texas -- Four adults who claim they were sexually abused by nuns demonstrated Wednesday outside a convention center where a national organization of nuns will meet this weekend.
   The alleged victims, organized by the Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests, known as SNAP, said they hoped to call attention to molestations by Catholic sisters and persuade the nuns to let them speak at their national meeting.
   They carried posters with messages such as "Help us heal," "No more suicides" and "We ask for bread and we're given a stone."
   Among those protesting were Landa Mauriello-Vernon, SNAP's Connecticut director, who has a lawsuit pending against a nun and the Catholic school she attended in New England. She said she lost friends and family when she was abused.
   "And when she sexually abused me, I lost my dignity," she said.
   The sexual abuse crisis in the Roman Catholic Church has focused primarily on molestation of priests. SNAP says the focus on priests has made those abused by nuns feel isolated and ignored.
   Steve Theisen, a 52-year-old member of SNAP from Hudson, Iowa, said a nun taught him how to kiss in fourth grade. He said he has dealt with decades of guilt because he was taught that nuns were married to the church.
• Milwaukee Preacher Gets Sentence For Exorcism [2003 Hemphill] -- death.
   Local6.com ; www.local6.com/news/3660562/detail.html , August 17, 2004
   MILWAUKEE (WI) -- A Milwaukee pastor was given a 2 1/2 year prison sentence in an exorcism that caused the death of an 8-year-old Milwaukee boy.
   Prosecutors say Ray Hemphill laid on Terrance Cottrell's chest for at least an hour while trying to release "demons" from him, before the boy died last August.
   A Milwaukee County jury found Hemphill guilty of felony child abuse in the death of Cottrell, who was autistic.
   Judge Jean DiMotto also sentenced Hemphill to 7˝ years of extended supervision.
   Hemphill also has to pay $1,200 in restitution, and the judge ordered him not perform any exorcisms unless he receives extensive training.
   "You call it an accident, but it was your unreasonable and reckless conduct that caused this child to die," DiMotto said.
• Convicted priest may face new charges [Ridsdale] Australia flag; Aust. Nat. Flag Assn. 
   The Age, www.theage.com.au/articles/2004/08/18/1092765013605.html , By Ian Munro, August 19, 2004
   AUSTRALIA: Convicted pedophile Gerald Francis Ridsdale may face new charges after the Director of Public Prosecutions this week decided to reconsider a decision not to prosecute new allegations.
   Nine more victims have filed complaints against Ridsdale, a former priest, since he was convicted in 1994 on 46 charges of sexual abuse throughout central and western Victoria.
   The DPP, Paul Coghlan, QC, has offered to meet victims who have come forward since the conviction, and said he would reconsider prosecuting Ridsdale, 70, over their allegations.
   Attorney-General Rob Hulls welcomed Mr Coghlan's review, which follows comments by Premier Steve Bracks encouraging victims to come forward. Mr Bracks said he hoped victims could have their day in court.
   In a letter to Mr Hulls, Mr Coghlan said the decision not to prosecute was based on the fact that the new allegations could have been heard at the original trial. Responding to what he called "disquiet in the community", Mr Coghlan said it was important the public have confidence in the justice system.
• Child abuse scheme to cover 30 more centres Ireland, Republic, flag; Mooney's MiniFlags 
   One in Four organisation, http://oneinfour.org/news/news2004/scheme ,
   IRELAND: Thirty institutions are set to be added to the Government's child abuse compensation scheme in a move which will expose the State to further compensation claims.
   Department of Education officials have identified several mother- and-baby homes, special-needs schools and institutions for young offenders in which abuse claims have been made.
   It is understood the institutions due to come under the redress board's remit include the Finglas Child and Adolescent Centre, the Holy Family School of Renmore, Co Galway, and a number of mother-and-baby homes.
   St Ita's psychiatric hospital, Portrane, Co Dublin, and St Luke's psychiatric hospital in Clonmel, Co Tipperary, are also likely to be included.
• Predator Alert: Alert Sex Offender To Be Released From Prison [1970s Holley] -- eight boys.
   Team Amber Alert News, www.teamamberalert.net/news/modules.php?name=News& file=article&sid=3434
   NEW MEXICO: From Santa Fe to Alamogordo, residents are outraged that a convicted pedophile priest is scheduled to be released from prison years before actually serving his sentence.
   As Mark Horner found now the governor says that priest may want to cancel his plans. Father David Holley sent to prison in 1993 for molesting eight boys back in the 70's. His sentence fifty-five to two hundred seventy-five years.
   "I mean, that implies to our victims, that he's going to die in prison. And to have this man reappear eleven years later with no notification is utterly devastating." This week Kasa Fox 2 uncovered a parole board decision to grant Holley parole.
   Prompting this response from the governor's office expressing "outrage" and a violation of public trust. And late Wednesday afternoon a spokesperson for the governor stated a new hearing will be held to reconsider the parole board's decision.
   Bill Richardson states "this sex offender was convicted, and I, like most New Mexicans, expect him to remain behind bars." Most disturbing for victims and others associated with the case a violation of law victims were never notified about Holley's parole hearing held earlier this year.
   I mean, this thin is replete with errors and omissions. I'm beginning to think that someone did something intentional in this case.
   No department in New Mexico can be this incompetent." Holley's been seeking parole for some time now last year he was shot down. Back then the parole board gave seven specific reasons why he should remain in prison.
   Team Amber Alert Ask that residents as Well as victims express their outrage on this very serious sex offender being released.
• More claim abuse at school for deaf [Sisters of St. Joseph]
   Boston Herald, http://news.bostonherald.com/localRegional/view.bg?articleid=40340 , By Franci Richardson, Wednesday, August 18, 2004
   RANDOLPH (MA): As a young girl at the Boston School for the Deaf, Penny Braddock was one of several classmates forced to drink another's urine, she said yesterday.
   "I held my breath and swallowed it," said Braddock, 53, of Peabody who attended the Randolph school for the hearing impaired from 1955 to 1967. "There was nothing else I could do. It was really disgusting."
   The 99-page civil complaint that attorney Mitchell Garabedian filed yesterday at Suffolk Superior Court alleges that 36 nuns, teachers and a priest at the school sexually and physically abused nine former students, including Braddock.
   Garabedian filed a complaint in May on behalf of another nine alleged victims.
   "These allegations are disturbing, demeaning and disgusting," Garabedian said. "There's some sort of sadism going on here. These children who can't speak and can't hear were tortured and tormented."
   The Sisters of St. Joseph of Boston released a statement yesterday saying that the allegations have left them "surprised and disheartened." They have, however, launched an independent investigation into the charges.
• "I am Joseph, your brother."
   Catholic World News, www.cwnews.com/offtherecord/offtherecord.cfm?task=single display&recnum=2090 , Posted by "Diogenes", Off the Record: Commentary from the News Room, 10:17 PM EST, Aug. 17, 2004
   UNITED STATES: Psychotherapist Richard Sipe, a frequent commentator on sexual misconduct by Catholic clergy, gave an address at a LinkUp conference last year in which he re-opened the controversy surrounding the late archbishop of Chicago (note: Bernardin was earlier Archbishop of Cincinnati; the Josephinum is a seminary in Columbus, Ohio):
A sad, and as yet unsolved, chapter of the sexual abuse saga in the United States is the story of Cardinal Joseph Bernardin. This man probably did die a saint, as his close friends attest. Without doubt, he did many wonderful things for the Church in America.
   In the media flurry that surrounded the allegation of sexual abuse, an impertinent reporter asked the Cardinal, "Are you living a sexually active life?" A simple "no" would have been sufficient. But the Cardinal said, "I am sixty-five years old, and I have always lived a chaste and celibate life."
   However defensible in the arena of public assault, I knew that the statement was not unassailably true. Years before, several priests who were associates of Bernardin prior to his move to Chicago revealed that they had "partied" together; they talked about their visits to the Josephinum to socialize with seminarians.
   It is a fact that Bernardin's accuser did not ever retract his allegations of abuse by anyone's account other than Bernardin's. If, as reported, three million dollars were paid in handling the scandal, certainly there are still informed people in Chicago who know at least part of the story. And the story is complex. It holds repercussions far beyond Chicago and one allegation.
   I speak of this only as an example -- a clue -- to a mystery. This should not be sensational. Rather, it should be an occasion for the Church to divine an important pattern of its sexual operation.
   While the verbs "partied" and "socialize" are ambiguous, Sipe makes it clear that he is using them to confute Bernardin's claim to have lived a chaste and celibate life; in context, they allege homosexual dalliance of some sort. Why is this significant? Because unlike most of Bernardin's detractors, Sipe has impeccable liberal credentials; he can't be dismissed as a right-wing muckraker -- indeed, he aligns himself with those who regard Bernardin as a saint. Moreover, Sipe claims to have had knowledge of his misbehavior antecedent to the public accusations against Bernardin, and this directly from the priests who misbehaved in his company. Any impartial student of the controversy would have to take Sipe's evidence seriously.
   It is almost impossible to over-estimate the importance of Cardinal Bernardin to the U.S. Catholic Church; on that point his critics and admirers are unanimous. Like Bismarck or Stalin or Richard Daley, he created and presided over a bureaucracy whose impersonality became his personal tool, and the way the USCCB does business bears his stamp to this day.
   What is the business of the USCCB? It does two things superlatively well: it foils or neutralizes Roman initiatives (disciplinary, educative, liturgical) aimed at the U.S., and it diffuses -- and thus eliminates -- episcopal accountability. The Marshall seminary visitation and the Vatican intervention against Hunthausen are examples of the first; the Women's Pastoral and the subterfuge behind The Many Faces of AIDS are examples of the second. The reflexive mendacity by which the episcopal apparat turned sex abuse crimes into a sex abuse cover-up can be attributed in equal measure to both.
   And that is why credible evidence of Bernardin's unacknowledged appetites is important to the puzzle -- "a clue," as Sipe says, "to a mystery."
• More join abuse suit against nuns [Sisters of St. Joseph]
   Boston Globe, www.boston.com/news/local/massachusetts/articles/2004/08/18/more_join_ abuse_ suit_against_nuns ; By Emily Anthes, Globe Correspondent, August 18, 2004
   RANDOLPH (MA): As a child at the Boston School for the Deaf from 1955 to 1967, Penny Braddock couldn't hear, but she could see.
   When she was about 9 years old, she saw a nun follow a young girl into the bathroom and emerge with a metal bowl filled with urine, she said through a sign-language interpreter yesterday. She saw the nun pour it into a brown bottle. And later, the nun made all the girls line up and forced them to drink spoonfuls from the bottle, Braddock said.
   "I went ahead, I held my breath, and I swallowed it down," she said. "There was nothing else I could do. It was disgusting. I would never do that to my children."
   Braddock, who now lives in Peabody, said that she still doesn't understand the nun's actions and that the girls had done nothing to merit punishment. She was one of several new plaintiffs in a lawsuit against the Sisters of St. Joseph who said they are still struggling to comprehend the reasons for the physical and sexual abuse they say they suffered at the now-defunct school.
   The Boston School for the Deaf, which was run by the nuns until 1994, was a residential facility in Randolph for students with hearing or speech impairments.
   The Rev. Christopher Coyne, a spokesman for the Archdiocese of Boston, said the school was not under the direct supervision of the archdiocese.
• Covington Diocese To Begin Sex Abuse Awareness Program
   WCPO, www.wcpo.com/news/2004/local/08/17/covdiocese.html , Reported by: A.P., Web produced by: Neil Relyea, Photographed by: 9News, 10:24:54 PM, Aug/17/04
   COVINGTON (KY): The Roman Catholic Diocese of Covington will begin the new school year by implementing a "safe environment" program to educate students and parents about sexual abuse.
   The program was approved by Bishop Roger Foys last month. It meets a requirement of the Charter for the Protection of Children and Young People adopted by American bishops in 2002.
   The diocese is currently engaged in a mediation process to settle the nation's first class-action lawsuit over claims of molestation by priests.
   The suit, which accuses the diocese of mishandling such allegations, covers victims from the last 50 years.
   The "safe environment" policy requires schools and parish-based religious educational programs to educate all parents and students in preschool through 12th grade.
• Dioceses Accused of Moving Assets to Avoid Paying Sex-Abuse Claims
   Los Angeles Times, www.latimes.com/news/local/la-me-priests18aug18,1,3988575.story?coll=la-headlines-california ; By Jean Guccione, Aug 18, 2004
   CALIFORNIA: The Roman Catholic bishop of Stockton has transferred title to the Cathedral of the Annunciation and 41 other church properties, triggering a court fight over whether people who allege they were abused by priests should be able to claim the land as damages.
   Hayward, Calif., lawyer Rick Simons accused the diocese Tuesday of "shuffling and hiding assets the way they shuffled and hid molester priests."
   Attorney Paul Balestracci, who represents the Diocese of Stockton, denied the allegation. But he acknowledged in an interview that the church considered its potential liability in the four lawsuits then pending against it when the transfers were made.
   The bishop still controls various church assets, including the chancery and insurance policies, Balestracci said.
   Elsewhere, lawyers are looking into the transfer of $30 million worth of property within the Diocese of San Diego, and the creation of at least two new corporations within the Diocese of Orange.
   "We are concerned that what we see in Stockton might be part of a systemic effort throughout the state to avoid the claims of the victims by transferring, obscuring or failing to disclose assets," said Venus Soltan, a Costa Mesa lawyer whose clients are suing dioceses throughout the state for allegedly failing to protect them from predatory priests.
• Church crisis hasn't changed donation trends, survey shows
   Fox 11, www.fox11az.com/news/local/stories/KMSB-20040817-dsbp-survey.88e2b3a3. html , By Stephanie Innes / Arizona Daily Star, 05:27 PM MST, Tuesday, August 17, 2004
   UNITED STATES: A new survey about Catholic giving indicates that the majority of American Catholics have not changed their donation patterns, even in the wake of a national crisis over clergy sexual abuse and multi-million-dollar settlements to abuse victims.
   The results of the University of Notre Dame survey, which also says that 6 percent of Catholics have increased their giving since the national scandal arose in 2002, are consistent with financial reports from the Roman Catholic Diocese of Tucson, which is weighing filing for bankruptcy while facing 20 pending lawsuits over allegations of priests sexually abusing children.
   In the Tucson diocese, plate collections are steady and, through Monday, this year's Annual Catholic Appeal has reached a record $3.3 million - up $200,000 from a goal of $3.1 million.
   "Sometimes, a time of crisis can strengthen a person's faith. My prayer is that this is a time of spiritual renewal for Catholic priests and for us as God's people," said the Rev. Liam Leahyof St. Mark the Evangelist Catholic Church, on Tucson's Northwest Side.
• Victims group plans to push clergy abuse issue with candidate
   Duluth News Tribune, www.duluthsuperior.com/mld/duluthsuperior/news/politics/ 9426781.htm , Associated Press
   MILWAUKEE (WI): Advocates for victims of sexual abuse by priests vowed Tuesday night to push the issue with congressional candidate Matt Flynn - a lawyer who represented the Catholic Archdiocese of Milwaukee in some abuse cases.
   Peter Isely, a founding member of the Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests [SNAP] and the group's Midwest regional director, said his group wants Flynn to respond to its concerns about his role in defending accused priests and the archdiocese.
   "We're upset that he has not met with us," Isely said.
   He said the group would send Flynn a letter seeking a meeting and also would try to meet with other candidates in the race for the Milwaukee area's 4th District congressional seat. Flynn is running in the Democratic primary Sept. 14.
   "We're going to look at neighborhoods in the district that have had priest sex predators, and we'll target and leaflet those neighborhoods with our concerns," Isely said.
   The group also will raise the issue at candidate forums, he said.
• Nonprofits tap into ChoicePoint's data
   The Atlanta Journal-Constitution, www.ajc.com/news/content/business/0804/18choice. html , By MARY LOU PICKEL, Aug/18/04
   ATLANTA (GA): The Catholic Church wants volunteers to confess to their past before they work with children. And just in case memory fails, the church will run a background check.
   After the priest pedophilia scandal rocked the church two years ago, 40 Catholic dioceses, including the Archdiocese of Atlanta, turned to Alpharetta-based ChoicePoint to screen volunteers. The Atlanta archdiocese runs checks not only on volunteers who work with children but also on those who work with the elderly or the disabled.
   The church's volunteer screens add to what ChoicePoint, an industry leader in data aggregation and credential verification, already was doing for other nonprofits, such as the Boy Scouts. In this year alone, ChoicePoint expects to screen more than a million volunteers nationwide for more than 6,500 nonprofits - at the deeply discounted rate of about $2 per check.
   ChoicePoint touts the volunteer checks as goodwill, but they also give the company other advantages. They allow ChoicePoint to increase awareness of its brand in new markets and to add more people to its databases, which contain everything from credit histories to criminal records.
• Three more priests named in settlement [Boudreau, Dranka, O'Malley]
   Berkshire Eagle, www.berkshireeagle.com/Stories/0,1413,101~7516~2341718,00.html , The Associated Press
   SPRINGFIELD (AP) (MA) -- Three of the priests named in a $7 million settlement between the Springfield Diocese and alleged victims of clergy sex abuse were not publicly identified by church officials prior to the settlement. Two of the priests served parishes in Berkshire County.
   The Revs. Paul T. Boudreau, Eugene Dranka and Thomas F. O'Malley were listed among 18 priests who were accused of sexual abuse, The Republican newspaper reported yesterday. Dranka and O'Malley are dead, and Boudreau has denied any wrongdoing.
   Served in Berkshires
   [Boudreau served as curate of St. Teresa's Church in Pittsfield in the 1950s; O'Malley was assistant pastor at St. Francis' Church in North Adams. The dates of his tenure there could not be determined yesterday. O'Malley was ordained in 1930, according to Eagle files.] [Posted by Kathy Shaw at 02:53 AM]
////////// End of Clergy Sex Abuse Tracker www.ncrnews.org/abuse , Wed August 18, 2004
Abuse Chronology: http://www.multiline.com.au/~johnm/ethics/ethcont93.htm
• Are Church heads buried in the sand? The fable about the ostrich hiding its head in the sand is what comes to mind, when considering how mainstream Churches, beset by the unfrocking of an Anglican bishop planned for August 25 and the bankruptcy and parish closures facing Roman Catholic US dioceses, are reporting on the Pope's trip to Lourdes (August 2004), and the forthcoming trip of the Church of England's leader to tell the Muslims in Egypt how everyone ought to be friends, and suchlike. Leaflet, one page, August 18, 2004.
ARE CHURCH HEADS
BURIED IN THE
SAND ?
  Perth, Western Australia, August 18, 2004

Microsoft Clip Art (adapted)
Ostrich. 327x375pixels
   Church newspapers around Australia in the past few weeks have been reporting visits of their world leaders to places like Lourdes and Egypt, pilgrimage tourism to holy places, openings of buildings, and various ceremonies and other events, plus devotional and doctrinal articles -- BUT the fable about the ostrich hiding its head in the sand is what comes to mind.
   In Australia the Anglican and Roman Catholic Churches have been exposed again and again since 2002 as backing child sex abusers, and moving them away from complainants.
   Reporting on the disgraces in the United States RC Church has virtually ceased in the RCC Australian diocesan newspapers. More victims are still surfacing in the courts, adding to the 10,667 who had been listed as being allegedly abused by 4392 priests in half a century. (Reuters, Feb 27, 2004.) US parishes are closing, and staff are retrenched.
   Does the average churchgoer or minister realise the following?
  • The Australian Anglican Church on August 25 will hold a "defrocking" ceremony for Bishop Donald Shearman, who had been shielded by former governor-general Peter Hollingworth when he was an Anglican archbishop. (The Mercury, Hobart, July 28, 2004)
  • CEBS (Church of England Boys' Society) was misused as an interstate paedophiles' and ephebophiles' boy exchange. (The Advertiser, Adelaide, May 22, 2003)
  • In various countries, accused clergy, brothers, and nuns are wasting funds on fighting deportation and extradition orders, both between States and between countries.
  • The Salesian Catholic Order has been highlighted as transferring child abusers to mission countries. (The Dallas Morning News, June 21, 2004.) A bishop in Samoa was furious with this. The present Australian head of the order has removed 10 offenders (added to the previous 15), but a former head is an alleged abuser! (See The Age, Melbourne, July 3, 2004, etc.)
  • The Christian Brothers in Ireland have allowed sexual and physical abuse for decades (One in Four organisation, early July 2004, etc). Their Australian and Canadian branches have been shown by inquiries and trials to be just as guilty. In 2004 the Order said it would leave its schools and go to the mission fields ! (Sydney Morning Herald, July 11, 2004)
  • A former Baptist Church leader and school principal of Victoria, John Morley, now deceased, has been credibly accused of molesting youngsters. (The Age, July 8, 2004)
  • Pictures of sex with minors and animals were on the main computer of the St Poelten RC priest-training college in Austria, and newspapers published photos of priests kissing and fondling the young seminarians. (News 24, July 7, 2004)
  • The Brooklyn Diocese in the USA took six years after complaints came in to remove Father Joseph P. Byrns from ministry. (Boston Globe, July 2, 2004)
  • The Diocese of San Bernardino sued the Boston Archdiocese for a refund of the losses it will incur because Boston sent them abuser Fr Paul Shanley. (The New York Times, Apr 9, 03)
  • The US Catholic diocese of Portland, in the north-west US State of Oregon, was the first in that country to file for bankruptcy Part 11 protection. It faces millions in damages for sex abuse (The Courier-Mail, Brisbane, July 7, 2004).
  • In spite of the heavy publicity about clergy child sex abuse from early 2002, clergy of various religions are being arrested for internet-assisted sex offences, such as arranging sex trysts with under-age boys or girls, or obtaining computer sexual images. (Aug 18, 2004)
    Let's lift our heads out of the sand ! John Massam, 46 Cobine Way, Greenwood, Western Australia, 6024. http://www.multiline.com.au/~johnm/ethcont93.htm#ostrich
  • [Aug 18, 04]
    • Voice of the Faithful 2000 on Boston Common.
       In the Vineyard, "VOTF on Boston Common," www.votf.org/vineyard/Aug2004/mass. html , Donna Doucette, August 18, 2004
       BOSTON, Massachusetts, USA: "Stand firm," sang the multi-parish choir August 15, as Catholics from the Archdiocese of Boston participated in a historic Mass on the Boston Common - the first Catholic Mass to be celebrated there since the Pope's Mass 25 years ago and the first Mass ever on the Common to be called for and organized by laity. The Mass was the outcome of nearly two months of planning by the Boston Area VOTF Council to show solidarity with parishioners facing the losses of their parish homes, now numbering over 80 parishes. Also, it was hoped that the Mass would demonstrate the strength and resources of the laity.
       As cantors intoned name by name each parish the Archbishop of Boston has ordered to close, the choir and congregation ended the Mass standing firm in an exhortation that echoed words of hope the Rev. Robert Bowers had uttered during the homily. "Be the new community, the restored community of hope," Fr. Bowers said, as he acknowledged the pain, the grief, and the uncertainty generated by a process the archdiocese calls reconfiguration but which the people experience as an unfair loss. "Our Church leadership has confused the mission of the Church with the money of the Church," he said.
       "All too often during this terrible time I have heard our Church leadership say what we DON'T have. We don't have enough priests. We don't have good solid buildings. We don't have donations like we used to," he continued, "But what we don't have is bishops who have the courage to ask, WHY? I say, look what we DO have: We have each other. We have a voice of the faithful. We have strength and resources and we have God with us."
       Strength and resources were precisely what the Boston Area VOTF Council needed when it began to plan the Mass - and both were present on Boston Common.
       Faced with a compressed schedule - about seven weeks from start to finish - the Boston Steering Committee entrusted the logistics planning to Ed Wade; the liturgy planning to Dorothy Kennedy, Darrell Simpson, and Linda McKay; communications to Sheila Grove; and fund-raising to Rich Acerra. From the first announcement of the plan, the organizing team also quickly gained a logistics angel: events planner Bill Sell of Expo Advisors, who attended the Boston Council's first Parish Summit meeting to learn how he could help prevent the closing of his own parish, St. Jeremiah in Framingham.
       Bill helped guide the process of obtaining permits from Boston city departments already under siege from plans for the Democratic National Convention. He secured tents, a stage, and sound equipment, and handled a multitude of tasks needed for such events.
       The one thing Bill could not control was the weather. But rains and winds from two hurricanes did not quell the spirit, or the turnout, for the Mass. Under gray, foggy skies and against a chill wind, some 2,000 Boston-area Catholics trooped to the Common for the 4 p.m. Mass, concelebrated by four priests whose parishes have been ordered to close: the Rev. Stephen Josoma of St. Susanna in Dedham, who as the presider asked God to forgive us all when we paid, prayed and obeyed and thought that would be enough for our faith; Fr. Bowers, the homilist, from St. Catherine of Siena in Charlestown; the Rev. Ronald Coyne of St. Albert the Great in Weymouth, whose parishioners carried their altar cross from Weymouth to the Common via bus so that it could stand alongside the altar there; and the Rev. David Gill of St. Mary of the Angels in Roxbury, whose parishioners in a previous week  had formed a living ring around their church in symbolic opposition to the closing order.
       Supporting the concelebrants were altar servers, readers, Eucharistic Ministers, cantors, singers, and musicians from numerous parishes in the diocese and a group of young liturgical dancers from Our Lady of Sorrows in Sharon, MA. The multi-parish participation as well as the multi-ethnic and multi-lingual prayers and songs during the Mass emphasized the impact of the closings on all Catholics in the diocese.
       John Hynes, chair of the Boston Steering Committee, reiterated this impact when he read messages of support and encouragement from VOTF affiliates around the country and the world at the end of Mass.
       John also thanked the scores of volunteers who worked so hard to prepare for the Mass. Special thanks went to the organizers from the Steering Committee and to Bill Sell, as well as to those whose efforts proved key to planning: Rich Feeley and Ross Holicker of ROI Event Management in Needham, MA, for behind-the-scenes planning; Performance Platforms of Hudson, MA, for the stage and sound system; Barbara Paul of Bloomin' Exhibits in Barrington, RI, for green plants to decorate the altar area; Tim Westerhaus, Pastoral Minister of Liturgy and Music at the Paulist Center in Boston, for organizing the music and musicians; the clergy and staff of the Paulist Center for their many gifts of time and support; and Suzanne Morse and Steve Krueger from the national VOTF office, who were so effective in helping publicize the Mass. Several regional TV evening news programs covered the Mass as well as the Boston Globe and the archdiocesan newspaper the Pilot.
       As attendees left the area, returning by charter bus, car, subway, and on foot to their homes - and home parishes - they passed the markers Mass organizers had assembled like poster-board tombstones along the walkways to the Mass, markers with the names of every parish targeted for closing by the Archdiocese. It was not easy, passing those markers, to feel the hope Fr. Bowers had asked for earlier, belief and hope in a better world and a new life.
       But it was precisely for that belief that the Boston Area VOTF Council organized the Mass: to gather a community of believers to attend to the grieving of all closing parishes and to participate together in the Eucharist, the Source of Life, Healing, and Strength.
       It was also to ask, as one young girl did of her mother when leaving the Mass on the Boston Common, "Why isn't it always like this?" # [Aug 18, 04]
    Abuse Chronology: http://www.multiline.com.au/~johnm/ethics/ethcont93.htm
    #### Clergy Sex Abuse Tracker, www.ncrnews.org/abuse, Thu August 19, 2004 edition follows:-
    • Priest Faces 20 Counts of Sexual Abuse [2000 Byrns] -- altar boy. U.S.A. flag; Mooney's MiniFlags 
       WABC, http://abclocal.go.com/wabc/news/wabc_081904_reverend.html , August 19, 2004
       BROOKLYN (NY): A priest has been charged with raping a young altar boy at his former parish in Brooklyn.
       Reverend Joseph Byrns, 61, was arraigned on Thursday for alleged sex abuse four years ago at St. Rose of Lima church in Kensington.
       Police say that after he sexually abused the altar boy, the reverend then went to extremes to keep him quiet.
       Stacey Sager reports from Fort Green at the Brooklyn Diocese. [Posted by Kathy Shaw at 08:03 PM] [See also The West Australian, "Accused priest in new abuse case," Associated Press, page 38, Saturday, August 21 , 2004]
    • The concerns of Catholics
       The Tidings, www.the-tidings.com/2004/0820/essays.htm , By Richard P. McBrien, for Aug 20. 2004
       EASTON (MA): Lectures in different parts of the United States and Canada and occasionally overseas have served for many years as a kind of floating laboratory. One gains a reasonably reliable sense of the variety of questions and concerns that are on people's minds.
       A recent visit to Stonehill College in Easton, Massachusetts, a sister institution to the University of Notre Dame (both were founded, and are sponsored and partially staffed, by the Congregation of Holy Cross), is a case in point.
       The event was planned and organized by the Voice of the Faithful (VOTF) organization in the diocese of Fall River. Stonehill provided the venue.
       Many in the audience were VOTF members, but many others were not. The great majority could probably be described as moderate-to-liberal Catholics, shaped by, or sympathetic with, the renewal and reforms of the Second Vatican Council.
       Because there were so many in attendance and too little time to address more than a handful of their written questions, I asked the organizers to send me a complete list of the questions that I never even saw, much less answered. I promised to find some public outlet --- perhaps this weekly column --- to acknowledge these questions and, if possible, to reply to one or two of them. ...
       A fourth grouping of questions had to do with one of VOTF's three purposes, namely, to support "priests of integrity" (the other two involve support for victims and survivors of sexual abuse by priests, and cooperation with pastoral leaders in the governance of the Church).
       Questioners wondered how they could provide meaningful support for such priests, and also worried that those priests who returned the support for VOTF might be silenced or otherwise penalized by their bishops.
    • Detroit judge allows abuse lawsuit against Catholic Church to go forward [1970s Sigler] -- boys.
       The Detroit News, www.detnews.com/2004/metro/0408/19/metro-247723.htm , By Adrienne Schwisow, Associated Press
       DETROIT (MI): A judge has refused to throw out a lawsuit filed by two men who say Roman Catholic church officials in Michigan and New Mexico worked together to cover up sexual abuse by a former priest 30 years ago.
       Lawyers for the Diocese of Lansing, the Archdioceses of Detroit and Santa Fe, N.M., and ex-priest and convicted pedophile Jason Sigler argued the victims filed their lawsuit too late to address incidents that are three decades old.
       But Wayne County Circuit Court Judge Warfield Moore called the church's shuffling of Sigler from Michigan to New Mexico a conspiracy and suggested the unique relationship between priest and parishioner overrides that the normal statute of limitations to sue had expired.
       "They allowed, with consistency, a one-man wrecking crew to go through, and when it got too hot, they said, 'Go somewhere else'," Moore said during a hearing in Detroit Thursday. "I feel that this was an active conspiracy."
       Moore also allowed lawyers for the plaintiffs to depose Sigler and continue seeking discovery documents to bolster their case, moves the church opposed.
    • Priest charged in altar boy abuse [1970s, 2002 Byrns]
       Newsday, www.nynewsday.com/news/local/brooklyn/nyc- prie0820,0,3988611.story?coll=nyc-homepage-headlines ; The Associated Press, August 19, 2004
       NEW YORK: A Brooklyn priest who was dismissed from his diocese earlier this year over sexual abuse allegations dating back more than 30 years was indicted Thursday for allegedly molesting an 11-year-old altar boy two years ago and giving him toys to keep him quiet.
       The Rev. Joseph Byrns, 61, who was the pastor at St. Rose of Lima Roman Catholic Church until he was suspended in 2002, pleaded not guilty before Supreme Court Judge John Walsh to two counts of felony sexual conduct and 20 counts of sexual abuse.
       Byrns was ordered held on $10,000 bail. If convicted he could face up to 25 years in prison, said Brooklyn District Attorney Charles Hynes.
    • The Price of Politics [Hudson]
       National Review, www.nationalreview.com/comment/hudson200408 181000.asp , By Deal W. Hudson, August 18, 2004
       UNITED STATES: In late 1998, Crisis magazine, which I have the honor to publish, ran a series of articles on "the Catholic vote" which unexpectedly led to my involvement in politics. The articles caught the attention of the nascent Bush presidential campaign and I was asked, and agreed, to be part of the team advising on their outreach to Catholic voters.
       Our basic advice, as reflected in our articles, was to target Mass-attending Catholic voters, not the larger group of self-identified Catholics, because Mass attendance is the best indication of a commitment to the kind of values taught by the Church and represented by then candidate Governor George W. Bush.
       This strategy, meshing perfectly with the theme of "compassionate conservatism," paid off and the candidate's message connected with Catholic voters: Governor Bush received ten percent more of the Catholic vote than Senator Dole had in 1996.  ...
       The next day I received a call from a liberal Catholic publication requesting a comment. In response to the reporter's question I told him that I thought the Conference had done the right thing.
       Within a few days the same reporter asked for an interview, he insisted it need be right away, and I complied. He interviewed me for about an hour; a photographer took pictures, while my son played video games around my feet. None of the questions was personal; the questioning was all political, all about my support for President Bush.
       No story appeared. Then people began telling me that this reporter was calling former employees and acquaintances and asking them for information about my personal life. Apparently this reporter was not content with a fair debate of the merits of substantive issues, where, of course, there could be honest disagreement. His target was now going to be my life, my past, and apparently any mistakes that he could uncover to embarrass me.
       Like many people, I have done things in my life that I regret.
    • From the Editor [Hudson]
       National Catholic Reporter, www.nationalcatholicreporter.org/update/bn081904.htm , By Tom Roberts, Aug 19, 2004
       UNITED STATES: Deal Hudson, the influential Catholic publisher and political operative, attempted, in his words, "to get a head start" on a story that NCR Washington correspondent Joe Feuerherd has been working on for more than four months. Hudson's ploy was to write a response to a yet-unpublished story. (See link below.) He was able to place the response on the Web site of National Review, the conservative magazine.
       As an aside, I find it intriguing that National Review would allow its Web site to be used in such a fashion. The publication to which Hudson referred was never named; no one ever called NCR to confirm whether we were doing a story or to determine the nature of the piece. The National Review allowed Hudson to characterize the unpublished story -- which was still in the process of being written -- as an unfair look at his personal life.
       He raises an important issue, and it deserves to be addressed.
       All of us, as Hudson put it, have done things in our lives that we regret.
    • The Real Deal: How a Philosophy Professor With a Checkered Past Became the Most Influential Catholic Layman in George W. Bush's Washington [Hudson]
       National Catholic Reporter, www.nationalcatholicreporter.org/update/bn081904.htm , By Joe Feuerherd, Washington, Aug 19, 2004
    Editor's note: Deal Hudson announced Aug. 18 that he would be giving up his position with the Republican National Committee in reaction to questions posed by "a liberal Catholic publication." In recent days, NCR has tried repeatedly to meet with Hudson to get his response to questions about his departure from Fordham University in 1994 following allegations of an inappropriate sexual relationship with a freshman female student. The university said Hudson "surrendered" his tenure. He also paid a settlement of $30,000 to terminate a lawsuit that the student brought against him on the basis of these allegations.
       WASHINGTON (DC): This past March 17, having paid tribute to the saint who drove the snakes from Ireland, George W. Bush -- first lady to his left, Irish prime minister to his right -- bounded off the Roosevelt Room podium. As he began to work the crowd of Irish Americans and Gaelic-wannabees, the president noticed a familiar face, a fellow Texan, among those assembled at the annual St. Patrick's Day White House gathering.
       "Immediately after George Bush spoke," recalled former U.S. ambassador to the Vatican Ray Flynn, "the first person he greeted was Deal Hudson." Heady stuff, perhaps, to be the first among the gathered Catholic glitterati to be singled out by the most powerful man in the world. But by now Hudson -- publisher of the conservative Catholic monthly Crisis, Bush political operative, and one-time philosophy professor -- was accustomed to the treatment.
    • Bush Campaign Adviser Quits as Sexual Misconduct Case Is Recalled [1995 Hudson] -- female.
       The New York Times, www.nytimes.com/2004/08/19/politics/campaign/19resign.html , By DAVID D. KIRKPATRICK, August 19, 2004
       NEW YORK: Deal W. Hudson, the publisher of the conservative Roman Catholic journal Crisis and the architect of a Republican effort to court Catholic voters, says he is resigning as an adviser to the Bush campaign because of a Catholic newspaper's investigation into accusations of sexual misconduct involving a female student at a college where he once taught.
       "No one regrets my past mistakes more than I do," Mr. Hudson wrote in a column posted yesterday on the online edition of National Review announcing his resignation.
       "At the time, I dealt with this in an upright manner, and the matter was satisfactorily resolved long ago," he wrote, without specifying the accusations. Mr. Hudson, 54, said he had been happily married to his current wife for 17 years. Called for comment, he declined.
       Mr. Hudson did not name the publication. Others who said they had been contacted by a newspaper doing an investigation said it was The National Catholic Reporter.
       Thomas Roberts, editor of The National Catholic Reporter, declined to comment.
       At Fordham University, a Jesuit school in New York where Mr. Hudson taught from 1989 to 1995, a university spokeswoman confirmed that the episode had led to Mr. Hudson's resignation. The spokeswoman, Elizabeth Schmalz, said: "Fordham followed its policy rigorously in this matter and initiated an investigation upon receipt of the student complaint. The professor later surrendered his tenure at Fordham."
       A person involved with the university's investigation said that a freshman in one of Mr. Hudson's classes reported to the university that, after she had become drunk at a bar, Mr. Hudson made sexual advances toward her. After a period of weeks, she charged him with sexual harassment. The accusations were made near the end of a school year, and Mr. Hudson left academia.
    • Court: Church protected [Kelley] -- girl.
       The Republican, www.masslive.com/metrowest/republican/index.ssf?/ base/news-1/1092919783125401.xml ; By BILL ZAJAC, wzajac@repub.com , Thursday, August 19, 2004
       SPRINGFIELD (MA) - A Hampden Superior Court judge's ruling that churches are protected by charitable immunity limiting judgments to $20,000 in clergy sexual abuse cases has cast doubt over whether the Catholic church will continue to negotiate multimillion dollar settlements with alleged victims.
       Hampden Superior Court Judge John A. Agostini ruled last week to uphold a charitable immunity statute in a case involving a Hampden woman who was suing the Roman Catholic Diocese of Worcester for abuse she alleges occurred while she was a minor.
       "It is well established that charitable immunity and charitable limitation of damages apply to cases involving negligent hiring and retention," wrote Agostini, who was assigned to the consolidated clergy sexual abuse suits filed against the Springfield diocese during the past two years.
       Jane Martin contended the Worcester diocese was negligent in hiring the Rev. Robert E. Kelley, who she said abused her as a child. Her lawyer said he plans to appeal the ruling.
       The law states charitable institutions can face no liability before September 1971 and a limit of $20,000 after that date.
    • Priest pornography investigation may take years [? 2003-04 Arceneaux]
       The Opelousas Daily World, www.dailyworld.com/html/785E3647-EA03-4F48-B335-DCD04949E025.shtml , by William Johnson / Louisiana Gannett News, Posted on August 19, 2004
       ARNAUDVILLE (LA) - Driving through town one can't miss the signs - "Bring back Father Jules," "Pray for Father Jules."
       At town council meetings, special prayers are offered for the return of their hometown priest.
       "He had a great impact on our town," Mayor Kathy Richard said.
       Father Jules Arceneaux, who has been pastor of St. Francis Regis Catholic Church for the past two years, was placed on administrative leave last month pending the outcome of a federal investigation into alleged pornography discovered on a church computer.
       William L. Goode, a lawyer representing Arceneaux, said a young man has come forward and admitted he was the one who placed the illicit images on the church computer.
       Nonetheless, the case against Arceneaux continues - and may continue for years.
    • Ruling casts doubt on future of clergy sex abuse settlements [Kelley] -- girl.
       Herald Tribune, www.heraldtribune.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20040819/APN/408190663 , The Associated Press, Aug 19, 2004
       SPRINGFIELD, Mass. -- A recent court ruling is casting doubt on future settlements between churches and alleged victims of clergy sex abuse.
       Hamdpen Superior Court Judge John Agostini ruled last week to uphold a charitable immunity state statute in a lawsuit filed by a Hampden woman who was suing the Worcester Diocese for abuse.
       The law says that charitable institutions - including churches - are shielded from prosecution of alleged crimes that happened before 1971. The law also limits the institutions' liability to $20,000 after that date.
       In the Worcester Diocese case, Jane Martin said the church was negligent in hiring the Rev. Robert E. Kelley, who she said abused her as a child. Her lawyer said he plans to appeal the ruling.
       The Springfield diocese, which recently reached a $7.5 million settlement with 45 people who say they were abused by priests as children, told The Republican newspaper of Springfield it is reviewing Agostini's decision. But officials didn't indicate whether church lawyers will invoke the charitable immunity law on future sex abuse claims.
       "The diocese is aware of last week's ruling. Our attorneys are reviewing it, and upon completion of that review will advise the diocese," read a statement issued by the diocese.
    • Memphis Pastor Arrested for Child Sex Abuse [Vahle] -- Lutheran.
       WREG, www.wreg.com/Global/story.asp?S=2193166 , By Roswell Encina, August 18, 2004
       MEMPHIS, TN - The pastor of Our Savior Lutheran Church in Whitehaven has been arrested for 41 counts of sexual assault against minors.
       Memphis Police picked up 53 year old Michael Vahle Wednesday afternoon with warrants from Yavapai County in Arizona. A member of Vahle's congregation says the Lutheran Pastor was writing his sermon when he was arrested.
       "He's intelligent, he's friendly and real pleasant to talk to. That's why this is such a shock," says Church Council President Michael Amsden. "There's no way you would even think he'd be involved with something wrong."
       News Channel 3 has also learned that Vahle is a substitute teacher in Desoto County, MS.
       Police says none of the alleged sex crimes were committed in Memphis but they're not taken any chances. "Our sex crime investigators will be looking through our reports and trying to determine if any chance he maybe involved in any sexual activity here," says Inspector Matt McCann of the Memphis Police Department.
    • Web site posts some diocese documents
       Quad-City Times, www.qctimes.com/internal.php?story_id=1033381&l=1&t= Nation+%2F+World&c=26,1033381 , By Todd Ruger, Wednesday, August 18th, 2004
       DAVENPORT (IA): A Web site tracking the sexual abuse crisis on a national basis has posted documents and other information from two lawsuits against the Catholic Diocese of Davenport.
       The court files posted at www.bishop-accountability.org include diocesan documents, affidavits and other materials filed by Craig Levien, a Quad-City attorney who represents numerous plaintiffs in lawsuits against the diocese.
       No documents, affidavits or materials filed by diocese attorneys are posted on the Web site. #
    • Group rallies, accuses nuns of abuse
       The Dallas Morning News, www.dallasnews.com/sharedcontent/dws/news/localnews/stories/081904 dnmetnuns.16596.html ; By SUSAN HOGAN/ALBACH, 02:51 AM CDT on Thursday, August 19, 2004
       FORTH WORTH (TX): Outside the Fort Worth Convention Center on Wednesday, a group of adults said that as children they were abused by Catholic religious leaders. The difference this time is that they say their abusers were nuns.
       They rallied outside the center because Catholic nuns meeting there today through Sunday declined to allow them to address their convention. Instead, the nuns have set up a small private meeting in Chicago on Oct. 3.
       "Nearly all of our members have indicated a willingness to address this issue," Sister Constance Phelps, president of the Leadership Conference of Women Religious, said in a statement. "However, we did not believe the assembly offered an environment conducive for listening and dialogue."
       The conference, which represents 73,000 U.S. nuns, is conducting a joint meeting with the Conference of Major Superiors of Men, which represents 21,000 priests and brothers belonging to male religious orders.
       The convention will focus on fostering peace and includes sessions on terrorism, domestic violence and serving as missionaries in places of violence. The keynote speaker is Mary Robinson, former president of Ireland.
    • Victim backs priest's penalty [Mueller]
       Beacon Journal, www.ohio.com/mld/beaconjournal/ 9436486.htm?ERIGHTS=-3363934154246322268 ohio::kashaw@peoplepc.com&KRD_RM= 3rrmsojkosqnksjjjjjjjjkjjp|Kathleen|Y ; By Colette M. Jenkins, Beacon Journal religion writer
       AKRON (OH): Pat Rogacs' faith in the hierarchy of the Catholic Diocese of Cleveland is on the mend.
       "I now believe that Bishop (Anthony) Pilla is acting on his words. He said he is sorry for the hurt and pain of the victims of sexual abuse. He said sexual abuse won't be tolerated," said Rogacs, 52, of Akron. "He took the time to listen to me, and he took action against the priest who abused me."
       On Monday, Pilla met with Rogacs and informed her that the Rev. John J. Mueller is no longer allowed to perform duties as a priest.
       Pilla's decision came last week after the diocesan review board assigned to investigate the cases of priests accused of sexual abuse issued its first recommendation. That came about 11 months after the predominantly lay review board began investigating the cases of more than half the 20 priests in the diocese who had been placed on administrative leave because of allegations of abuse.
       Pilla stated in a letter read last weekend to parishioners at St. Mary of the Immaculate Conception in Wooster that the board members "have indicated to me that a preponderance of the evidence presented to the Review Board shows that Father John J. Mueller has engaged in conduct defined by the Policy (for the Safety of Children in Matters of Sexual Abuse) as sexual abuse of a minor."
    • Diocese suspends Q-C area priest [1998] -- man.
       Quad-City Times www.qctimes.com/internal.php?story_id=1033420&t=Local+News&c=2,1033420 , By Todd Ruger
       DAVENPORT (IA): A priest in the Davenport Catholic Diocese has been restricted from active duty pending an internal investigation into a current allegation of sexual abuse, an attorney for the diocese said Wednesday.
       Davenport attorney Rand Wonio said a man told the diocese last year that a priest sexually abused him in Johnson County during 1998. The diocese will not identify the accused priest until the completion of its investigation, in accordance with the diocese policies on sexual abuse, Wonio added.
       The criminal statute of limitations on the allegation has not expired, meaning it could be criminally prosecuted in court, the diocese said.
       The incident was reported to an assistant in the Johnson County Attorney's office during July 2003, even though the man "who made the report did not wish any criminal charges to be filed," Wonio said.
       "Nor did he want his name to be given to anyone, not even family," he said, adding that the diocese is paying for the attorney who represents the man.
    • Perv priest bust [1970s, 2000-02 Byrns] -- boys.
       New York Post, www.nypost.com/news/regionalnews/18802.htm , August 19, 2004
       NEW YORK: A Catholic priest allowed to remain on the job despite allegations he sexually abused two brothers in the 1970s was busted yesterday on charges he raped a young altar boy in Brooklyn four years ago, The Post has learned.
       The Rev. Joseph Byrns, 61, who is barred from working as a priest, was taken into custody in upstate Oneonta and is expected to be arraigned today on charges linked to sexual abuse of the boy at his former parish, St. Rose of Lima Church in Kensington, law-enforcement sources said.
       Byrns began to fondle the then 11-year-old in 2000, and moved on to sodomizing him, the sources said. He allegedly used threats as well as bribes of money and toys to keep the boy quiet about the molestation, which the sources said continued until 2002.
       The indictment was handed up last week after the boy, now 15, and his father testified to a Brooklyn grand jury. The DA's Office refused to comment.
       "As a father, I was devastated," said the boy's dad, a Haitian immigrant who now lives with his family in Florida. "To see a person that you trusted with your kids, the same person every Sunday you finish Mass, you're shaking his hand, the same person [then] do some act on your kids - that's unbelievable."
    • Ex-priest guilty of sex crimes [1960-62 Houston] -- boys. Had been convicted previously. Canada flag; Mooney's MiniFlags 
       Winnipeg Sun, www.canoe.ca/NewsStand/WinnipegSun/News/2004/08/19/590070.html , By ANDREW RAVEN, Northern News Services, Aug 19, 2004
       INUVIK, N.W.T., CANADA -- A former Manitoba priest has been convicted of sex crimes with students at an Inuvik residential school in the early '60s. Martin Houston, 67, pleaded guilty Tuesday to one count of buggery and two counts of indecent assault involving students under his charge.
       The assaults took place between August 1960 and June 1962 when he was a dorm supervisor at Grollier Hall, a residential school run by the Roman Catholic church in Inuvik.
    INNOCENT LIVES SOILED
       "You soiled the lives of innocent boys," said Justice Arthur Lutz, who gave Houston a suspended sentence and put him on three years probation.
       The sentence was a joint recommendation of Crown attorney Noel Sinclair and defence lawyer Richard Wolson.
       This is the second time Houston has been sentenced for sexual abuse at Grollier Hall. In 1962, he pleaded guilty to five counts of buggery and five counts of gross indecency.
    • Accused priests took in minors -- boys. Whidbey Island, Ohio and Detroit known to Church group. U.S.A. flag; Mooney's MiniFlags 
       Post-Intelligencer, http://seattlepi.nwsource.com/local/186975_priest19.html , By CLAUDIA ROWE AND MICHELLE NICOLOSI
       SEATTLE (WA): Buried deep in the thousands of sexual abuse allegations against Roman Catholic priests lies a startling, little-known fact: Dozens of clerics accused of molesting minors lived with children, often serving as legal parents or guardians to boys who called their rectories home.
       The Seattle Post-Intelligencer has found four priests in Washington, later removed from ministry for alleged sexual abuse, who had boys living with them in church-owned properties.
       Across the nation, sometimes the church knew of the unorthodox living arrangements but did nothing; in other cases, church officials say they had no notion that minors were living in rectories.
       In at least three instances -- one on Whidbey Island, another in Ohio and a third in Detroit -- boys were placed in priests' homes with the knowledge of Catholic Charities, records and interviews show.
       In many cases the victims, now grown men, say they endured the abuse because they had nowhere else to go.
       Often, the parenting priests appeared as rescuers, removing children from lives of extreme hardship and offering to raise them in middle-class comfort.
    • The 11 abuse cases the P-I examined -- males. [Mitchell, Mertens, Ashwell, Cornelius, etc.]
       Post-Intelligencer, http://seattlepi.nwsource.com/local/186956_priestlitany19.html , Thursday, August 19, 2004
      SEATTLE (WA): A synopsis of 11 abuse cases examined by the Seattle Post-Intelligencer:
       Washington cases
  • The Rev. James Mitchell brought two teens to Washington from Colombia and promised to adopt them, subjecting them to frequent sexual abuse, according to a complaint filed by one of them in May. A recent visit to his home in Pullman revealed that two young men are living there today. One said their relationship with Mitchell is not sexual. The other did not comment. Mitchell has been removed from active ministry.
  • The Rev. Arthur C. Mertens of the Spokane Diocese invited a Mexican-born boy to live with him in his Walla Walla rectory as a way of escaping violence at home, then raped him for years, according to a recently filed lawsuit. Mertens has been removed from active ministry.
  • The Rev. G. Barry Ashwell was a state-licensed foster father to at least five children on Whidbey Island -- including one who settled a molestation claim with the Seattle Archdiocese in 1996. Ashwell has vehemently denied the allegations. In 2002, he was removed from active ministry after the Seattle Archdiocese found credible evidence of sexual abuse in another case.
  • A Seattle priest, the Rev. John Cornelius, took in as many as 13 children. None of them has claimed abuse, but more than 20 other men have accused him of abusing them. Cornelius resigned in 2002, saying "To all those I have hurt, I express to you my sorrow, and I ask for your forgiveness." Contacted recently, Cornelius said he has no further comment.
       Cases elsewhere
  • A Milwaukee jury found the Rev. Marvin Knighton not guilty last year of charges that he sexually assaulted a teen in the late '80s, but the Milwaukee Archdiocese reviewed claims against Knighton, and in April found that there is a "preponderance of evidence" that Knighton committed sexual abuse. According Knighton's attorney, Gerald P. Boyle, Knighton has three adopted sons.
  • In Michigan, the Rev. Edward Olszewski was found guilty in December 2002 of four counts of indecent liberties with Albert Green, now a Lynnwood resident, who lived with him in the '70s when he was a child.
       Olszewski is now registered in Florida as a sexual offender. He has said his trial was flawed, and he is not guilty of any sexual misconduct. He said Green is "a pathological liar. ... This is all made up."
  • According to a recently settled lawsuit, the Rev. Dozia Wilson molested a youth who lived with him in his rectory in Massachusetts for three years in the 1970s. According to the lawsuit, Wilson was the boy's partial guardian -- he had legal authority to handle his financial, school and medical affairs. A second man who has sued Wilson alleging abuse -- Joe Woodward -- said he lived with Wilson for a brief period in New York.
  • Former Toledo, Ohio, Deacon Glen Shrimplin has recently been sued by two men alleging abuse. One of those men, who filed as John Doe, said Shrimplin was a foster father to a boy who was placed in Shrimplin's home by the Catholic Charities arm of the Toledo Diocese in the early '70s. He says he knew that child when they were kids and were both being molested by Shrimplin. He said he has since spoken to the man, who has decided not to go public with his allegations.
       Claudia Vercellotti, co-coordinator of the Toledo chapter of SNAP -- the Survivors Network of Those Abused by Priests -- said she also spoke with the alleged victim. "He said emphatically that he was placed in foster care as a child through Catholic Charities with Glen Shrimplin," she said.
       John Doe said he told a case manager and a priest at the diocese last year that Shrimplin was a foster parent who had abused the foster child who stayed with him.
       But Sally Oberski, director of communications at the diocese, said that "if it happened, we don't know about it." She said none of the officials in the diocese recall ever being told there was a foster child or any child living with Shrimplin.
       "A lot of people take people in to help them out" without going though formal channels, she said. "If that was the situation, we might not have even known about it. It's kind of scary if that's what he was doing," she said.
       Shrimplin did not return calls placed to a number registered in his name, but has said in the past that the abuse allegations are false.
  • Rochester, N.Y., priest Robert O'Neill had a young man living with him in his rectory for about a year in the 1980s. Mark Furnish -- who has sued O'Neill alleging sexual abuse -- said he believes the boy was 16, but O'Neill said he was 20.
       Diocese spokesman Michael Tedesco said he and others in the Rochester Diocese "have no knowledge of ... any kind of information about a young man or boy who lived with him in the rectory."
       The Rochester Diocese removed O'Neill's priestly faculties in May 2002 "because of what we thought were credible allegations of abuse," Tedesco said.
       Tedesco said the diocese did not have rules against minors living with or staying overnight with priests at the time, but in 2003 passed a new code of conduct that prohibits it.
  • In Minnesota, the Rev. Francis Hoefgen invited a suicidal teenager to move into his home. He later admitted to sexually abusing the boy.
  • And in California, the Rev. Oliver O'Grady was found guilty of moving in with a single woman and sexually abusing her children throughout most of the 1980s. #
    • Advocates for Abuse Victims Stage Protest
       The Mercury News, www.mercurynews.com/mld/mercurynews/news/world/9437359.htm?ERIGHTS=-621059487235 7113661mercurynews:: kashaw@peoplepc.com&KRD_RM=4nrnolomtsptrnrkkkkkkkkloo|Kathleen|Y , By BOBBY ROSS JR., Associated Press
       FORT WORTH, Texas - Advocates for victims of clergy sex abuse held posters that read "No more suicides" and "Help us Heal" in a protest Wednesday outside a convention hall where a group representing Roman Catholic nuns was about to meet.
       The Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests [SNAP] has been trying to focus attention on molestation cases against nuns, after more than two years of church scandal that has focused mainly on misconduct by priests.
       The Survivors Network has been lobbying for weeks for a chance to address the four-day assembly of the Leadership Conference of Women Religious, an association based in Silver Spring, Md., representing about 1,000 leaders of women's orders. The meeting is set to begin Thursday.
       A representative of the Leadership Conference distributed a statement from the group's president, Sister Constance Phelps, saying the convention would not be "an environment conducive for listening and dialogue." She instead offered to have conference officials meet with the advocates for "a productive discussion focused on critical issues relevant to supporting survivors and preventing further sexual abuse."
    • Abuse victims' group pickets nuns meeting
       Star-Telegram, www.dfw.com/mld/startelegram/news/local/9440298.htm?ERIGHTS= 8498876012317778512dfw::kashaw@peoplepc.com&KRD_RM= 8oowvxvswtpwovppxorooooooo|Kathleen|Y ; By BRETT HOFFMAN
       FORT WORTH (TX) - A handful of protesters who said they were sexually abused by nuns picketed outside the Fort Worth Convention Center on Wednesday where a national conference of Roman Catholic nuns is scheduled to begin today.
       The protesters, members of Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests, or SNAP, have asked to speak to the four-day convention of the Leadership Conference of Women Religious. Conference leaders declined the request.
       The conference comprises about 1,000 leaders of religious orders in which about 70,000 U.S. Catholic nuns serve.
       Last month, after a similar SNAP demonstration outside their Maryland headquarters, conference officials agreed to meet with SNAP representatives on Oct. 3 in Chicago.
       But SNAP members say that is not sufficient.
       "We think it's far more important to talk to 1,000 leaders who are in Fort Worth today rather than three of four individuals who represent the 1,000 in Chicago," Barbara Blaine, president of SNAP, said Wednesday.
    • Judge agrees with diocese; throws out papers in suit [Kelley] -- three previous victims. -- Crimen Sollicitationis and supporting document set aside.
       Telegram & Gazette, www.telegram.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article? AID=/20040819/NEWS/408190374/1008/NEWS02 , by Kathleen A. Shaw, T&G STAFF, kshaw@telegram.com , Aug 19, 2004
       SPRINGFIELD (MA): Judge John A. Agostini of Hampden Superior Court has upheld the Diocese of Worcester's contention that certain documents be stricken from Jane Martin's lawsuit against the diocese involving allegations of sexual abuse by the Rev. Robert E. Kelley.
       Judge Agostini also upheld the diocese's position that the state's charitable immunity law applies to Ms. Martin's case.
       Among documents that were tossed out is the 1962 Vatican document called Crimen Sollicitationis, which surfaced in Worcester a year ago, and a 1991 document from Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger of the Vatican's Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, which discusses grave sins by clergy.
       James Gavin Reardon Jr., lawyer for the diocese, said yesterday he was pleased with the judge's decision. The judge upheld the diocese's two leading contentions that the state's charitable immunity law applied in this suit and that Crimen Sollicitationis is not relevant, he said.
       Mr. Reardon said although Judge Agostini's decision is not binding on Judge Jeffrey Locke, who is hearing pending Worcester lawsuits, he said it is "instructive" to the other judges because Judge Agostini reviewed the case and applied the law.
       Mr. Reardon and lawyer Joanne L. Goulka of Stoneham made a similar argument to Judge Locke in Worcester Superior Court, but he has not ruled.
       Several lawyers throughout the United States are attempting to introduce the Crimen document in civil suits in Worcester, Springfield, Los Angeles, Dallas, Louisville, Ky., and other jurisdictions.
       The lawyers believe that Crimen Sollicitationis - Latin for "The Crime of Solicitation" - and the Cardinal Ratzinger letter demonstrate a worldwide conspiracy by the hierarchy of the Catholic Church to cover up sexual abuse by its priests. The document has not been admitted as evidence into any of the pending lawsuits.
       Judge Agostini said the Crimen document "purports to establish procedures in Canonical Courts for hearing and adjudicating accusations of solicitation by priests. This should be stricken," he said in his decision.
       "Martin failed to provide any facts to support her claim that the documents originated with the Vatican or that the Diocese actually received it. Furthermore, how the Catholic Church handled allegations of solicitation within in Canonical Courts is irrelevant to the issues here," the judge said.
       The judge said the document from Cardinal Ratzinger was written 17 years after the alleged abuse of Ms. Martin by Rev. Kelley and is not relevant to this suit.
       Ms. Martin's lawyer, Michael P. Ascher, accused the judge and the legal system in Massachusetts of further victimizing Ms. Martin and said the judge has effectively taken away Ms. Martin's claims that the diocese acted beyond the scope of its charitable purpose when it allowed Rev. Kelley to continue as a priest.
       The judge's decision "has set a precedent," Mr. Ascher said. He said he believes it to be erroneous and based upon legal theories that are misapplied. He said he is appealing. Judge Agostini's decision was filed with the court Aug. 12.
       Mr. Ascher said Ms. Martin met April 14 with Bishop Daniel P. Reilly, who has since retired. Bishop Reilly "looked her in the eye and promised to settle her case before Bishop McManus' arrival," he said.
       "He asked her to draft a written letter with an itemization of what she needed to settle her claims. She apparently did so and delivered it to Bishop Reilly. She followed up with several telephone calls, and we were then served with a letter that essentially told Jane to stop communicating with the bishop directly, although he had solicited the letter," Mr. Ascher said.
       Mr. Reardon said lawyers for both sides agreed to let Ms. Martin meet with Bishop Reilly, but that it would be a private meeting, that the substance of the meeting would be kept confidential, and that no lawyers would be present. He said he would honor the confidentiality of the meeting and not discuss it further, but he did deny that Bishop Reilly ever promised to settle her lawsuit.
       Ms. Martin's lawyer said the judge's decision has eliminated any incentive by the diocese to participate in settlement discussions because it can argue that its damages are capped at $20,000.
       Judge Agostini said Ms. Martin incorrectly framed the issue "as whether the sexual abuse of children is an activity carried on to further the Diocese's charitable purpose." The real issue is whether the diocese's negligent hiring, training and supervision of Rev. Kelley and its failure to investigate and remove him were beyond the charitable purpose of the diocese, the judge said.
       Ms. Martin, who lives in Hampden County, alleges in a civil lawsuit that the diocese failed to properly supervise the Rev. Kelley when he was an active priest of the diocese. She alleges that he sexually abused her when he was assigned to Notre Dame Parish, Southbridge.
       Rev. Kelley has admitted in a previous deposition that he sexually abused Ms. Martin. The issue being argued in this lawsuit is whether the diocese was negligent. According to the suit, Ms. Martin was about 10 when she was abused. She maintains she reported the abuse to her pastor, the late Monsignor Raymond Page, who was also Rev. Kelley's superior.
       Rev. Kelley, who was removed from active ministry by the diocese but never defrocked, is serving a prison term after pleading guilty to raping Heather Mackey and Denise Gallian when he was assigned to St. Cecilia Parish, Leominster. He previously served a jail term after pleading guilty to raping Jennifer A. Kraskouskas of Gardner when she was a girl. [Posted by Kathy Shaw at 06:39 AM]
    ////////// End of Clergy Sex Abuse Tracker www.ncrnews.org/abuse , Thu August 19, 2004
    Abuse Chronology: http://www.multiline.com.au/~johnm/ethics/ethcont93.htm
    • Convicted priest may face new charges. [Ridsdale] -- 9 new complainants. Australia flag; Aust. Nat. Flag Assn. 
       CathNews, http://www.cathnews.com/news/408/106.php , Aug 19, 2004
       MELBOURNE, Victoria, Australia: Convicted pedophile and former Melbourne priest Gerald Ridsdale may face new charges after the Director of Public Prosecutions this week decided to reconsider a decision not to prosecute new allegations.
       The Age reports today that victims have filed complaints against Ridsdale since he was convicted in 1994 on 46 charges of sexual abuse throughout central and western Victoria.
       The DPP, Paul Coghlan, QC, has offered to meet victims who have come forward since the conviction, and said he would reconsider prosecuting Ridsdale, 70, over their allegations.
       Victorian Attorney-General Rob Hulls welcomed Mr Coghlan's review, which follows comments by Premier Steve Bracks encouraging victims to come forward. Mr Bracks said he hoped victims could have their day in court.
       In a letter to Mr Hulls, Mr Coghlan said the decision not to prosecute was based on the fact that the new allegations could have been heard at the original trial. Responding to what he called "disquiet in the community", Mr Coghlan said it was important the public have confidence in the justice system.
       "The group who are of the greatest concern are the victims. I have not met them. I am prepared to do so," Mr Coghlan wrote in a letter to Mr Hulls. "It follows that such meetings only have a point if I am prepared to reconsider my decision. I am prepared to do so. I will arrange for the victims to be contacted and informed of my decision."
       SOURCE
    Convicted priest may face new charges (The Age 19/8/04)
       LINKS
    Milwaukee Preacher Gets Sentence For Exorcism (Local6.com 17/8/04)
    Child abuse scheme to cover 30 more centres (One in Four)
    Prosecutors block child sex charges against ex-priest (CathNews 17/8/04)
    Activities of jailed priest reportedly resurface in Pell inquiry (CathNews 2/10/02)
      HAVE YOUR SAY   Click here   
    Abuse Chronology: http://www.multiline.com.au/~johnm/ethics/ethcont93.htm
    #### Clergy Sex Abuse Tracker, www.ncrnews.org/abuse, Fri August 20, 2004 edition follows:-
    • Holy Ghost Pastor Languishes in Jail As Relatives Fail to Pursue Rape Case [? 2004 Vandi] -- Lutheran. Girl. Liberia flag; Mooney's MiniFlags 
       AllAfrica.com http://allafrica.com/stories/200408190407.html , by George Bardue, August 19, 2004
       MONROVIA, LIBERIA: Relatives of a "Holy Ghost Pastor" and those of a 13-year-old alleged rape victim have reportedly failed, so far, to pursue the rape case at the Monrovia Magisterial Court.
       But the suspect, Pastor Sao Vandi of the Holy Ghost Lutheran Church in Banjor, lower Virginia, is still languishing in jail.
       City Solicitor Atty. Richard Brown told The NEWS Wednesday that since the Writ of Arrest was issued about a week ago, neither the relatives of the 13-year-old girl nor those of the defendant were yet to press for an assignment for the case.
       The City Solicitor did not say which lawyers were representing either party, but he said if they continue to delay in calling for an assignment for the case to be heard, the prosecutors would not relent to seek for a transfer to the circuit court. [Posted by Kathy Shaw at 09:41 PM]
    • All sides appeal murder case involving pastor convicted of murdering wife [2004 Fossmo] -- Pentecostal. Wife murder. Sweden flag; Mooney's MiniFlags 
       CBC, www.cbc.ca/cp/world/040820/w082066.html , 10:35 PM EDT, Aug 20, 2004
       STOCKHOLM, Sweden (AP) - A bizarre murder case involving a Pentecostal pastor convicted of manipulating his former nanny to shoot his wife will go another round in court as both prosecutors and defence lawyers appealed the initial ruling.
       Helge Fossmo was sentenced to life in prison last month for the murder of his wife, Alexandra, but prosecutors appealed Friday saying he should be convicted of killing his previous spouse as well.
       Defence lawyers also appealed the July 30 ruling, hoping to have the 32-year-old pastor acquitted on all charges in a case that has captivated Swedes for the last eight months.
       The Uppsala District Court ruled that Fossmo persuaded his nanny, Sara Svensson, 27, to shoot his wife as she was sleeping in their home in Knutby, about 75 kilometres northeast of Stockholm. Svensson also shot Fossmo's neighbour, who survived the Jan. 10 attack.
    • Lee County pastor denied bond in wife's slaying [2004 Bynum] -- Cry Out Loud Ministries. Wife killing. U.S.A. flag; Mooney's MiniFlags 
       News 14, http://rdu.news14.com/content/headlines/?ArID=53865&SecID=2 , Associated Press, 5:45 PM, Aug/20/2004
       ROCKINGHAM, NORTH CAROLINA - A Lee County pastor charged with killing his wife was denied bond Friday.
       Melvin Lamont Bynum is the pastor at Cry Out Loud Ministries in Sanford.
       His wife's body was found in the trunk of her car nearly three weeks ago north of Hamlet. Marnita Bynum was strangled.
       Melvin Bynum was arrested Thursday night and charged with first-degree murder.
       Prosecutors told Judge Hunt Gwyn they probably will seek the death penalty for Bynum, who is in the Richmond County Jail.
    • Va. Minister Charged in Daughter's Death [2004 Grote] -- Baptist.
       Guardian, www.guardian.co.uk/uslatest/story/0,1282,-4439183,00.html , Saturday August 21, 2004
       HANOVER, Va. (AP) - A minister whose 3-year-old daughter died of heatstroke was indicted Friday on a charge of involuntary manslaughter. The child was mistakenly left alone in the family vehicle for nearly eight hours on a day temperatures went up to the mid-80s.
       Douglas William Grote, 32, surrendered Friday and was released on a $2,500 bond. His arraignment was set for Tuesday. If convicted, he would face up to 10 years in prison.
       Grote, recreation minister for Cool Spring Baptist Church, mistakenly left his daughter, Kristen, inside the family's sport utility vehicle in the church parking lot after he arrived for work Aug. 3, authorities said.
    • A slice of Gilbert Deya -- "miracle babies." Kenya flag; Mooney's MiniFlags 
       East African Standard, www.eastandard.net/headlines/news20080418.htm , By Samuel Rambaya
       KENYA: Until the media detonated the 'proverbial bomb' on his ministry, Archbishop Gilbert Juma Deya was just another classical latter day priest.
       But a sensational dig into his operations by the dominant secular Press has unearthed an explosive scandal that has left his credibility in ruins.
       The archbishop has found no favour in his home country in Kenya and in his base in United Kingdom where he commands over 34,000-strong following. It was the British Broadcasting Corporation (BBC) that set in motion what is turning out to be one of the biggest religious scandals this century matched only by the Catholic priests child abuse scam.
       Deya's predicament has put some big names in a spot among them Presidents and Queens of nations who had publicly identified with him. [...]
       Deya is fabulously rich, owning two private jets and with international connections that span across continents.
       He is not just a cleric but also an enterprising businessman who has invested heavily in the UK. His son Amos is also a pastor in one of the numerous churches across UK affiliated to the Gilbert Deya ministries. [...]
       Curiously, Deya has no Church in Kenya although he commands large crowds whenever he comes to hold the "miracle" crusades.
       Born in Juja, Thika district around mid last century, Deya's ancestral home is in Sakwa, in the rural recesses of Bondo district.
       He tells his own story in East African, a London magazine published by a Kenyan, Gakuru Macharia in its August 17th issue.
       By the age of nine years, he was begging to support his family neglected by his father, who he said, was a drunk. [...]
       At the age of 19, he left his rural home to Kisumu to become a security guard but lost the job to a con artist and so he drifted into the ministry.
       Before he left the country in 1996, Deya had gained notoriety as a country exorcist preacher with his favourite venue being KICC.
       His television show, whose highlights were miraculous healings, was featured on KBC and later KTN.
       Deya's wife, Mary, also claims healing power and takes credit for the 'miracle babies.' #
    • Fetish priest jailed 20 years for defilement [2004 Asenso alias Ashaikro] -- girl. Ghana flag; Mooney's MiniFlags 
       GhanaWeb, www.ghanaweb.com/GhanaHomePage/NewsArchive/artikel.php?ID=64455 , GNA, Aug 20, 2004
       KUMASI, GHANA - There was prolonged laughter at the Circuit Court at Kumasi last Tuesday, when a 32-year-old fetish priest told the Court that he was ordered by the gods to marry a 15-year-old girl he defiled.
       Yaw Asenso alias Ashaikro, the fetish priest from Prenyase near Jachie, whose plea was not taken, was sentenced to 20 years imprisonment in hard labour.
       Chief Inspector Agnes Dinkyiri told the Court that Madam Ellen Dzikunu, the victim's mother rented a room in the house of Asenso at Prenyase about four months ago.
       She said Madam Dzikunu's elder daughter started behaving strangely and the accused promised to cure her of the infirmity and succeeded in calming her down after giving her some herbal preparation.
       Chief Inspector Dinkyiri said Asenso requested Madam Dzikunu to invite her other daughter who was in Accra to come for healing since some spirits that could kill her shortly were hunting her.
    • Goa priest charged with child abuse [? 2003-04] -- 13-y-o girl, but faithful object to charge. India flag; Mooney's MiniFlags 
       The Indian Express www.indianexpress.com/full_story.php?content_id=53512 , By RAJU NAYAK, Posted online at 0115 hours IST, Saturday, August 21, 2004
       PANAJI, INDIA, AUGUST 20: The Goa police has filed a case of child abuse and molestation against a parish priest of Ribander village near Panaji, about eight months after the incident, following a complaint from a women's group chief on behalf of the 13-year-old Catholic girl.
       This is the first time the Goa police has initiated action against a Catholic priest in the face of pressure from the villagers who backed him. They are also said to have pressured the molested child and her mother to deny the involvement of the priest in the matter. The villagers had organised a morcha to force the victim to withdraw the complaint.
       A case has been registered under Section 354 of the IPC and Section 8 of the specially formulated Children's Act for Sexual Harassment and Child Abuse and Molestation.
       The matter came to light after social activist Aires Rodrigues, in a written complaint to Archbishop Filip Nerie Rodrigues, demanded action against the priest.
    • Tucson Bankruptcy Dilemma -- Bishop making out the bishop does not have absolute control over Church's assets. U.S.A. flag; Mooney's MiniFlags 
       Religion & Ethics Newsweekly, www.pbs.org/wnet/religionandethics/week751/news.html , August 20, 2004
       UNITED STATES: LUCKY SEVERSON, guest anchor: In Boston, a special mass this week to protest the planned closing of 81 Catholic churches. More than 1,000 Catholics gathered on the Boston Common, mostly priests and parishioners from churches that are scheduled to close in coming weeks. The Boston archdiocese announced the closures in May, saying it was because of declining Mass attendance, a shortage of priests, and the rising cost of upkeep on old buildings. Parishioners say they'll continue to fight the decision.
       And a second Roman Catholic diocese -- this one in Tucson, Arizona -- could soon declare bankruptcy. The diocese faces lawsuits demanding more than $20 million in damages from victims of priestly sex abuse. The Archdiocese of Portland, Oregon, filed for bankruptcy last month. Bankruptcy would allow a judge to determine what assets a diocese must relinquish to compensate victims. But it's a step that raises a number of questions, including issues related to the separation of church and state. Judy Valente reports.
       JUDY VALENTE: On this particular morning, Bishop Gerald Kicanas is doing what he calls his most important work -- being pastor to the people of Tucson. The occasion -- the funeral of a popular 16-year-old who died of leukemia. Though sad, the occasion marked a rare chance for the bishop to escape his most pressing problem: how the keep the diocese functioning and still compensate victims who were sexually abused by priests. [...]
       Ms. CADIGAN: To file for bankruptcy does two things. It re-victimizes the victims and makes them look like the predators -- that they're the ones chasing down the Church for money. It delays their lawsuit; it further prolongs their agony.
       For these boys to come forward was very difficult. The parishioners ostracized them, called them "faggot," and they've had to switch schools. They had to testify in a criminal hearing. It's ruined their lives.
       VALENTE: Cadigan's clients say the priest who abused them is this man: Father Juan Guillen, who is already in prison serving a 10-year sentence for sexual misconduct with a minor.
       The bulk of the other lawsuits against the diocese name this priest: Monsignor Robert Trupia. Although Trupia has not been convicted in a court of law, the Vatican recently forbade him to act as a priest after finding the sexual abuse allegations against him were credible. [...]
       VALENTE: A diocese filing for bankruptcy is entering uncharted legal territory. A bankruptcy court judge could conceivably question a bishop's management decisions and order assets to be sold. A bankruptcy filing would also give victims' attorneys -- and the public -- unprecedented access to a diocese's financial records. Those records could help determine just how much the diocese is worth. The argument is likely to center around property. [...]
       VALENTE: The Tucson diocese says much of the land it directly controls, like this parcel, is scorched desert property with limited resale value. It estimates this and the other property it owns is worth about $3.2 million. But that figure does not include the diocese's 70 parishes, and herein lies the major battle to come in any bankruptcy proceeding: a potential showdown between canon law and civil law.
       Bishop KICANAS: In canon law, it is very clear: I, as a bishop, have absolutely no right to demand the assets of the parishes. Those were given by the people in trust to their own parish for its mission and for its work. # [Posted by Kathy Shaw at 06:31 PM]
       [COMMENT: Statements like Bishop Kicanas's last remark have already been called into question by canon lawyers. COMMENT ENDS.]
    • Private eye seeks FLDS prophet [Jeffs] -- Nephew sues fundamentalist polygamists' leader.
       The Spectrum (Southern Utah's home page), www.thespectrum.com/news/stories/20040820/localnews/1084418.html , By RACHEL OLSEN, rolsen@thespectrum.com, Friday, August 20, 2004
       HILDALE (UT) -- A private investigator attempted Thursday to serve a summons and a copy of a lawsuit alleging sexual abuse by Fundamentalist Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints Prophet Warren Jeffs.
       Sam Brower was hired as an investigator by the firm representing the plaintiff, Brent Jeffs. The plaintiff, 21, alleged in the lawsuit that Warren Jeffs and two of his brothers sexually abused him as a child, according to a court document. Brent Jeffs, the nephew of the FLDS prophet, seeks an unspecified amount in the lawsuit.
       Upon the initial filing of the complaint, Warren Jeffs denied the claims of sexual abuse in a written statement issued through his lawyer, Rodney Parker.
       The FLDS church is based in the twin communities of Hildale and Colorado City and is led by Warren Jeffs, the self-proclaimed prophet. The FLDS church constitutes the largest polygamist group in North America.
       Brower said he had already given the papers to an individual at the new polygamist compound in Texas, where the church built what members say is a retreat for the faithful near Eldorado. However, Brower said he wanted to serve the papers at Warren Jeffs' Utah address.
    • Utah court backs LDS in molest case -- woman and boy. Mormon Church "no responsibility" for known predator.
       The Washington Times, http://washingtontimes.com/upi-breaking/20040820-013123-3618r.htm , UPI, Los Angeles, CA, Aug. 20, 2004
       UTAH: -- A Utah appeals court has ruled the Mormon Church is not responsible for warning members about known sexual predators in their congregations.
       Thursday's ruling from the Utah Court of Appeals came in a lawsuit from a woman who sued the church after a fellow member of her ward who was also a convicted child molester allegedly abused both her and her son.
       The lawsuit alleged that Latter-day Saints leaders knew about the man's past, but ignored it and even allowed him to serve as a Boy Scout leader.
       The court, however, ruled that the church had no special relationship with the alleged molester and the alleged acts took place outside the church.
    • Audit Finds Diocese Of Pittsburgh Complying With Abuse Policies
       ThePittsburghChannel.com ; www.thepittsburghchannel.com/news/3669107/detail.html , August 20, 2004
       PITTSBURGH (PA) -- The Pittsburgh Roman Catholic Diocese said an outside audit found that it is complying with church policies on handling clergy sex abuse cases.
       Two years ago, America's Catholic bishops responded to the clergy sex abuse crisis by adopting a toughened discipline plan that mandated annual reviews of whether the 195 US dioceses were doing enough to protect children.
       The first onsite audits were conducted last year and found 90 percent of dioceses were in compliance with the new policy. Pittsburgh is among the first dioceses to have a second audit.
    • Priest sex abuse an 'industrial accident', says bishop -- girl. Netherlands (Holland) flag; Mooney's MiniFlags 
       Expatica (NEWS AND INFORMATION FOR EXPATS IN THE NETHERLANDS - 21 AUGUST 2004 ), www.expatica.com/source/site_article.asp?subchannel_id=19&story_id=10899 , August 20, 2004
       AMSTERDAM, THE NETHERLANDS: The Dutch Catholic Church has gone to court to force insurer Aegon to reimburse a damages pay-out to a girl who was sexually abused by a priest. The Bishop of Rotterdam claims the abuse was an industrial accident and was covered by the Church's liability insurance, it was reported Friday.
       The Church's legal action against the insurance company began with a preliminary hearing behind closed doors in a court in The Hague on Wednesday, newspaper De Telegraaf reported. Is it expected the court will hear the case in full within the next six weeks.
       The girl was six when she was abused by the priest in Rotterdam. She took a claim against the diocese and in February 2000 she was awarded NLG 100,000 (EUR 45,000) compensation. The priest was prosecuted for the sexual abuse.
       Rotterdam diocese wants Aegon to reimburse it with EUR 58,000 to cover the full cost of dealing with the case because it claims the abuse should formally be seen as an industrial accident.
       To support its claim, it argues the abuse was committed by a clergyman during work hours and in his work place, his local parish. It further argues that there is a risk that a priest performing his pastoral work may carry out such an attack.
       Aegon told the De Telegraaf it could not comment on the matter as it is before the courts but confirmed the insurer is refusing to cover the cost of the compensation claim. [Copyright Expatica 2004] #
    • DA: When will priest face the music? [1994-94 Superiaso] -- girl. U.S.A. flag; Mooney's MiniFlags 
       The Examiner, www.sfexaminer.com/article/index.cfm/i/082004n_priest , By Sabrina Crawford, Friday, August 20, 2004
       REDWOOD CITY (CA) -- The case against a former local Catholic priest accused of molesting a 12-year-old girl hit yet another bump in the rocky road to trial Thursday.
       In his quest to have charges against him dismissed, 50-year-old Jose Superiaso, a former priest at St. Andrew Catholic Church in Daly City, appeared in San Mateo County Superior Court before Judge James Ellis.
       Superiaso faces 24 counts of committing lewd and lascivious acts with a minor under age 14 on multiple occasions between July 1994 and November 1995.
       Over the past three months, Superiaso, who is in jail on $2.5 million bail, has appeared in a veritable courtroom round-robin. On multiple occasions, before a variety of judges, the defense has sought to have the charges against him dropped on the grounds that the statute of limitations on the case has expired.
       However, with paperwork flying back and forth, each judge in turn has delayed making a ruling -- and indeed even hearing the full arguments.
       But with the trial date still set for Aug. 23, the district attorney wants to get the show on the road.
    • Activists call for resignation
       WMTW, www.wmtw.com/Global/story.asp?S=2199826 , 10:07 AM, Friday, August 20, 2004
       PORTLAND (ME) (AP) - The leader of a national support group for people abused by Roman Catholic clergy is asking for the resignation of a member of Maine's clergy review board.
       David Clohessy says the Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests [SNAP] can no longer trust Ann Pulsifer to be objective in her work on the review board, based on comments she made in a weekly church bulletin.
       Pulsifer chairs the pastoral council at St. Mary's Parish in Wells, where Monsignor Joseph Ford is pastor.
       Ford's 1990 memo on abuse allegations against a priest is at the center of an appeal pending before Maine's Supreme Judicial Court.
       Pulsifer wrote that she felt compelled to clarify "distorted reporting in the media" about Ford. She says her comments do not warrant her resignation. #
    • Bush Religion Adviser Quits Campaign Post -- Non-clergyman Baptist, Catholic.
       Washington Post, www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/articles/A17087-2004Aug19.html , By Alan Cooperman, Page A06, Friday, August 20, 2004
       WASHINGTON (DC): Deal W. Hudson, publisher of the conservative Catholic magazine Crisis and a close ally of the Bush White House, has resigned as an adviser to the Bush-Cheney reelection campaign because of allegations that he sexually harassed a Fordham University student a decade ago.
       Hudson, 54, had been a key player in the Republican Party's effort to attract Roman Catholic voters. Because of his connections to the White House and his friendship with senior presidential adviser Karl Rove, he was widely regarded as a Catholic power broker in Washington. ...
       The article that Hudson had anticipated was published yesterday by the weekly National Catholic Reporter. It chronicled how Hudson's once-promising academic career was derailed by the sexual misconduct charge in 1994. The paper's Washington bureau chief, Joseph Feuerherd, denied any political motivation and said in a column that "I went where the story led me."
       The alleged victim, Carastona Poppas, was an 18-year-old Fordham freshman who had been in and out of foster homes since age 7. Hudson was her philosophy teacher, a tenured associate professor who had been a Baptist minister before converting to Catholicism.
       "He knew I was a ward of the court, without parents, severely depressed, and even suicidal," Poppas told the Catholic newspaper. "He was extremely attentive and genuinely concerned."
       That attention allegedly went too far one night in February 1994 when Hudson invited her and several older students to a bar in New York's West Village. They all got drunk, and he had sex with her in his car and office, the paper reported.
       According to a sexual harassment lawsuit she filed the following year, Hudson pleaded with her to remain silent and created an "extraordinarily hostile" classroom environment that "emotionally devastated" her. The paper said Hudson settled the lawsuit for $30,000 in 1996 and moved to Washington, where he revitalized Crisis magazine and caught Rove's eye by devising a GOP strategy to target frequent Mass-attending Catholics in the 2000 election.
       A spokeswoman for Fordham, Elizabeth Schmalz, issued a statement yesterday saying "sexual harassment is not tolerated" at the Catholic university. Without naming either Hudson or his accuser, she said, "Fordham followed its policy rigorously and initiated an investigation into the matter upon the student's complaint. The professor later surrendered his tenure and left the University."
    • Protest targets ex-priests
       Press-Telegram, www.presstelegram.com/Stories/0,1413,204~21474~2346251,00.html , By Kristopher Hanson, Thursday, August 19, 2004
       SEAL BEACH (CA) - Karie Duncan wanted to get her message across to Leisure World's residents and visitors Thursday afternoon, and she couldn't have put it more bluntly.
       Standing outside the retirement community's main entrance on Seal Beach Boulevard, Duncan hoisted a neon green sign above her head reading "Child Molesters Live Here."
       Duncan was one of six people who gathered at a rally outside Leisure World to inform residents that two former priests accused of molesting kids may reside in the private retirement community.
       The group, members of an organization called Survivors Network of Those Abused by Priests, or SNAP, spent the afternoon passing out fliers advising residents and visitors of the accusations against two retired priests thought to be living inside the gated community.
       "How can people protect their kids and grandchildren if they don't know there may be a child molester living next door?" asked Mary Grant, a rally organizer. "We don't want to see another child hurt. We're convinced that child molesters rarely, if ever, stop molesting kids."
    • New suit accuses diocese of concealing real estate assets
       Azcentral.com ; www.azcentral.com/news/articles/0820diocese-lawsuits-ON.html , Associated Press, 07:55 AM, Aug. 20, 2004
       TUCSON (AZ) - Another lawsuit has been filed against the embattled Roman Catholic Diocese of Tucson, accusing it of concealing millions of dollars in real estate assets.
       The suit was filed Thursday in Pima County Superior Court on behalf of 20 plaintiffs who already have actions pending against the diocese.
       The diocese is considering whether to file for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection as a way of meeting financial costs associated with lawsuits alleging clergy sexual abuse of children.
       Diocese spokesman Fred Allison said officials had not seen the suit yet so they could not comment on it.
    • Another lawsuit filed against Tucson Diocese
       KVOA, http://kvoa.com/Global/story.asp?S=2199582 , August 20, 2004
       TUCSON, Ariz. Another lawsuit has been filed against the Tucson Diocese by lawyers accusing the church of hiding millions of dollars in real estate assets.
       The suit was filed in Pima County Superior Court on behalf of 20 plaintiffs who already have actions pending.
       The Arizona Daily Star reports it's the latest attempt by attorneys Lynne M. Cadigan and Kim E. Williamson to discredit the church's finances as the diocese considers possible Chapter eleven reorganization.
       The diocese is weighing whether to file for federal bankruptcy protection as a way of meeting its financial costs associated with the lawsuits.
    • St. Poelten scandal sees hundreds leaving the Catholic Church -- handing back baptismal certificates. Austria flag; Mooney's MiniFlags 
       Die Presse, www.diepresse.at/Artikel.aspx?channel=&ressort=ee&id=438765 , Aug 20, 2004
       VIENNA / ST. POELTEN, AUSTRIA: The Catholic Church in Austria has faced a sharp increase in the number of people leaving the church in the wake of a child porn scandal centred on a priests training college in Lower Austria.
       The figures, which have not yet been published but have been seen by "Die Presse," reveal that the number of people leaving the Church has surpassed religious leaders' greatest fears, with an increase of 185.7 per cent recorded in the affected diocese St. Poelten.
       In Vienna, nearly 30 per cent more people left the Church this July, compared to the same month in 2003. The number is also particularly high in Krems, which recorded a 322.2 per cent increase in the number of people handing back their baptism certificates.
       The figures are particularly alarming because July is traditionally a month where people seldom visit the authorities but observers warn that worse is expected for August. Authorities in Vienna have indicated that the figures for August have reached the same level as 2003 in the first half of the month alone. #
    • Husband Charged in Death [2004 Bynum] -- Cry Out Loud Ministries. U.S.A. flag; Mooney's MiniFlags 
       The Pilot, www.thepilot.com/news/082004Husband.html , BY MATTHEW MORIARTY, Aug 20, 2004
       SANFORD (NC): Law-enforcement officers have charged the pastor of a Sanford church with the murder of his wife, Marnita Bynum.
       Officers arrested Melvin Bynum Thursday night, according to Moore County Sheriff Lane Carter. No other details were available. There will be a press conference at 11 a.m. today at the Richmond County Sheriff's Department.
       Melvin Bynum is a pastor of Cry Out Loud Ministries in Sanford.
       A Richmond County sheriff's deputy found the body of Marnita Bynum, 40, in the trunk of her car Aug. 2. She had died of strangulation, according to an autopsy. Her car was parked on the side of N.C. 177 near Hamlet.
       On Wednesday, Marnita Bynum's mother made an impassioned plea, asking that anyone with information about her daughter's murder to come forward. Officers didn't say whether her plea helped lead to the arrest.
    • N.Y. priest, cleared in past case, charged with sex abuse [1970s, 2000, 2002 Byrns] -- altar boy. Even though priest and his brother had complained, diocese had not banned sex molester.
       Boston Globe, www.boston.com/news/nation/articles/2004/08/20/ny_priest_cleared_in_past_ case_charged_with_sex_abuse ; By Michael Rezendes, August 20, 2004
       NEW YORK: A Brooklyn priest, who continued in active ministry after church officials cleared him of sexual abuse accusations leveled in 1998, yesterday was charged with repeatedly molesting an altar boy as recently as two years ago, after plying the boy with money and toys.
       The Rev. Joseph P. Byrns, who was permanently removed from ministry two months ago, was the pastor at St. Rose of Lima Church in 2000 when he began luring the 11-year-old boy for sexual encounters that gradually "escalated to oral and anal sodomy," according to the district attorney in Kings County, N.Y.
       A son of Haitian immigrants, the boy moved to southern Florida with his family last year and later disclosed the alleged abuse to his parents. Byrns, 61, was arrested Wednesday in Oneonta, in upstate New York, and was being held in New York City on $10,000 bail.
       In 1998, the Rev. Timothy J. Lambert, a New Jersey priest, and his brother, Robert V. Lambert, told officials of the Brooklyn diocese that they were molested by Byrns while growing up in Queens during the 1970s. But church officials, including retired Bishop Thomas V. Daily, sided with Byrns after he insisted he was innocent.
    • Sexual abuse matters pending [2002 Poster, 1970s-80s Wiebler, 1964 Bass] -- 5 defrocking requests.
       Press-Citizen, www.press-citizen.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20040820/NEWS01/408200317/1079 ; Aug 20, 2004
       IOWA: Several sexual abuse matters involving priests who served in Iowa City parishes remain pending, said Rand Wonio, an attorney for the Roman Catholic Diocese of Davenport.
       In February, the diocese asked the Vatican to defrock five priests accused of sexual abuse.
       Three of those priests included Richard Poster, who served as parochial vicar from December 1992 to August 1995 at St. Mary's Church, 302 E. Jefferson St.; William F. Wiebler, who served as an assistant pastor from August 1967 to August 1969 at St. Mary's; and Francis Bass, who worked as the lead pastor from January 1978 to August 1981 at St. Patrick's Church, 228 E. Court St.
       In August 2003, Poster pleaded guilty to a federal count of possession of child pornography. While at an Oxford Junction church in December 2002, 270 computer files containing child pornography were discovered on Poster's computer. He was sentenced to one year in prison and ordered to pay a $3,000 fine.
       Records show the Diocese received a report in 1992 showing that Bass had sexually abused a minor in 1964. In 1998, the Diocese received another report that Bass had abused another minor in the 1960s. Additional allegations of abuse against Bass recently have been received by the Diocese. Bass retired in October 1992 and lives in Davenport.
       The Diocese received allegations of sexual abuse against Wiebler that date back to the 1970s and '80s. The February report states that Wiebler has admitted to several acts of abuse with several minors. His last pastoral position ended in 1985 in Ottumwa and he retired in 1991.
    • Judge allows lawsuit against priest [1970s Sigler, Servants of the Paraclete] -- males.
       Lansing State Journal, www.lsj.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20040820/NEWS01/408200310/1001/news , Associated Press, Published August 20, 2004
       DETROIT (MI) - A judge has refused to throw out a lawsuit filed by two men who say Roman Catholic church officials in Michigan and New Mexico worked together to cover up sexual abuse by a former priest 30 years ago.
       Lawyers for the Diocese of Lansing, the Archdioceses of Detroit and Santa Fe, N.M., and Jason Sigler, ex-priest and convicted pedophile, argued the victims filed their lawsuit too late to address incidents that are three decades old.
       But Wayne County Circuit Court Judge Warfield Moore called the church's shuffling of Sigler from Michigan to New Mexico a conspiracy and suggested the unique relationship between priest and parishioner overrides that the normal statute of limitations to sue had expired.
       "They allowed, with consistency, a one-man wrecking crew to go through, and when it got too hot, they said, 'Go somewhere else,' " he said during a hearing Thursday.
    • Judge: Other testimony in abuse case admissible [1988, '89, '91 Stein] -- boy. Norbertine.
       Post-Crescent, www.wisinfo.com/postcrescent/news/archive/local_17425013.shtml , The Associated Press, Posted Aug. 20, 2004
       GREEN BAY (WI) - The trial of a Norbertine priest accused of molesting a boy in 1988 may include testimony about his conviction in another case and an allegation that didn't lead to charges, a judge ruled Thursday.
       Lawyers for James Stein, 44, sought to bar testimony about Stein's conviction for fourth-degree sexual assault in 1991 and an uncharged allegation of fondling a teen at the St. Norbert Abbey in 1989.
       Defense attorney Stephen Glynn, appearing at the hearing by telephone, said introducing the other incidents would improperly prejudice the jury.
       But Assistant Dist. Atty. Dana Johnson said the other incidents would show a pattern of abuse.
    • Priest seeks plea deal in abuse case [1996, '99 LeClaire] -- boy.
       The Arizona Republic, www.azcentral.com/news/articles/0820EVpriest20.html , by Jim Walsh, Aug. 20, 2004
       MESA (AZ) - A priest accused of child molestation may plead guilty today to a lesser charge.
       The deal, if approved by the Maricopa County Attorney's Office, would cut the Rev. Karl LeClaire's maximum jail time to two years from 24 years.
       LeClaire, 48, former principal of Queen of Peace Catholic School in Mesa, is one of 11 priests from the Diocese of Phoenix accused or convicted of sex crimes involving minors. Mary Jo West, diocesan spokeswoman, said LeClaire is not active but remains a priest.
       LeClaire is charged with child molestation and sexual conduct with a minor stemming from allegations in 1996 and 1999 involving a teen boy.
       Public Defender Dan Sheperd proposed at a settlement conference on Thursday that LeClaire plead guilty to aggravated assault, a felony that can be reduced to a misdemeanor if a defendant completes probation.
    • Church not responsible for abusers -- $US 3m settlement.
       The Salt Lake Tribune, www.sltrib.com/ci_2398232 , By Elizabeth Neff, Aug/20/2004
       SALT LAKE CITY (UT): Churches have no obligation to warn followers about known sexual predators in their congregations, the Utah Court of Appeals ruled Thursday.
       And churches cannot be sued for failing to report suspected child abuse to authorities, as required by state law, the court said.
       The sweeping ruling, issued in a lawsuit against The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, stands to curb suits filed against the church with such allegations.
       Thursday's decision upholds 3rd District Judge Tyrone Medley's dismissal of a lawsuit brought by a mother and son who claimed convicted child molester George K. Tilson of Salt Lake City abused them both while he was a member of the church.
       The suit alleges LDS leaders knew Tilson had sexually abused children in wards where he lived, but never reported the abuse to authorities or warned other church members. Facing similar allegations in past lawsuits, the LDS Church has settled several cases, including a $3 million settlement in a Portland, Ore., lawsuit.
       A church spokesman said the church "strongly disputes" the suit's allegations and is "gratified that the Court of Appeals decided the church cannot be held responsible as an institution when an individual member commits private criminal conduct."
    • Defense of priest met with criticism
       Portland Press Herald, http://pressherald.mainetoday.com/news/state/040820church.shtml , By TOM BELL, Friday, August 20, 2004
       PORTLAND (ME): Ann Pulsifer, a member of the board that reviews sex abuse complaints for Maine's Roman Catholic diocese, said Thursday that calls for her resignation are unwarranted.
       Leaders of a national support group for clergy sex abuse victims are urging Pulsifer to step aside, saying they can no longer trust her to be objective because of her recent public defense of a Wells priest.
       Pulsifer, of Wells, said her comments in a church bulletin were intended to correct what she described as misleading news reports. Her resignation, she said, "does not seem warranted by this simple attempt to clarify media distortion."
       Pulsifer, a clinical psychologist, sits on a 10-member panel the Portland Diocese set up last year to review allegations of abuse and advise church leaders on sexual abuse complaints.
       David Clohessy, national director of the Survivors Network of Those Abused by Priests [SNAP], said Pulsifer should not be taking a public stand on behalf of a priest who is accused of covering up abuse. "She can't do that while maintaining her objectivity as member of this board," he said.
       At issue are comments that Pulsifer made regarding a Portland Press Herald story about a 14-year-old memo at the center of an appeal pending before the state Supreme Court on a priest abuse case. In the memo, Monsignor Joseph Ford gives advice to Auxiliary Bishop Amadee Proulx on how to communicate with a Maryland man who claims that a Maine priest had abused him in the 1980s.
       The Press Herald article, which appeared July 16, said the memo showed that church officials kept their concerns about the priest quiet for fear of liability and scandal. Ford today is pastor at St. Mary's Parish in Wells. Pulsifer chairs the church's pastoral council.
       In the bulletin that the church distributed Sunday, Pulsifer writes that some parishioners have been critical of Ford for covering up complaints of sexual abuse. She felt compelled, she writes, to clarify the "distorted reputation in the media of a man who is our priest and pastor, and to remind ourselves of the danger of gossip, hearsay and the careless use of words." In Ford's 1990 memo, he tells Proulx to "avoid reference to no earlier complaints" about an abusive priest.
       Pulsifer said in an interview that Ford's use of a double negative is an example of how muddled language can get a person in trouble. She said a more careful reading of the memo would show that Ford was recommending that the diocese "not deny" that there had been any other serious concerns about the priest's behavior. "You have someone trying to basically do the right thing," she said.
       Clohessy, however, said the issue is not what Ford wrote 14 years ago. It is about what Pulsifer wrote in this Sunday's bulletin. Even if Pulsifer's interpretation is correct, he said, she shouldn't be defending a priest who is involved in an abuse lawsuit. He said victims of clergy abuse are already skeptical about the objectivity of people on church-appointed review boards.
       "This is not about what Ford said or didn't say," he said. "This is about her taking a public position, which is why it's critical that she avoid any action that seeks to betray bias."
       Pulsifer said she agrees that the review board members should be objective. She said her comments in the church bulletin were about the media, not about Ford's guilt or innocence. She added that her panel has not looked at the case in which Ford is involved and that she is unfamiliar with it.
       The review board is charged with screening allegations of sexual abuse to determine if the diocese should remove a clergy member from the ministry. The review is separate from any criminal or civil process, has no statute of limitations and sets a higher standard for employees than they would face in the courts.
       The panel could recommend a priest's removal even though the same evidence would not result in a criminal charge or support a lawsuit. An official at the diocese could not be reached for comment.
       Staff Writer Tom Bell can be contacted at 791-6369 or at: tbell@pressherald.com #
    • Priest arrested on abuse charges: Man from Brooklyn parish caught at local Holiday Inn. [2000+ Byrns] -- boy.
       The Daily Star, www.thedailystar.com/news/stories/2004/08/20/priest.html , By Jack Mazurak, Aug/20/04
       ONEONTA (NY) - A 61-year-old Catholic priest formerly of a Brooklyn parish vacationing in the area was arrested Wednesday on sex-abuse charges.
       State police in Oneonta said they picked up the Rev. Joseph Byrns at about 4:30 p.m. in a room at the Holiday Inn.
       Senior Investigator Ricky Charles, who made the arrest with another Oneonta investigator, said they got a warrant from Kings County Court and a tip that Byrns was at the motel.
       The warrant, Charles said, charged Byrns with numerous counts of sexual abuse. Byrns had been a priest at the St. Rose of Lima parish in Brooklyn but was suspended in 2002.
       Sources told the New York Post that Byrns began fondling an 11-year-old boy in 2000, then moved on to sodomizing him.
    • Church seeks abuse-claims deadline
       The Oregonian, www.oregonlive.com/news/oregonian/index.ssf?/base/front_page/10930032 8492320.xml ; By NANCY HAUGHT and JEFF MANNING, Friday, August 20, 2004
       PORTLAND (OR): In a bid to learn who has undisclosed plans to sue, the Archdiocese of Portland has proposed a Dec. 31, 2004, deadline for victims of sexual abuse to name themselves and provide details of their ordeals.
       In papers filed Thursday in U.S. Bankruptcy Court, the archdiocese proposed a two-page "tort proof of claim" form. The archdiocese, which serves Western Oregon Catholics, also outlined a plan to advertise the deadline in regional and national news media.
       A church official and a lawyer characterized it as a necessary step to move the bankruptcy proceedings forward. Lawyers for victims roundly condemned the proposed form and media campaign as insensitive.
       The archdiocese sought Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection last month in an effort to shield some of its assets from dozens of lawsuits that have already been filed. It is the first Catholic diocese to file for bankruptcy because of clergy abuse claims, and the Portland case is being closely watched nationwide.
    • Brooklyn priest indicted [2000 Byrns ] -- altar boys.
       Newsday, www.nynewsday.com/news/local/brooklyn/nyc-nyprie203936295aug20,0,671543. story?coll=nyc-homepage-headlines ; BY SEAN GARDINER, August 20, 2004
       NEW YORK: Between the time Roman Catholic Church officials first learned in 1997 of allegations that the Rev. Joseph Byrns had molested two altar boys 30 years ago and finally removed him in June, the cleric allegedly abused another altar boy, law enforcement officials said yesterday.
       Byrns, 61, was ordered held on $10,000 bail after being arraigned in Brooklyn on 22 counts of sexual abuse and sexual conduct against a child.
    Altar boy claims abuse
       An altar boy at St. Rose of Lima Church recently told authorities that in March 2000, when he was 11 years old, Byrns called him and asked him to serve at what he said was a special Saturday Mass at the Midwood church, according to court papers.
       The boy met Byrns at the rectory. After telling the boy the Mass had been canceled, the priest had the boy fondle him, court papers said.
    • A picture speaks volumes [1970s-80s Strittmatter, Doyle, Thomas] -- girl, boy.
       Toledo City Paper, www.toledocitypaper.com/news/editor.html
       UNITED STATES: Last year, school officials at a Catholic high school in Cincinnati removed the portrait of a former principal after abuse allegations surfaced against the priest.
       Tom Otten, the school's principal, told The Cincinnati Enquirer at the time that he removed the portrait because "having the picture up is, I think, sending the wrong message. We're not supporting anything that happened. We don't want to send that message, and we don't want to have to defend it."
       The priest, the Rev. Lawrence Strittmatter, was accused by at least 10 men of abusing them during the 1970s and '80s.
       In California, abuse allegations announced in 2002 led a bishop to order the removal of photos honoring a priest who had served as principal at two schools. The Los Angeles Times reported that Santa Margarita High School even removed mention of the priest from the history section of the school's Web site.
       More recently, victims of priest sexual abuse in the Toledo area have requested similar consideration, but, as detailed in the Toledo City Paper's Aug. 5-11 issue, tributes to abusive priests continue to adorn numerous area churches.
       At the Catholic Center in Downtown Toledo, an entire wing is named after the late Msgr. Michael Doyle. Doyle was admired as an activist and labor mediator, but he also faced abuse allegations which resulted in a monetary settlement to the victim. The victim, 57-year-old Connie Davis, has demanded that the tributes to Doyle be removed, but her demands have not been met.
       Perhaps more bothersome is the case of Robert Thomas, whose portrait hangs at Our Lady of Perpetual Help in South Toledo. Thomas was arrested on a sex charge involving a 16-year-old boy and barred from ministry in Toledo. Thomas' case may be extreme, but the sordid details apparently weren't extreme enough for the diocese to consider what leaving his picture in place means.
    • Newspaper drudges up regrettable past of Crisis magazine's Deal Hudson [? 1995] -- female.
       Cruxnews, www.cruxnews.com/articles/hudson-20aug04.html , Aug 20, 2004
       WASHINGTON (DC) -- Deal W. Hudson, longtime advisor to President George W. Bush on Catholic issues, has resigned his role in the president's re-election campaign. Hudson announced his decision in an article published this week in National Review Online.
       Hudson, the publisher of the Washington D.C.-based Crisis magazine, explained that a forthcoming article from a "liberal Catholic publication" will expose regrettable aspects of his past, including the fact that he has had multiple marriages and has weathered at least one allegation of sexual harassment from a female student at a college where Hudson once taught.
       The New York Times revealed that the sex allegation led to Hudson's resignation from Fordham University, where Hudson taught Philosophy from 1989-1995, just prior to being hired as the editor of Crisis magazine.
    • Mothers of both defendant and victim speak [Horton] -- girl. U.S.A. flag; Mooney's MiniFlags 
       The Daily Journal, www.mydjconnection.com/articles/2004/08/18/community/news3.txt , By TERESA RESSEL, Aug 18, 2004
       FARMINGTON (MO): The defendant's mother described her son as a dedicated husband and father and an asset to the Park Hills community.
       Patrick Horton's mother was one of three witnesses called by the defense to testify during the sentencing phase of the trial.
       His mother said that growing up, he never got in trouble and had a lot of friends. "Teachers liked him," she said. "He was a typical teenage boy."
       The youngest of eight children, Horton wrestled in high school and "found the Lord" at the age of 17.
       He married his wife and now has a stepson, a daughter from a previous marriage and a daughter with his current wife. The couple began working with the youth not long after they married.
       "(Patrick and his wife) have been there for anyone who needed them, old or young," she said.
       She told the jury that she doesn't believe he did what the girl accused ... [Posted by Kathy Shaw at 02:50 AM]
    • Jury finds former youth pastor guilty [2002 Horton] -- Harvest Assembly of God.
       The Daily Journal, www.mydjconnection.com/articles/2004/08/18/community/news2.txt , By TERESA RESSEL, Aug 18, 2004
       FARMINGTON (MO): A former St. Francois County youth pastor was found guilty of second-degree statutory sodomy Tuesday afternoon.
       The jury deliberated for nearly four hours before coming to their verdict. The verdict was delivered exactly two years to the date after the alleged crime had occurred.
       Patrick Horton, 33, of Desloge, had worked as a part-time youth pastor at Harvest Assembly of God just outside Park Hills for eight months before the allegations were made. He was also president of Liberty Outreach, which operated the Fire Escape Youth Center in downtown Park Hills. The youth center was not part of the church and is no longer in operation.
       The jury recommended that he be sentenced to two years in prison. The jury could have recommended up to seven years in prison.
       Circuit Court Judge Sandra Martinez ordered a presentence investigation report, which is compiled by the State Board of Probation and Parole, and set formal sentencing for Oct. 8.
       Horton was placed in custody after the judge revoked his bond.
    • Former Youth Minister Charged [2000s Garrison] -- Grace Community Church. -- female.
       TheBakersfieldChannel.com ; www.thebakersfieldchannel.com/news/3644727/detail.html
       WASCO (CA): A former Youth Ministry director and teacher in Wasco has been charged with three counts of having unlawful sex with a 17-yr old girl.
       William Garrison was arrested on Wednesday, following a three month investigation by the Kern County Sheriff's Department.
       "The fact he was 27 at the time," said Sgt. Joe McDonald, "and the position of trust that he was in being a youth counselor, made this a bit more serious."
       Sgt. McDonald also stressed that even though the teenager told investigators the sex was consensual, in California, it's illegal to have sex with a minor.
       Garrison's relationship with the girl allegedly began, while he was director of Youth Ministry at Grace Community Church in Wasco.
       He was removed from that position one year ago, after what church officials described as an inappropriate "non-sexual" relationship between Garrison and the girl in the church youth group.
    • Sanford man charged in death of wife whose body found in trunk [2004 Bynum] -- Cry Out Loud Ministries.
       Winston-Salem Journal, www.journalnow.com/servlet/Satellite?pagename=WSJ%2FMGArticle%2FWSJ_BasicArticle &c=MGArticle&cid=1031777424171&path=!localnews&s= 1037645509099 ; Associated Press
       SANFORD, N.C. - The husband of a woman whose body was found in the trunk of her car was charged Thursday with first-degree murder in her death, authorities said.
       Melvin Bynum, 43, of Sanford, was charged with murder in the death of Marnita Bynum, 40, said Moore County sheriff's Chief Deputy Neil Godfrey. The Richmond County Sheriff's Office had issued the warrant earlier Thursday. ...
       The Richmond County Sheriff's Office has scheduled a press conference at 11 a.m. Friday at the courthouse in Rockingham to discuss the case. Authorities there refused to say Thursday what led to Melvin Bynum's arrest.
       Her husband, pastor at Cry Out Loud Ministries in Sanford, had filed for divorce June 18. The couple had been separated since October 2001, according to court records.
    • City pastor arrested over sex crimes [Vahle] -- Lutheran.
       Commercial Appeal, www.commercialappeal.com/mca/local_news/article/0, 1426,MCA_437_3123517,00.html , By Stephen D. Price, August 20, 2004
       WHITEHAVEN (TN): A Whitehaven pastor has been charged with 41 counts of sexual assault and misconduct with a minor and will soon be extradited to Arizona to face the charges.
       Michael Vahle, 53, pastor of Our Savior Lutheran Church on Elvis Presley Boulevard, was arrested there Wednesday. Michael Amsden, council president of the 25-member church, said the congregation is shocked.
       "He's been a real good pastor," Amsden said. "He's intelligent. Articulate."
       Memphis Insp. Matt McCann said his department received a call from Arizona Wednesday about Vahle's arrest warrant.
       McCann said Vahle will be extradited as soon as authorities from Prescott, Ariz., pick him up. He said there have been no complaints against Vahle in Memphis.
    • Outrage over priest [1970s, 2000-02 Byrns] -- boys.
       New York Post, www.nypost.com/news/regionalnews/27216.htm , August 20, 2004
       NEW YORK: The Diocese of Brooklyn was harshly criticized yesterday for keeping on the job an accused child-molesting priest who allegedly went on to rape a young altar boy.
       "I always knew it was going to happen again," said Robert Lambert.
       He and his brother, the Rev. Timothy Lambert, told the diocese in 1997 they had been molested as kids in Queens by the Rev. Joseph Byrns in the early 1970s, only to see the Catholic priest allowed to remain as a parish's pastor.
       "They put every child in Brooklyn in harm's way," said Lambert, 48, singling out Bishop Thomas Daily for not taking action against Byrns in 1997, when he headed the diocese. "I think he should be accountable for this . . . He was the shepherd, and he never took care of his flock. He didn't protect little children, and that's sinful. He didn't care."
       In Brooklyn Supreme Court yesterday, Byrns, 61, pleaded not guilty to two felonies and 20 misdemeanors related to allegedly sodomizing and fondling the altar boy at St. Rose of Lima Church in Kensington. The alleged abuse began in 2000 when the child was age 11, and ended two years later.
    • Former pastor under fire [Lyons, Wempe]
       Daily Pilot, www.latimes.com/news/local/pilot/news/la-dpt-priest20aug20,1,3857687. story?coll=la-tcn-pilot-news , by Marisa O'Neil, Aug 20, 2004
       SEAL BEACH (CA) - A group of abuse survivors gathered outside of Leisure World Thursday afternoon to let residents know that two of their neighbors, including a former pastor at a Costa Mesa church, have faced sexual-abuse charges.
       Denis Lyons, 70, former pastor at St. John the Baptist Catholic Church, and 63-year-old Michael Wempe, a former Catholic priest in Los Angeles, both live in the retirement community, according to members of the Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests [SNAP].
       Though neither has been convicted of a crime, residents - some who have grandchildren visit the complex on a regular basis - should know about the accusations, said Esther Miller, the group's Orange County coordinator.
       "The wolf is not just knocking at the door," warned Karie Duncan, one of half a dozen survivors protesting outside the community on Thursday. "He lives next door."
       The group organized the peaceful protest after Wempe was released from a Los Angeles jail last weekend. A superior court judge lowered Wempe's bail last week, while the former priest awaits trial on charges he engaged in lewd and lascivious acts with a child under 14.
    • Abuse Victims Bring Message to Leisure World [1977-86 Wempe; Lyons]
       Los Angeles Times, www.latimes.com/news/local/la-me-priests20aug20,1,908369.story?coll=la-headlines-california , By David Reyes, Aug 20, 2004
       CALIFORNIA: Several activists who describe themselves as victims of sexual abuse picketed at Leisure World in Seal Beach on Thursday and told residents that their grandchildren could be at risk because two Roman Catholic priests who have been charged with child molestation were living there.
       "We're troubled that children visiting their grandparents here are being placed at risk," said Mary Grant, regional director of Survivors Network of Those Abused by Priests (SNAP).
       Retired priest Michael Wempe, who is free on bond awaiting trial, and Father Denis Lyons, 70, have moved into homes behind the gated retirement development, according to SNAP and news reports. A spokesperson for Leisure World could not be reached for confirmation.
       Last summer, Wempe, 64, was charged with 42 counts of sexually molesting 13 boys between 1977 and 1986. A few days later, the U.S. Supreme Court struck down a 1994 California law that allowed retroactive prosecution involving older sex crimes against children. As a result, criminal charges against Wempe were dismissed.
    • Portland, Ore., Archdiocese asks for Dec. 31 deadline for abuse victims claims [80 complainants expected]
       KWWL, www.kwwl.com/Global/story.asp?S=2198403
       PORTLAND, Ore. The Archdiocese of Portland -- the first American diocese to file for bankruptcy -- has asked an Oregon federal judge to set a December 31st deadline for priest sex abuse victims to come forward.
       The archdiocese contends the deadline is necessary so that it can establish a firm estimate of the number of potential lawsuits to help settle creditor claims.
       The diocese filed protection under federal bankruptcy law last month.
       At least 60 alleged victims have pending claims against the archdiocese. And another 20 are expected to file claims.
       An attorney for 17 of those victims says the deadline is unrealistic.
    • Court rejects complaint [1987 Consedine] -- females. New Zealand flag; Mooney's MiniFlags 
       Otago Daily Times, www.odt.co.nz
       CHRISTCHURCH, NEW ZEALAND: A Christchurch woman has had her case against the Catholic Church, over its handling of a sexual misconduct complaint, thrown out by the courts.
       The Christchurch High Court struck out a statement of claim by Bonnie Quilter, a Shirley invalid beneficiary, who alleged the Church had improperly handled her complaint against former Lyttelton priest Jim Consedine.
       Ms Quilter was one of four women who laid complaints of sexual misconduct against Father Consedine.
       She met Father Consedine as a chaplain at Christchurch Women's Prison when she was an inmate in 1987. She claims he later started acting in an over-familiar way, making lewd suggestions and touching her bottom while hugging.
       The Church accepted complaints from the three other women as credible.
       Describing Ms Quilter's statement of claim as "unintelligible", Justice John Hansen said she was essentially alleging that there was a "conspiracy" between several people dealing with her complaint.
       This had prevented her from becoming aware of protocol documents for the investigation of sexual abuse complaints against priests.
    • Colombian's 'adoption' by priest too good to be true [1982 + Mitchell] -- male. U.S.A. flag; Mooney's MiniFlags 
       Seattle Post-Intelligencer, http://seattlepi.nwsource.com/local/187185_ariza20.html , By CLAUDIA ROWE
       WASHINGTON: For years, Ariel Ariza believed that his name was Ariel Mitchell. It was listed on his birth certificate, passport and the papers he filed to enroll at Highline Community College. But it was not a name Ariza ever embraced.
       Every time he wrote "Mitchell," it reminded him of the day that the Rev. James Mitchell arrived in his rural mountain village in Colombia -- half a day's walk from the nearest road -- with offers of a way out of poverty, an escape from violence. And, he says, it reminded him of what happened afterward: five years of sexual abuse under the guise of a caring, adoptive father.
       In 1982, Ariza badly needed help. He was 17 years old, and terrified. The priest's arrival in town coincided with his own homecoming from the hospital, where he'd been treated for a bullet wound to the chest. The guerrilla fighters who shot him had already killed his father and sister.
       Although he had known the priest for less than a day, Mitchell's suggestion that Ariza leave home and enroll -- for free -- at the priest's school, El Camino, sounded like a godsend.
    • Priest Who Denied Sex Abuse Faces Charges in a New Case [2002 Byrns] -- altar boy.
       The New York Times, www.nytimes.com/2004/08/20/nyregion/20priest.html , By WILLIAM GLABERSON, Published August 20, 2004
       NEW YORK: A Roman Catholic priest who drew attention two years ago when he took to his Brooklyn pulpit to deny sexual abuse accusations was indicted yesterday on charges of abusing an 11-year-old altar boy the same year.
       In the spring of 2002, the priest, the Rev. Joseph P. Byrns, drew sympathy from some of his parishioners, and extensive news coverage, by taking an aggressive approach to allegations that he abused an altar boy 30 years earlier at a church in Douglaston, Queens. He called his first accuser a tortured person "more to be pitied than condemned."
       But in the charges unsealed yesterday, the Brooklyn district attorney, Charles J. Hynes, said that in the spring of 2002, Father Byrns repeatedly called his 11-year-old victim to St. Rose of Lima Church in Kensington, Brooklyn, though on many occasions there was no legitimate reason for doing so.
       The indictment said Father Byrns gave the boy money and toys and threatened him to try to maintain his silence. Father Byrns, 61, was charged with 2 felony and 20 misdemeanor counts of sexual abuse.
       He pleaded not guilty yesterday and was to be released on $10,000 bail. His lawyer, Jonathan Fink, declined to comment.
    • Judge: Prosecutors may call witnesses from other incidents [1988-89, '91 Stein] -- Norbertine.
       Duluth News Tribune, www.duluthsuperior.com/mld/duluthsuperior/news/politics/9446099.htm , Associated Press
       GREEN BAY, Wis. - The trial of a Norbertine priest accused of molesting a boy in 1988 may include testimony about his conviction in another case and an allegation that didn't lead to charges, a judge ruled Thursday.
       Lawyers for James Stein, 44, sought to bar testimony about Stein's conviction for fourth-degree sexual assault in 1991 and an uncharged allegation of fondling a teen at the St. Norbert Abbey in 1989.
       Defense lawyer Stephen Glynn, appearing at the hearing by telephone, said introducing the other incidents would improperly prejudice the jury.
       But Assistant District Attorney Dana Johnson said the other incidents would show a pattern of abuse.
    • Report: four Washington priests accused of abuse lived with boys
       KGW, www.kgw.com/sharedcontent/APStories/stories/D84ILR1G0.html , Associated Press, Aug/20/2004
       WASHINGTON: Four Roman Catholic priests in Washington state who left church ministry because of sexual abuse allegations had boys living with them in church-owned properties, a newspaper reported Thursday.
       Records and interviews show that nationally, dozens of priests accused of molesting minors lived with children, often serving as guardians to young boys who stayed in church rectories, the Seattle Post-Intelligencer reported in a copyright story.
       The P-I said most of the victims it interviewed saw few options for escape once they were living with the priests.
       "I didn't know which was worse - either I was going to be beaten by my ex-father, or I was going to have this other abuse," said P.J., now 34, who recently filed a lawsuit alleging that the Rev. Arthur Mertens, then of St. Patrick's Parish in Walla Walla, raped him repeatedly.
       The rapes allegedly began when P.J. was 12.
    • Brooklyn Priest Again Accused of Abuse [2000-02 Byrns] -- altar boy. Even when a priest-victim complained, nothing was done.
       The Telegraph, www.macon.com/mld/macon/news/nation/9448787.htm , By LUKAS I. ALPERT, Associated Press
       NEW YORK - A Roman Catholic priest who has been charged with sexually abusing an 11-year-old altar boy committed the crimes while decades-old allegations against him were making headlines, prosecutors allege.
       Queens prosecutors in 2002 had found two adult brothers' abuse claims against the Rev. Joseph Byrns credible, but the statute of limitations had expired. On Thursday, prosecutors in Brooklyn announced that Byrns had been charged with abusing the altar boy for two years, beginning in the spring of 2000.
       Bob Lambert, 48, said Thursday that the latest abuse could have been averted if the Brooklyn Diocese had listened to the claims he made in 1997 with his brother, the Rev. Timothy Lambert, a priest in the Diocese of Metuchen, N.J.
       Diocesan officials never contacted the brothers, although they publicly said they investigated the charges and found no evidence to support them, said Bob Lambert, of Las Vegas.
       "I'm very disgusted with it," said Lambert, who has sued the diocese. "There was no reason for this to happen."
    • Man says sex with priest began at 11 [Olszewski]
       Seattle Post-Intelligencer, http://seattlepi.nwsource.com/local/187183_albert20.html , By MICHELLE NICOLOSI
       WASHINGTON: Albert Green vividly remembers the first time he saw the home of the Rev. Ed Olszewski, the priest who cared for him when he was 11.
       "The first day, I was so excited. I went running through the church. Everything was so pretty -- it was like a mansion. It had 12 bedrooms and six bathrooms. It was humongous," said Green, 46, who lives in Lynnwood.
       He also remembers that Olszewski didn't wait long to establish that their relationship would be sexual.
       Green said that first night, they went to Olszewski's bedroom and drank some wine. Then Olszewski took out some Vaseline and "he was rubbing it on me, on my front and my back. He put it up into my rectum. I felt something really weird. I just turned over and felt something else go inside of it." [Posted by Kathy Shaw at 02:03 AM]
    ////////// End of Clergy Sex Abuse Tracker www.ncrnews.org/abuse , Fri August 20, 2004
    Abuse Chronology: http://www.multiline.com.au/~johnm/ethics/ethcont93.htm
    • Atheist helps Church to tackle sex problem. Australia flag; Aust. Nat. Flag Assn.  Vatican City flag; Mooney's MiniFlags  Canada flag; Mooney's MiniFlags 
       The Catholic Leader (Brisbane, Queensland, Australia), www.catholicleader.com.au/ prinfriendly.php?num=2010 , by Peter Bugden, for issue of Aug 22, 2004 (sighted on WWW Aug 20, 2004)
       Psychologist Dr Bill Marshall's extensive experience in the treatment of child sex offenders and research in the area prompted Vatican officials to seek his advice on the issue. Reporter PETER BUGDEN spoke with him about his recommendations.
       AUSTRALIA: Dr Bill Marshall, as an atheist, was pleasantly surprised when invited into the Vatican to offer advice on what the Church should do about child sex abuse.
       Dr Marshall, 68, an Australian-born Canadian, was hand-picked by Vatican officials to be part of a group of scientific experts to visit Rome in April last year for a symposium to advise them on addressing child sex abuse among priests and religious.
       He warned them he was a non-believer before he accepted the invitation, thinking that may make a difference.
       'But they said "No, you're just what we want. We want objective presentations of evidence".'
       Dr Marshall was in Australia in recent weeks to talk to corrections staff and therapists in some states about developments in the treatment of sex offenders.
       While he was here he has shared his insights with Church groups and some leaders, meeting with Archbishop Philip Wilson of Adelaide and Archbishop Adrian Doyle of Hobart and giving public talks for Church groups in those cities. He also gave a presentation in Sydney.
       Dr Marshall said that, following the symposium in Rome, the Vatican had asked him for further submissions.
       He had used that material as the basis for his presentations to Church groups in Australia.
       The professor emeritus of psychology and psychiatry at Queen's University in Kingston, Ontario, was invited to Rome because of his expertise in treating child sex offenders and how to reduce the chances of them re-offending.
       He said he and the other experts were asked to give evidence collected over more than 30 years on child sexual abuse and how it related to priests and brothers who had abused children.
       'I had reservations about getting involved - I thought it may have been a public relations exercise but that wasn't the case,' Dr Marshall said.
       'I was very impressed - their concern was the protection of children, not the protection of the Church, not saving the Church money by avoiding litigation. Their concern was to protect the children.'
       The three main points Dr Marshall suggested the Church focus on were the screening of those seeking to become priests and brothers, education of candidates, and appropriate monitoring after ordination or profession.
       He said screening could help identify traits that indicate a candidate may be a risk of abusing children.
       These include narcissism, which studies have shown 'is astonishingly higher among those priests (who have offended) than the population at large and much higher than among priests who have not offended'.
       For some the risk traits may be too pronounced for them to be accepted after screening, but Dr Marshall says proper counselling could open the way for others to proceed to priesthood without being a risk.
       He admitted it was not easy to identify people with traits that would lead to them being a risk 'but some things jump out and we know about some of these that make some people more a risk'.
       'The Church needs to fund research so we can get a better handle so that we can distinguish these guys from those that don't offend,' he said.
       Dr Marshall drew criticism from victims support groups in Australia for his comments against the United States Church's zero tolerance policy on priest child sex offenders.
       He has spoken against offenders being banished from the priesthood, describing that approach as 'a recipe for disaster'. His position is not, however, one of leniency.
       His view was that, once a convicted priest has served his sentence, they should return to some role within the Church, but not to a ministry where they would be a danger to children.
       'What I'm saying is if they're kept in the fold and given a job that keeps them away from children and where they can be monitored there is less chance of them re-offending,' he said.
       The aim should be to ensure proper monitoring and access to treatment, Dr Marshall said.
       'I understand the victims and the need for vengeance, because (the abusers) have hurt innocent people, and children especially.
       'We've just got to put that aside. If we wreak vengeance on these guys we're only increasing the risk of them re-offending (and) the price is another child being a victim.'
       The bottom line is to prevent other children being abused.
       Dr Marshall said there was evidence around the world to indicate that psychological treatment of offenders can be successful.
       An assessment of 43 programs indicated a 50 per cent drop in the rate of re-offending was achieved with treatment. (Picture: Dr Bill Marshall) [Emphasis added]
       [COMMENT: The Christian scriptures contain a statement that Jesus said he would send another helper (paraclete), the spirit of truth, who would "lead you to the complete truth." (John's Gospel, 16:7 and 13). Jesus also said he would be with his followers until the end of the age (Matthew 28:20). Have the leaders of this Church lost such heavenly guidance, and so are asking for advice from an atheist? Perhaps heaven is turning the atheist into a child of Abraham along the lines suggested in Matthew 3:9 and Luke 3:8.
       If so, perhaps he will rethink his opposition to expelling the corrupting clergy, when his soul is imbued with "No man, having put his hand to the plough, and looking back, is fit for the kingdom of God." (Luke 9:62) He might also start teaching the Vatican the sentiments in Hebrews 6:4-6, 1 John 5:16-18, and 1 Corinthians 16:22. COMMENT ENDS.] [To publish Aug 22, sighted Aug 20, 04]

    Abuse Chronology: http://www.multiline.com.au/~johnm/ethics/ethcont93.htm
    #### Clergy Sex Abuse Tracker, www.ncrnews.org/abuse, Sat August 21, 2004 edition follows:-
    • Mother's appeal brings tip in Bynum murder case [2004 Bynum] -- Cry Out Loud Ministries. U.S.A. flag; Mooney's MiniFlags 
       Fayetteville Online, www.fayettevillenc.com/story.php?Template=region&Story=6519077 , By Julia Oliver, Aug-21-2004
       ROCKINGHAM, NORTH CAROLINA - Investigators received new information about the murder of Marnita Bynum after her mother made a public appeal for help in solving the case, the Richmond County Sheriff's Office said Friday.
       Melvin Bynum, pastor of Cry Out Loud Ministries in Sanford, was charged Thursday with his wife's murder. At his first appearance in Richmond County on Friday, a judge ordered him held without bail.
       Jacquelyn Carter, Marnita's mother, said Friday that she had mixed feelings about the arrest. She worried that her grandchildren, who are 20 and 17, would be left without parents.
       "I don't want him to be guilty," she said. "But I want justice."
       Richmond County Sheriff Dale Furr would not elaborate on what information led to the murder charge. He said the investigation was hampered by a lack of cooperation from members of Bynum's church. [Posted by Kathy Shaw at 06:05 PM]
    • Priest named in lawsuit placed on leave [1936-91 Murphy, Sisters of Saint Joseph]
       Boston Globe, www.boston.com/dailynews/234/region/Priest_named_in_lawsuit_placed:.shtml , Associated Press, Aug/21/2004
       BOSTON (MA) (AP) A priest named in a lawsuit alleging abuse at a now-defunct school for the deaf has accepted a voluntary leave of absence while allegations against him are investigated, the Archdiocese of Boston said Saturday.
       The allegation against the Rev. Charles J. Murphy, who is also a part-time chaplain at the state prison at Norfolk and part time chaplain to the archdiocesan deaf apostolate, was regarding an incident alleged to have taken place about 25 years ago, the archdiocese said.
       Murphy was among nuns, priests and administrators named as defendants in a suit brought in May by former students of the Boston School for the Deaf. The Congregation of Sisters of Saint Joseph served as the faculty and administration of the school, which was operated by an independent, nonprofit corporation. The school, in Randolph, closed a decade ago.
       Murphy, who was ordained in 1960, served as a chaplain at the school, archdiocese spokesman the Rev. Christopher Coyne said.
       A message left at St. Francis Xavier Parish in Weymouth, where Murphy is in residence and has been serving a part-time assignment, was not immediately answered.
       In two separate lawsuits, 18 former students at the school claim they were beaten, sexually molested and emotionally tormented by the nuns who ran the school. On Tuesday, attorney Mitchell Garabedian said he has 80 clients altogether who claim they were abused at the school between 1936 and 1991, when they were between the ages of 4 and 17.
    • Bail denied for Lee pastor [2004 Bynum]
       News Observer www.newsobserver.com/news/story/1549797p-7736178c.html , By JOSH SHAFFER, Aug 21, 2004
       ROCKINGHAM, NORTH CAROLINA-- Handcuffed, his legs in shackles, the Rev. Melvin Bynum shuffled into a Richmond County courtroom Friday, charged with strangling his wife and stuffing her body into the trunk of her silver convertible.
       The victim's mother, Jacquelyn Carter, sat waiting as Bynum, 43, passed by in his orange jail jumpsuit. She wore a T-shirt with her daughter Marnita's face printed on the front, and the message "He only takes the best" on the back.
       Just before Bynum returned to jail, she leaned forward and told the pastor, "I forgive you, and I love you."
       She wept as deputies led her outside the courtroom. "My heart hurts," said Carter, who lives in Chicago and decided to stay until investigators made an arrest. "He hasn't been tried. He is not on trial."
       District Court Judge Hunt Gwyn denied bail in Bynum's first-degree murder case and scheduled his next court date for Sept. 2. Prosecutors plan to seek the death penalty.
       But Bynum's attorney said he plans to prove his innocence. (Picture: Melvin Bynum is charged with murder in wife's death.)
    • Pastor's guilty verdict confirmed by judge [1996-97 de Nysschen] -- 9-y-o girl, Ark Christian Ministries. South Africa flag; Mooney's MiniFlags 
       IOL, www.iol.co.za/ index.php?set_ id=1 &click_ id=13&art_ id=vn2004082 1115026150 C235555 ; by Tania Broughton, 01:18PM, August 21 2004
       SOUTH AFRICA: He was a feisty - if somewhat controversial - campaigner for the homeless, always surrounded by supporters.
       But on Friday, the head of the Ark Christian Ministries, Pastor Derich de Nysschen, was all alone when Durban Regional Magistrate Trevor Levitts confirmed that he was guilty of raping and indecently assaulting a young relative.
       The man who stood his ground for months when the Point Development Company wanted to shut down his shelter, now has a different battle on his hands - and, if he loses, he faces between 10 and 15 years in jail.
       It has been a legally complicated case, which has dragged on since the 1999, when De Nysschen was initially convicted of raping and indecently assaulting the nine-year-old girl in 1996 and 1997.
    • Anglicans to screen for sexual predators Australia flag; Aust. Nat. Flag Assn. 
       Sydney Morning Herald, www.smh.com.au/articles/2004/08/21/1092972820931.html , By Sarah Price, The Sun-Herald, August 22, 2004
       AUSTRALIA: Anglicans to be ordained to the ministry could be made to undergo a stringent series of background and personality checks, including a psycho-sexual assessment, if a raft of recommendations designed to prevent child sex abuse in the Anglican Church are adopted.
       A report by the church's Child Protection Committee, which has called the church's past actions on child abuse appalling, has made 26 recommendations in what it calls a comprehensive plan for action.
       Committee chairman Garth Blake, SC, said the church had been through "a dreadful time" in the past three years.
       "How bad does it have to get before we face up to the problems we have?" Mr Blake asked.
       The committee recommends that the screening of candidates for ordination to the ministry should include a medical report, a children's commission background check or a criminal history check, a psycho-sexual assessment and a safe ministry check, which includes 28 questions on issues such as criminal history and addiction.
    • $1.19 million settlement will be paid, bishop says; at least 2 claims against Toledo diocese unresolved U.S.A. flag; Mooney's MiniFlags 
       Toledo Blade, www.toledoblade.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20040821/NEWS02/408210445/-1/NEWS , By DAVID YONKE, BLADE RELIGION EDITOR, Aug 21, 2004
       TOLEDO (OH): The Toledo Catholic Diocese has agreed to pay $1.19 million to settle all but one of 19 lawsuits involving 23 people who alleged sexual abuse of minors by clergy, Bishop Leonard Blair announced yesterday.
       Individual settlements ranged from $4,500 to $150,000, according to a source familiar with the cases.
       However, one victim, Jon Schoonmaker, said last night that he told the diocese he had changed his mind and would not sign an agreement, which means at least two lawsuits are still unresolved.
       Bishop Blair, in a statement released yesterday, said "final settlement arrangements" are still pending in several cases.
       The unresolved issues involve the wording of public acknowledgements that credible allegations of sexual abuse have been made against specific priests, according to Catherine Hoolahan, a Toledo attorney representing 12 people who filed 10 suits.
    • The Real "Real Deal"
       TCR News, http://tcrnews2.com//NewsFeature4.html , By Deacon Keith Fournier, © Third Millennium, LLC, ~ Aug 21, 2004
       WASHINGTON (DC): Says a conservative Catholic activist: "The White House has a Catholic strategy and its name is Deal Hudson."
       I made this comment this several months ago, off the record, in an interview on a very different story that was being written by a reporter from the "independent" newspaper, The National Catholic Reporter. That article concerned, according to the writer, the "Bush administrations outreach to Catholics." I told the writer that I was not a "conservative" but rather a Catholic who informed my political participation by my faith, so I rejected all the political labels. I told the writer that I was pro-life, pro-family, pro-freedom, pro-poor and pro-peace. Back when I was contacted, the article was to be on whether the White House had an effective Catholic Outreach.
       The same reporter called me last week and asked if I would allow myself to be named for attribution to the quote with which I began this article, the only thing that survived from our interview. I repeated that I was not a conservative, certainly not a liberal and not a neo-conservative. He asked me whether I knew what was happening and then told me that he had not yet completed his story and the "turn" that the article had taken. I was shocked. I knew nothing of the "past" concerning Deal Hudson except that he was a convert from the Baptist Christian tradition. I met him back in the early nineties. ...
       However, Deal Hudson is a faithful Catholic, has a brilliant intellect, is a wonderful writer and is a voice for faithful Catholics, other Christians and other people of good will, around the globe, in an age that desperately needs such voices to drown out the rising tide of neo-paganism. He is also my brother in the Lord through our Baptism. That gives me the highest of obligations toward his soul, his family and his flourishing.
       The entire matter demands that we who desire to be Catholic first, pause and consider the current state of the political discourse and our involvement in it. We should all condemn the injurious way in which the past was used in this article to hurt a man who had not only reconciled with his past, but also followed absolutely everything that the Church invites every repentant sinner to do! Look, either the Sacrament of Reconciliation is efficacious or our claim to mercy for all men and women -and the invitation to newness that lies at the heart of the Christian claim - are not true. Secondly, both the Canon Law and the Churches clearly articulated and sensitively applied process of declaring purported "marriages" in some peoples past a "nullity" are effective and true, or they are not. As a convert, Deal dealt with all of all of this in good order and according to the teaching of the Church that he has joined with a willingness to serve without reservation.
       Let me fully go on the record. Deal Hudson was maligned. It was poor journalism at best and represented the worst kind of misunderstanding of the integration of faith and life by this writer. The way that Deal has handled this injustice through his honest ownership of his past is commendable. He has only affirmed for me what I already knew. Deal Hudson is a faithful Catholic who underwent a genuine conversion, which is still underway. May the same be said of every one of us?  . . .
    • Former altar boy asks court to proceed with abuse lawsuit [1980s Grammond] -- boy.
       The Oregonian, www.oregonlive.com/news/oregonian/index.ssf?/base/news/1093089422215830.xml , By JEFF MANNING, Saturday, August 21, 2004
       PORTLAND (OR): In the first of what could be dozens of similar pleas, a former Catholic altar boy and alleged victim of priest sexual abuse has asked a U.S. Bankruptcy Court judge to allow his $135 million lawsuit against the Catholic Archdiocese of Portland to proceed.
       A man identified only as C.B. filed a motion Friday seeking relief from the automatic stay that essentially put a temporary hold on all litigation against the archdiocese. The automatic stay went into effect July 6, the day the archdiocese filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection.
       "At some point, the archdiocese is going to have to come to terms with these claims," said Peter McKittrick, a Portland lawyer and bankruptcy specialist representing C.B. "They're either going to have to be settled or litigated. And we just didn't see any reason to wait."
       Church officials could not be reached for comment.
       C.B. claims he was repeatedly abused by the late the Rev. Maurice Grammond during the mid-1980s, when Grammond served at a church in Seaside. C.B. filed the complaint in 2001 in Multnomah County Circuit Court and was set to go to trial on July 6.
       But the church averted a trial when it went bankrupt the same day.
    • Church studying Ribandar molestation charges -- 13-y-o girl; some resisting prosecution. India flag; Mooney's MiniFlags 
       Navhind Times, www.navhindtimes.com/stories.php?part=news&Story_ID=08215 , NT Staff Reporter, Aug 20, 2004
       PANAJI, INDIA: The official spokesperson of the Archbishop Patriarch of Goa and Daman and secretary of the Diocesan Centre for Social Communications Media (DCSCM), Fr Olavo Velho Pereira, in a press note on Friday said the Church authorities in Goa are studying the allegations of molestation of a 13-year-old girl by the parish priest of Ribandar and advised restraint from all quarters.
       "Allegations of such serious nature demand careful study and proper discernment. In this context, the matter is under consideration of the Church authorities. If there is a serious case, it should be treated with seriousness - not by threats and slander," Fr Pereira's press note states.
       It also says some individuals, called a press conference and also spoke to local TV news channels regarding the alleged molestation. A letter containing the above allegation was also received by the Archbishop of Goa on the August 12, the press note says.
       "Natural justice would require that a proper inquiry be made into such accusations by the legitimate authorities, at their own pace. Instead, a total lack of seriousness and responsibility has been displayed by the signatory of the letter, who, according to reliable sources, distributed copies of his letter to all the residents of Ribandar and to all and sundry at the Panjim Bus Stand," the press note states.
    • Call out to find 'priest' victims [Byrns] -- altar boy. U.S.A. flag; Mooney's MiniFlags 
       New York Post, www.nypost.com/news/regionalnews/27279.htm , By Marsha Kranes, August 21, 2004
       NEW YORK: The family of the young altar boy who accused his priest of raping him in a Brooklyn church yesterday urged any other victims of the 61-year-old clergyman to "be courageous and come forward."
       "It's important that any other children who may have been molested come forward and contact the prosecutor," said lawyer Vidian Mallard, speaking on behalf of the family of the boy who accused the Rev. Joseph Byrns. "It would help convict him," Mallard said.
       Byrns has been charged with two felonies and 20 misdemeanors.
    • Court Upholds Mormon Sex Suit Dismissal [1976 Tilson] -- boy and girl. Time ran out. Mormon.
       Centre Daily, www.centredaily.com/mld/centredaily/news/9460174.htm , Associated Press, ~ Aug 21, 2004
       SALT LAKE CITY (UT) - A state appeals court upheld the dismissal of a lawsuit brought against the Mormon church by a mother and son who claimed they were abused by a church leader, saying the statute of limitations had run out.
       In a 2000 lawsuit listing The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints as a co-defendant, the mother and son claimed George Tilson abused both of them when they were children, saying the church knew of his history of abuse but failed to tell police or other officials.
       Tilson served as a "high priest," which is not a member of the church's clergy but is a term used to describe someone who is "deserving of the trust of its members," according to the lawsuit.
       The Utah Court of Appeals dismissed the lawsuit Thursday, saying the statute of limitations had run out on the woman's claims of negligence and breach of trust. She alleged she was abused in 1976.
    • For 2 Brothers, Priest's Arrest Is Bittersweet [Byrns, Daily] -- altar boy.
       The New York Times, nytimes.com/2004/08/21/nyregion/21about.html?ex=1093752000&en=b152b8ca414c34c2&ei=5040&partner=MOREOVER , By DAN BARRY, August 21, 2004
       NEW YORK: A son of Queens who left this city 30 years ago, damaged, began the morning yesterday at the computer in his Las Vegas home. Gradually, on a news Web site, there came into focus a classic perp-walk image of a man in a Yankees T-shirt, cuffed hands raised in a vain attempt to shield his face.
       As Bob Lambert stared into the photograph's dark detail, his emotions veered from glee to sorrow, guilt to anger. One moment, welcome relief that the hands of the Rev. Joseph Byrns were in shackles at last. The next moment, profound disgust at what the charismatic priest was accused of this time: molesting an altar boy while buying his silence with toys.
       "And that brought back the memories," Mr. Lambert said.
       You would not want these memories of Bob Lambert's, nor those of his younger brother, the Rev. Timothy Lambert - nor, perhaps, those of certain officials of the Roman Catholic Diocese of Brooklyn and Queens. For years, the Lambert brothers shouted that Father Byrns had molested them as children, and for years, its bishop, Thomas V. Daily, and his advisers did little more than nod and say a case of they-said-he-said, let us pray.
       Now, with the arrest of this popular priest, the Lamberts experience a pained vindication, while high-ranking members of the clergy contemplate a painful chronology.
    • Teacher's attorney rejects accusations [? 2004 Reiser]
       COLLEYVILLE Star-Telegram, www.dfw.com/ mld/dfw/news/ 9454804.htm ?ERIGHTS=2297745728942423096dfw::kashaw@peoplepc.com&KRD_RM= 8oowvxvswt pwovppxo rooooooo| Kathleen|Y ; By Darren Barbee, ~ Aug 21, 2004
       COLLEYVILLE (TX) -- A Holy Trinity Catholic School teacher is stunned by accusations that she sexually assaulted a 13-year-old male student and denies any offenses, her attorney says.
       But Mitch Poe, chief of the Crimes Against Children Unit of the Tarrant County district attorney's office, said Friday he will move forward with what he called a "very disturbing case" by seeking an indictment from the Tarrant County grand jury next month.
       In June, Dawn Reiser, 29, of Euless was arrested by Colleyville police and suspended without pay from her duties as religion and English teacher at the school in Grapevine. The offense is considered aggravated because it involves a child younger than 14 years of age, police said.
       Reiser has declined to comment. But her attorney, Sam Cammack of Bailey, Galyen and Gold in Bedford, said the allegations are unfounded.
       "They were a surprise to Mrs. Reiser," he said. "Mrs. Reiser was a consummate professional and was very friendly with the children, but [showed] no inappropriate type of behavior.
       "She had a lot of contact with the parents as well as the children," he said. "She was just a good school teacher."
    • Audit shows Pittsburgh diocese complying with abuse policies, officials say -- 10% non-compliant.
       Centre Daily, www.centredaily.com/mld/centredaily/news/politics/9455043.htm , Associated Press, ~ Aug 21, 2004
       PITTSBURGH (PA) - The Pittsburgh Roman Catholic Diocese is complying with church policies on handling clergy sex abuse cases, an outside audit has found, according to the diocese.
       Two years ago, America's Catholic bishops responded to the clergy sex abuse controversy by adopting a toughened discipline plan that mandated annual reviews of whether the 195 U.S. dioceses were doing enough to protect children.
       The first onsite audits were conducted last year and found that 90 percent of dioceses were in compliance with the new policy. Pittsburgh is among the first dioceses to have a second audit.
       Diocese spokesman the Rev. Ronald Lengwin said Pittsburgh had in place many of the practices before they became required policy.
    • Toledo Diocese Settles 23 Sexual Abuse Suits -- > $US 1m agreement.
       13abc.com ; http://abclocal. go.com/wtvg/ news/820_toledo catholics.html , ~ Aug 21, 2004
       TOLEDO (OH): The Toledo Diocese says it's reached an agreement to settle 23 sex abuse suits. The suits are part of the sexual abuse scandal that's plagued the Catholic Church.
       Bishop Leonard Blair released a statement Friday giving details. It says, all lawsuits against the diocese that deal with sexual abuse of minors by clergy have been settled or will soon be settled. One suit was dismissed voluntarily.
       The cost to the diocese tops more than a million dollars, which Catholic leaders say will be paid out of an insurance fund. Bishop Blair says "while the financial costs are significant, they pale in comparison to the human costs of this scandal."
    • 2nd audit commends diocese on abuse response
       Post-Gazette (Pittsburgh), www.post-gazette.com/pg/04234/365263.stm , By Steve Levin, Saturday, August 21, 2004
       PITTSBURGH (PA): An independent audit this week of the Catholic Diocese of Pittsburgh -- the second in less than a year -- found it in full compliance with national policies developed by the church in the wake of its clergy sexual abuse scandal.
       The double audits of each of the country's 195 dioceses are required as part of the U.S. bishops' 2002 approval of the Charter for the Protection of Children and Young People. The bishops approved the second round of on-site audits at their June meeting.
       Pittsburgh was one of the first dioceses to have a second audit. It began Monday and concluded about noon yesterday, said the Rev. Ronald Lengwin, a diocese spokesman.
       While the diocese's first audit noted that its policies and procedures "warrant commendation and reference as 'best practices,' " the most recent one found that the diocese had conducted activities "which exceed the requirements of the charter."
    • Parish futures eyed -- Article admits losses are due to abuse.
       Sun Chronicle, www.thesunchronicle.com/articles/2004/08/21/city/city1.txt , Aug 21, 2004
       FALL RIVER (MA): Catholic clergy and laity in the Fall River Diocese will embark on a study that could lead to recommendations to close, merge or expand some parishes.
       Bishop George Coleman is calling for the study that he said is due to population shifts from the cities to the suburbs, a "serious decrease" in the number of priests, and a "relative decline" in Mass attendance.
       No figures are yet available on declining attendance, diocesan spokesman John Kearns said, but that data is expected to be released as the study gets under way in the fall.
       But the number of diocesan priests is expected to drop by more than half in the next two decades, from more than 120 now to fewer than 60 by 2021.
       The decline is due to an aging priestly population and a shortage of new recruits to the priesthood, as well as to the loss of priests who were accused of sexual abuse in recent years.
    • Bishop sorry for diocese's comment on suit [1980 Mickey] -- twin boys.
       The Jackson Sun, http://miva.jacksonsun.com/miva/cgi-bin/miva?NEWS/news_storyV2.mv+link=200408216424546 , By WENDY ISOM, wisom@jacksonsun.com , Aug 21 2004
       MEMPHIS (TN): The bishop of the Catholic Diocese of Memphis issued a formal apology Friday for remarks the diocese's communications director made regarding sexual abuse allegations against the pastor at St. Mary's Catholic Church.
       In an article that ran on Aug. 13 in The Jackson Sun, communications director John Morris said: "We think the allegations are false." Morris added, however, "to be fair to the families and children and to Father (Richard) Mickey, the bishop thought it would be best to have him placed on administrative leave while we do an internal investigation."
       The same day the article was published, leaders of a national support group for clergy sex abuse victims, Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests [SNAP], sent a letter to the Diocese of Memphis and requested an apology.
       "As an absolute bare minimum, Morris needs to publicly apologize to Catholics for his insensitive and potentially dangerous remark," SNAP founder and president Barbara Blaine, of Chicago, said in the letter. "We're not sure if Father Mickey is indeed a child molester. But we are sure that when church leaders prematurely proclaim that an accused abuser is innocent, they deter others who may have witnessed or experienced abuse from coming forward."
       In a letter apologizing for "the lack of sensitivity" of Morris' comments, Bishop J. Terry Steib said: "Mr. Morris has known Father Mickey both personally and professionally for many years, and under the pressure of the moment misspoke."
       Twin brothers Blain and Blair Chambers said in a lawsuit filed in Circuit Court in Memphis that Mickey abused them in 1980 when they were students at Bishop Byrne High School, where Mickey worked as a counselor and religion instructor. The brothers are seeking unspecified damages from Mickey, the diocese and the school. Mickey has denied the allegations. He has been reassigned to administrative duties in Memphis during the investigation.
    • Tucson Diocese Facing Another Lawsuit -- hiding assets alleged.
       KOLD, www.kold.com/Global/story.asp?S=2203266&nav=14RTQ6cA , (AP), ~ Aug 21, 2004
       TUCSON (AZ): Another lawsuit has been filed against the Tucson Diocese by lawyers accusing the church of hiding millions of dollars in real estate assets.
       The suit was filed in Pima County Superior Court on behalf of 20 plaintiffs who already have actions pending.
       The suit comes as the diocese considers possible Chapter 11 reorganization. The diocese is weighing whether to file for federal bankruptcy protection as a way of meeting its financial costs associated with sexual abuse lawsuits
    • Priests weigh in on abuse report [1998] -- boy.
       Press-Citizen, www.press-citizen.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article? AID=/20040821/NEWS01/408210319/1079 ; By Vanessa Miller, Aug 21, 2004
       IOWA: In the wake of sexual abuse allegations involving a Johnson County parish, local priests are reiterating the Catholic Church's sentiment that each incident is troubling and needs to be taken seriously.
       "It's a concern, it's a grave matter," said the Rev. Rudolph P. Juarez, a priest with St. Patrick's Church, 228 E. Court St. "I hope justice can be done. I hope all those hurt can have healing brought about."
       The case involving Johnson County surfaced after a priest in the Roman Catholic Diocese of Davenport recently was restricted from active duty pending results of an internal investigation into allegations that a boy was sexually abused in a local parish in 1998. Identities of the victim, the accused priest and the parish have not been released.
       According to diocese attorney Rand Wonio, the Diocese Review Board could complete the internal investigation as early as next week, after which officials will decide whether to identify the priest and the alleged victim. Wonio said he thinks the alleged victim told another priest about the alleged abuse. That priest then told the diocese, who reported the claim to Assistant Johnson County attorney Anne Lahey on July 11, 2003. [Posted by Kathy Shaw at 03:37 AM]
    ////////// End of Clergy Sex Abuse Tracker www.ncrnews.org/abuse , Sat August 21, 2004
    Abuse Chronology: http://www.multiline.com.au/~johnm/ethics/ethcont93.htm
    • Even a priest's complaints did not lead bishop to expel sex-abusing priest. [2000-02 Byrns] -- two males, altar boy. "Inquiry" without quizzing complainants!
       The West Australian, Perth, W. Australia, "Accused priest in new abuse case," Associated Press, page 38, Saturday, August 21 , 2004
       NEW YORK: A Catholic priest charged with sexually abusing an 11-year-old altar boy committed the crimes while decades-old allegations against him were making headlines, lawyers say.
       In 2002, New York prosecutors had found two adult brothers' abuse claims against the Rev. Joseph Byrns credible but the statute of limitations had expired.
       On Thursday, prosecutors in Brooklyn said that Mr Byrns, 61, had been charged with abusing the altar boy over two years from 2000.
       Bob Lambert, 48, said yesterday that the latest abuse could have been averted if the Brooklyn diocese had listened to the claims he made in 1997 with his brother, the Rev. Timothy Lambert, a priest in another New Jersey diocese.
       Diocesan officials never contacted the brothers, though they publicly said they investigated the charges and found no evidence to support them, said Mr Lambert, who has sued the diocese. "I'm very disgusted," he said. "There was no reason for this to happen." #
    FOR GOOD TEACHINGS TO BE HEEDED, A BIG CLEAN-UP IS NEEDED
    Clergy Sex Abuse Tracker SIGN-UP: www.ncrnews.org/abuse/signup.php for daily e-mails
    or click Clergy Sex Abuse Tracker www.ncrnews.org/abuse for current on-line
    The Boston Globe Spotlight http://www.boston.com/globe/spotlight/abuse
    The Needle periodically, and books: pbpress@iinet.net.au W. Australia
    References at: www.multiline.com.au/~johnm/ethicscontents.htm
    Overview at: www.multiline.com.au/~johnm/minilist.htm
    Books: www.multiline.com.au/~johnm/carnalbooks.htm
    Buy Fidelity magazine www.j23.com.au Australia

    INTENTION: A challenge to RELIGIONS to PROTECT CHILDREN. Click for more explanation.

    NEWSITEMS RECEIVED COVERING OTHER THAN CHILD AND/OR SEXUAL ABUSE
    • 2d guilty plea made in corruption case.
    Jose Mendoza, a Reading carpenter, admitted lying to a bank about working for a company said to have done repairs at codefendant Corey Kemp's church. [2000s] -- Church of God in Christ. U.S.A. flag; Mooney's MiniFlags 
       Philadelphia Inquirer, www.philly.com/mld/inquirer/news/local/states/pennsylvania/cities_neighborhoods/ philadelphia/9401894.htm?ERIGHTS=- 4440908831610272489philly::kashaw@peoplepc.com&KRD_RM= 1impqpknppohhhhhhhhhh oljmp|Kathleen|Y ; By Emilie Lounsberry, Posted on Sun, Aug. 15, 2004
       PHILADELPHIA (PA): A Berks County carpenter yesterday became the second defendant to plead guilty in the sprawling federal corruption indictment that also led to charges against former Philadelphia Treasurer Corey Kemp and lawyer Ronald A. White.
       No other guilty pleas are scheduled. The remaining 10 defendants are on a course for trial, now scheduled to begin in January, in U.S. District Court.
       Jose Mendoza, 45, pleaded guilty to making a false statement to a bank that he was general manager of a company said to have done repairs at Kemp's church, St. James Chapel Church of God in Christ, in Reading.
       "Why do you want to plead guilty?" U.S. District Judge Michael M. Baylson asked.
       "I realize I made a big mistake," Mendoza replied.
       His defense lawyer, L. Felipe Restrepo, later characterized Mendoza as a "very good man who found himself in a very bad situation" and was now quite remorseful.
       Mendoza has agreed to cooperate with federal prosecutors in the ongoing investigation. On Thursday, another defendant, lawyer Rhonda M. Anderson, pleaded guilty to mail fraud and agreed to cooperate.
    • Anambra Lawmakers: We Swore at Okija Shrine [2004] Nigeria flag; Mooney's MiniFlags 
       This Day, www.thisdayonline.com/news/20040815news02.html , By Collins Edomaruse, Aug 15, 2004
       NIGERIA: Majority Leader of Anambra State House of Assembly, Hon. Humphrey Nsofor, yesterday admitted that he and 21 other members of the House were forcefully paraded before the Okija shrine's chief priests, to take an oath of allegiance.
       Giving a graphic detail of the exercise over the telephone last night, the lawmaker, however, denied acceding to the terms of the oaths administration as: "I opted to swear with the name of the Almighty God."
       The lawmaker who said the exercise, at the instance of their estranged godfather, Chief Chris Uba, was mainly to extract a definite commitment that the members of the House would be loyal to him.
       "He cajoled us, at some point, intimidated us, but assured us that if we remained loyal to him, he would ensure that President Olusegun Obasanjo does anything he wants him to do for us in the course of our duty.
       "He also told us at the shrine that if we fell short of being loyal to him, the deity would take our lives."
    • Pastors must refrain from deceit Ghana flag; Mooney's MiniFlags 
       GhanaWeb, www.ghanaweb.com/GhanaHomePage/NewsArchive/artikel.php?ID=64118 , Aug. 16, 2004
       GHANA: Reverend Lawrence Sikatse, a Pastor of the International Christian Association on Sunday advised Pastors to refrain from using the banner of Christianity to engage in deceit. He was delivering a sermon at the Dela Evangelical Presbyterian Church, Ghana, at Ho-Kpodzi, in Ho on Sunday.
       Rev Sikatse said tricks, which undermine the purpose of Christianity, were as evil as the act of murder.
       He said material wealth means nothing in heaven and advised the rich to give to the under-privileged.
    • Michigan priest wanted on embezzlement charge [2000s Werra] -- $240,000 missing. U.S.A. flag; Mooney's MiniFlags 
       Catholic World News, www.cwnews.com/news/viewstory.cfm?recnum=31516 , Aug. 16, 2004
       KALAMAZOO, Michigan, (CWNews.com) - An arrest warrant has been issued for a Michigan priest who authorities say may have stolen $240,000 from his parishes. Father Bogdon Werra of the Diocese of Kalamazoo faces a charge of embezzlement over $20,000.
       Van Buren County Prosecutor Juris Kaps said this week that authorities were working with Werra's attorney to have the 49-year-old priest turn himself in. In a statement, the diocese said it had undertaken a preliminary investigation that "found evidence of financial irregularities in excess of $240,000" at St. John Bosco Parish in Mattawan and St. Margaret Mary Mission in Marcellus.
    • Area Priest May Face Charges in Finance Probe [2000s Werra]
       Courier Leader, www.zwire.com/site/news.cfm?newsid=12704840&BRD=2188&PAG=461 &dept_id=414962 &rfi=6 , August 16, 2004
       MATTAWAN, MICHIGAN - The resignation of area priest, the Rev. Bogdon Werra, was recently accepted by the local Roman Catholic diocese.
       The priest, who serves churches at St. John Bosco Parish in Mattawan and St. Margaret Mary Mission in Marcellus, has been under investigation for alleged financial irregularities at those churches.
       Michigan State Police Detective Mike Spring said this week that a report has been turned into the Van Buren County Prosecutor's Office for review.
    • Archdiocese: Former pastor mismanaged $271,000 in funds [2000s Axe]
       The Cincinnati Post, www.cincypost.com/2004/08/16/arch081604.html , Associated Press, Aug 16, 2004
       CINCINNATI (OH): A yearlong church investigation has found that the former pastor at the largest parish in the Archdiocese of Cincinnati mismanaged $271,000 in a church account.
       The Rev. Thomas Axe also spent some of the money in the discretionary account on personal expenses, archdiocese officials said, declining to reveal that amount.
       Axe, who retired last year, was pastor of the Good Shepherd parish in suburban Montgomery, which has more than 4,000 families and 12,000 members.
       The investigation began when a church audit concluded that Axe had spent some of the parishioners' money on himself.
       "It is uncontested that Father Axe mismanaged the parish's funds and co-mingled personal expenses with expenses of the parish," the archdiocese and Axe said in a joint statement Sunday.
    • Pastor Dives Into River - To Escape Arrest [2004 Watch] -- New Life Fountain Ministry. Ghana flag; Mooney's MiniFlags 
       GhanaWeb, www.ghanaweb.com/GhanaHomePage/NewsArchive/artikel.php?ID=64203 , Tues, 17 August 2004
       GHANA: Luck eluded the pastor of New Life Fountain Ministry at Obuasi in the Ashanti Region when he dived into the Offin River in a bid to escape arrest.He had to be rescued by the very person he was running away from, together with some residents since he could not swim and therefore found himself drowning.
       The pastor, Theophilus Watch, was suspected by one Mr Richard Amoasi, a licensed chemical seller at Dunkwa-on-Offin in the Central Region, to have stolen his electrical gadgets and was therefore going to confront him at his hideout.The pastor who had gone into hiding in a bush near the Offin River after committing the crime, on seeing Amoasi approaching, dived into the river.
       Some residents who witnessed the incident and spoke to The Mirror, alleged that the pastor took advantage of Mr Amoasi's absence to rob him of his video deck, VCD and sound system after he had gone to his house to pray for him. They said Pastor Watch had been having prayer sessions with Mr Amoasi at his residence at Dunkwa-on-Offin for some time and for his last prayer visit, he arranged to visit again on a Tuesday.
    • Okija Has Foreign Patrons - Priest [2004] Nigeria flag; Mooney's MiniFlags 
       AllAfrica.com ; http://allafrica.com/stories/200408161473.html , Fidelis Okolie, Lagos, August 16, 2004
       NIGERIA: One of the arrested priests at the Okija shrine in Anambra State and son of the 90-year-old chief priest of the shrine, in whose custody 10 registers containing names of prominent patrons of the shrine were found, has disclosed that foreigners also patronised the shrine.
       Speaking in Abuja, Fidelis said apart from Nigerians who swore on oath at the shrine, some foreigners also visited the shrine to seek retribution against their oppressors.
       According to him, aggrieved individuals from Aba, Nsukka, Imo, Lagos, Ebonyi and some African countries also visited the shrine to seek justice or to cement an agreement.
       He stressed that the shrine had been in existence for a long time and that every Igbo man and woman knew of its existence.
    • Church dispute erupts about pastor, financial records [2000s Reed ] -- Progressive Baptists. U.S.A. flag; Mooney's MiniFlags 
       WQAD, www.wqad.com/Global/story.asp?S=2183392&nav=1sW7PwH2 , 6:57 AM, Aug/17/04,
       DAVENPORT, IOWA (AP) -- The Progressive Baptist Church's board of trustees in Davenport is suing its former pastor, treasurer, financial secretary and two trustees in a dispute highlighted by members calling the police to sit through one Sunday service to keep order.
       Vince George, a member of the church's council, told police the congregation is split between those supporting the Reverend Jimmy F. Reed and those opposed. George told police that Reed refused to obey the council's vote to remove him.
       Police officers were called to sit through the July 18th church service, but they called the dispute a civil issue and remained only to keep the peace.
       In a lawsuit filed in Scott County District Court, the board claims Reed and other defendants have continued denying access to church financial records so they can be audited. It also claims that Reed and the other defendants did not deposit Sunday church collections in a timely manner and had the treasurer keep the collections at her home without accountability.
    • Romanian cleric in trouble for long sermon [2004 Rusu] -- Orthodox. Roumania flag; Mooney's MiniFlags 
       Ananova, www.ananova.com/news/story/sm_1062663.html
       ROMANIA: A Romanian orthodox priest is to live in seclusion for a month after delivering a five-hour funeral service.
       Agapie Aurel Rusu has also been ordered to live on just bread and water for the month as a punishment.
       The case of the long funeral service has also came under the attention of consumer protection authorities after complaints regarding the things he's alleged to have said during the service.
       It's reported the priest wanted to get revenge on the 21-year-old dead man's relatives who had wanted another priest to officiate the funeral.
       He talked during the sermon about politics, history and even heart surgery. He's also said to have used many poems to illustrate the sermon.
    • Police Go After Okija Shrines' Patrons [2004] Nigeria flag; Mooney's MiniFlags 
       AllAfrica.com ; http://allafrica.com/stories/200408170820.html , By MALACHY UZENDU and FELIX UKA, August 17, 2004
       ABUJA and AWKA, NIGERIA: Investigations into the Okija shrines matter moved a rung up as police yesterday decided to invite some of the accused patrons of the shrines to Force Headquarters, Abuja.
       It was alleged that top politicians and some wealthy businessmen whose identities are being tightly guarded, are among those expected to be invited.
       But Deputy Speaker of Anambra State House of Assembly, Ozo Ughamadu (Awka South II), said yesterday that he did not doubt an earlier re-port by the Majority Leader that members of the Assembly were at the Okija shrines, adding, however, that he (Ughamadu) did not take any oath there.
       The decision to invite the shrine patrons has already been communicated to Assistant Commissioner of Police (ACP), Ahmed Yusuf, who is co-ordinating investigations of the Okija shrines matter.
    • Okija Shrines Register Not Missing, Say Police [2004]
       AllAfrica.com ; http://allafrica.com/stories/200408180630.html , By Ndidi Okafor, Malachy Uzendu and Felix Uka, August 18, 2004
       ABUJA/AWKA, Nigeria: Fresh controversy now trails the findings at Okija shrines in Anambra State, following a claim sweeping through the area that two of the registers of victims recovered there may have become missing.
       Daily Champion learnt that the rumour emanated from public suspicion regarding discrepancies in the number of registers police said they recovered.
       But, both Force Headquarters in Abuja and the state police command have denied the claim that any register was missing, saying that the rumour was "a distraction to make the police deviate in its investigations" and "intended to further raise tension".
       South-East Traditional Rulers Forum, on its part, said shrines are part of traditional religion all over Nigeria but denounced any killing or maiming of people associated with the worship.
    • The bizarre case of Rev. Ryan St. Anne Scott U.S.A. flag; Mooney's MiniFlags 
       Renew America, www.renewamerica.us/columns/abbott/040818 , by Matt C. Abbott, August 18, 2004
       WISCONSIN: During his tenure in the Diocese of La Crosse, Wis., then-Bishop Raymond Burke - currently the noted Archbishop of St. Louis - had a particularly interesting cross to bear, one might say. That cross was one Ryan Patrick Scott. Father Ryan Patrick Scott, that is.
       Or, as he is currently known, Father Ryan St. Anne, O.S.B. You see, Scott is an independent Catholic priest. In Church-speak, he is schismatic, that is, not in communion with Rome. And whether he is/was validly ordained is, well, debatable.
       (According to sedevacantist priest Fr. Anthony Cekada, Scott "claims he was ordained a priest by an Old Catholic and then conditionally ordained by the retired Bishop of Peoria who was then suffering from Alzheimer's disease.")
       At the USCCB's November 2002 meeting, during the height of the clergy sex-abuse scandal, Father St. Anne gave a presentation at a press conference held by 'The Linkup' organization for survivors of clergy abuse. The following are excerpts:
       "On Saturday, October 26, 2002, I stood before Archbishop Timothy Dolan's listening panel for victims of sexual abuse by members of the Catholic clergy in the Archdiocese of Milwaukee. As I did so, one of the thoughts that ran through my mind was: 'Why am I here, begging you for help?' I wondered if I had sunk so low as to finally seek help from those who abuse and cover-up. My answer was clear: No. I am here because I have hope!
       "As you can see, I am a priest. My name is Father Ryan St. Anne. I am a Benedictine Monastic priest, but I am also a victim of sexual abuse by members of the Catholic clergy in an incident that occurred in the Archdiocese of Milwaukee.
       "In 1996 when I brought this forward in a private meeting with diocesan officials [in La Crosse, Wisconsin], the information I provided was used against me in the form of public defamation, denouncement, libel and slander. Because I came forward, the bishop [Burke] had me jailed for 23 days under false charges, and while I was being held, that same bishop obtained a restraining order forbidding me to speak to him for three years.
       "In 1998, my confessor, spiritual director, friend and colleague, Rev. Father Alfred J. Kunz, from Dane, Wisconsin, was brutally murdered in his church, just prior to substantiating not only my story, but the scandal itself that is rocking the Catholic Church today.
       "In the early fall of 1976, as a young religious, I was brutally gang-raped in the rectory of St. John's Cathedral in Milwaukee, Wisconsin. I was lured there under false pretenses by a fellow priest and set up for humiliation and bodily harm.."
       Does Fr. St. Anne's story hold water? Not according to the Diocese of La Crosse. In an e-mail to me, the diocese's Vicar General and Moderator of the Curia, Father Richard W. Gilles, stated:
       "I am very aware of what 'Fr. Scott' has said about Bishop Burke. It is a complete falsehood and is slanderous of the good Bishop's reputation. In the Diocese we have learned one important lesson regarding all of this: have as little to do as possible with Scott. It is best not to engage him in any way, shape or form. All will be quickly distorted and used against you.
       "Again, there is no proof whatsoever that Scott was ever validly ordained."
       And then there's a story in a September 1999 edition of the La Crosse Tribune. Reporter Gayda Hollnagel wrote:
       "Bishop Raymond Burke and two other Diocese of La Crosse officials have been named in a defamation suit filed Wednesday in Dane County Circuit Court.
       "The suit was filed by Ryan St. Anne Scott, who is identified in the suit as the senior religious official for the Holy Rosary Abbey Inc., Pocahontas, Iowa.
       "Scott, who previously operated Holy Rosary Abbey in Vernon and Crawford counties, also uses the name, Father Ryan St. Anne Scott.
       "Scott accuses Burke of defaming him by making public statements saying that Scott is not a validly ordained Roman Catholic priest, that he does not follow the precepts, dogma, sacred teaching and traditions, doctrines, practices and mandates of the Roman Catholic Church.
       "Also named in the suit were the Rev. Michael Gorman, diocesan moderator of the curia, and Sister Marlene Weisenbeck, diocesan chancellor.
       "James Birnbaum, lawyer for the La Crosse diocese, said the diocese has not yet been served with the lawsuit and that he has not talked with Burke about it. However, he said he received a copy of the claim from a news reporter.
       "'There's nothing in there that I believe has legal or factual merit,' Birnbaum said.
       "He said the diocese has had previous dealings with Scott and in October 1996 obtained a temporary restraining order against him after Scott threatened Burke.
       "Birnbaum said Scott was never a priest of the diocese and had no connection with Burke or the diocese while he operated his Holy Rosary Abbey monastery.
       "The diocese in 1996 published an official decree in the diocesan newspaper, the Times Review, disavowing any connection with Scott.
       "According to Tribune files, Scott, a former finance officer for Edgerton, Wis., pleaded no contest to felony misconduct in office in Rock County on Feb. 3, 1994, was placed on three years probation. Scott, who lived in Avoca, Wis., at the time, was arrested two months after he quit his job. He was accused of taking a city check for $30 and cashing it for $300.
       "Diocesan officials said in 1996 that they were notified of Scott's presence by Erwin G. Clouse, Metropolitan Archbishop of the American Catholic Church, also known as the Reformed Catholic Church of America.
       "Scott was a former priest of the group but was excommunicated by its Council of Bishops, according to the information received by the diocese."
       Also of note is Scott's reported association with the late Marvin Kucera, an alleged "mystic" who, according to an article on UnityPublishing.com, was "a con artist from the beginning."
       In an e-mail, Scott told me the article on that site is a "99 percent fabrication" and that, "I was not Marvin Kucera's 'spiritual director' -- I had only met him on one occasion in Wisconsin for about 15 minutes."
       Perhaps the most intriguing unanswered questions have to do with the aforementioned still-unsolved murder of Fr. Alfred Kunz, Scott's alleged spiritual director. (According to Scott, Father Kunz was the one who determined that his ordination was indeed valid.)
       In a telephone conversation several months ago, Scott told me he provided to the police all of the names of the priests who had allegedly assaulted him. He also claimed Father Kunz had confronted each of the priests involved in the alleged predatory ring and that none of them denied assaulting Scott.
       Scott also gave me the name of an ex-priest whom he claimed had been involved in the ring many years back and who might be willing to talk about the ring's activities.
       When I asked, via e-mail, Detective Kevin Hughes of the Dane County Sheriff's Office (who is well aware of Scott), which is investigating the Father Kunz murder, if that ex-priest's name rang a bell, the detective responded, "I cannot answer that."
       Father Ryan St. Anne Scott currently resides in Powers Lake, North Dakota, where he has already made the news. In a story in the May 20, 2004 edition of the Minot Daily News, reporter Andrea Johnson wrote:
       "A Williston judge approved a restraining order last month meant to keep the administrator of the Shrine of Our Lady of the Prairies and two members of the Shrine's board of directors from coming into contact with one another.
       "Abbot Ryan St. Anne, 51, and Roseanna P. Gebvelinger, who was listed as treasurer of the board in a church newsletter last year, sought the restraining order against board members Paul Dobrowski and Jerry Durick in Northwest District Court in Williams County on April 16.
       "In his petition for the restraining order, St. Anne alleged that members of the board had made threats against him and threatened to destroy property and financial records at the Shrine. St. Anne also alleged that the Shrine of Qur Lady of the Prairies is the subject of a county, state and federal investigation into its finances prior to St. Anne's arrival at the Shrine more than a year ago..
       ."He is not recognized as a priest by the Bismarck Catholic Diocese and the church is not considered part of the diocese.
       "St. Anne himself has a 1994 felony conviction for misconduct in public office. St. Anne said.those charges were related to certain information he divulged during a public meeting when he served as finance officer of Edgerton, Wis. St. Anne, who was then known as Ryan Patrick Scott, pleaded no contest to the charge.
       "Felony forgery charges against him -- related to an accusation that he took a city check for $30 and cashed it for $300 -- were dropped by the judge.
       "St. Anne said he feels none of those charge was not really justified.
       "He said he was told by the mayor and city manager of Edgerton to divulge that information at the meeting. He also said he called for an audit of city finances in Edgerton and subsequently city board members there were also charged.
       "St. Anne was sentenced to three years of probation by a Rock County, Wis., judge, which he served from 1994 to 1997."
       Matt C. Abbott is the former executive director of the Illinois Right to Life Committee and the former director of public affairs for the Chicago-based Pro-Life Action League. He is also a contributor to Cruxnews.com, RenewAmerica.us, MichNews.com, IllinoisLeader.com, AmericanDaily.com, ChristianNewsToday.com, Catholiccitizens.org, "The Wanderer" Catholic newspaper, TCRNews2.com, Catholic.net, Catholic.org, and CatholicExchange.com. He can be reached at mattcabbott@CatholicExchange.com
    © Copyright 2004 by Matt C. Abbott, www.renewamerica.us/columns/abbott/040818 #
    • 'Satanic priest' at center of manhunt [2000s McDonald] -- bank allegations. "Self-described satanic priest".
       El Paso Times, www.borderlandnews.com/stories/borderland/20040819-157364.shtml , by Daniel Borunda, Aug 19, 2004
       TEXAS: The U.S. Marshals' Service is after several fugitives, including a "satanic priest" believed to be hiding in Juárez, officials said Wednesday.
       Peter McDonald Jr. "is a self-described satanic priest" with a pentagram tattoo on his neck. He has been wanted since Jan. 8, 2003, on a bond revocation stemming from a bank fraud charge, said Jerry Payan, supervisor of the fugitive task force. Marshals have received information that the 28-year-old, blue-eyed blond has been involved in occult rituals in Juárez.
       McDonald, who also uses the name "Amen," is 6 feet 4 inches tall and weighs 235 pounds, officials said.
       "He is easy to spot if you see him," Payan said.
    • Charges weighed in baby's death [2004 McKim] -- Youth pastor left baby in car in heat.
       Commercial Appeal, www.commercialappeal.com/mca/local_news/article/0,1426,MCA_437_3118209,00.html , By Clay Bailey, August 18, 2004
      TENNESSEE: Stephen McKim already has received a life sentence of guilt. Dist. Atty. Gen. Bill Gibbons's office now will decide if society should hand down further punishment.
       The question of criminal prosecution against the 25-year-old father lingers because of issues such as precedent, fairness and equal treatment of such cases.
       Bartlett police investigators will likely meet with the attorney general's office this week to discuss their findings in the review of 7-month-old Mia McKim's death. Stephen McKim, a youth pastor at Central North Church who was running late for work Aug. 9, left the baby in a car where temperatures reached at least 115 degrees in the ensuing two hours.
       "The attorney general is the one who has to defend this," Bartlett Asst. Chief Mark Hopper said. "We want the attorney general's staff to be comfortable with this, and the best way to do that is let them decide if they want to prosecute."
       State prosecutor Thomas Henderson, who will review the case, declined comment this week, citing the ongoing investigation.
    • Stuart pastor takes leave amid state fiscal probe [2000s Allen]
       Palm Beach Post, www.palmbeachpost.com/localnews/content/martin_stlucie/ epaper/ 2004/08/19/m1a_mcpastor_0819.html ; By Pat Moore, Thursday, August 19, 2004
       STUART (FL) - The longtime pastor of St. Joseph Catholic Church abruptly left the church last month amid a state investigation into a complaint of financial improprieties, a Treasure Coast prosecutor confirmed Wednesday.
       The Rev. Alden Christopher Allen, 52, who joined the Stuart church as assistant pastor in 1992 and became its pastor in 1997, said he "decided to take a leave of absence for my own personal reasons."
       He denied knowing anything about financial problems at the church.
       But Assistant State Attorney Chris Taylor confirmed that his office was investigating a complaint about where contributions were going.
       "There was a concern over what was done with the money after it was donated," he said.
    • Two Nigerians Arrested in Ireland for Ritual Killing [2004] Nigeria flag; Mooney's MiniFlags  Ireland, Republic, flag; Mooney's MiniFlags 
       This Day, www.thisdayonline.com/news/20040819news03.html , By Moses Jolayemi in Lagos and Charles Onyekamuo in Awka, with agency report, Aug 19, 2004
       IRELAND: Barely one month after the conviction in the United Kingdom of a Nigerian, Kingsley Ojo for the brutal murder of a five year old boy named Adam, police in the Republic of Ireland are questioning two men arrested in Dublin in connection with the murder of the daughter of Malawi's chief justice.
       The headless body of Paiche Unyolo Onyemaechi was found last month in the south of Ireland, where she lived with her Nigerian husband and two children.
       Her killing may have had a ritualistic motive, according to the police.
       Detectives have been keen to trace her husband, Chika, who is currently missing.
       The two men being interviewed by police were arrested in Dublin on Tuesday. ...
       Meanwhile in Nigeria, Inspector General of Police, Mr. Tafa Balogun yesterday in Okija, Anambra state, said the chief priests and the over 30 priests of the different shrines of Ogwugwu deity arrested on August 4 would be prosecuted for ritual killings at the end of police investigations.
    • Ritual murders: Inside Nigeria's 'evil forest' [2004] Nigeria flag; Mooney's MiniFlags 
       Mail and Guardian, http://www.mg.co.za/Content/l3.asp?ao=120658 , by Joel Olatunde Agoi | Okija ; August 19, 2004
       NIGERIA: Two weeks after a police squad raided a group of fetish shrines in the dense jungle of southern Nigeria, dozens of partially decomposed bodies still littered the groves of Okija's "evil forest".
       Open wooden coffins lay abandoned in the dense undergrowth as spooked cops continued an investigation that has scandalised Nigeria and prompted a bout of national soul searching.
       "It is fearful and dreadful. Ordinary mortals avoid the vicinity of the shrines like a ghost," said 25-year-old Austine Ogbuche, one of a courageous group of villagers who followed Nigeria's police chief into the woods.
       "It is only the government and its agents that can dislodge the shrines. Nobody can dare the gods," he said, as inspector general Tafa Balogun and a heavily-armed squad of officers set off into Ogugwu Akpu's dreaded groves.
    • More human skulls found as probe continues
       IOL, www.iol.co.za/index.php?set_id=1&click_id=86&art_id=qw1092994021407N262
       AKURE, NIGERIA: Nigerian police have found two human skulls in different locations in south-western Ondo State, which they suspect to be the remains of victims of ritual murders, state police commissioner Nwachuku Egbochuku has told journalists.
       The skulls were recovered in Ode-Irele and Ajue, two neighbouring towns in the state, Egbochuku told journalists late on Thursday in Akure, the state capital.
       A priest for the local "ayelala" deity and another suspect have been arrested in connection with the find and are being questioned, he said.
       The discovery of the two new skulls followed a police raid a fortnight ago on shrines in an "evil forest" in Okija in south-east Anambra state where corpses, skeletons and more than 20 skulls were discovered.
       More than 30 people have so far been detained and more arrests have been promised following the discovery of membership lists of the three Ogwugwu shrines.
    • Pastor Under Investigation [Cortez] -- Alpha and Omega Church takes rent. U.S.A. flag; Mooney's MiniFlags 
       WOAI, www.woai.com/news/local/story.aspx?content_id=ACDC726B-4834-411F- AD8D-208FA76F9C47 ; Posted By: Karina Cardona, LAST UPDATE 6:28:10 AM, Aug/19/2004
       SAN ANTONIO (TX): A San Antonio pastor who's drawn a lot of controversy is getting more tonight.
       Pastor John Cortez says he runs his northwest side ministry to help the homeless and disadvantaged, but News 4 WOAI'S Amy Davis is uncovering evidence he's more interested in business than the Bible.
       There are 9 buildings classified as churches in his ministry within a one mile radius.
       The Bexar County Tax Assessor checked her files and found a problem: all churches are tax exempt, but these are actually houses that are free and clear of all property taxes.
       People must worship in those houses in order to continue having exemption status, but we found one woman living in one house.
       Tenant Linda Sanchez has lived there for three years. She showed Amy Davis receipts that she paid Pastor John Cortez $600 a month for rent. Sanchez also says she's made it clear she wants nothing to do with the church.
       Cortez told us last week another tenant offered to pay $200 a month and that's it out of her own kindness.
       He also says all of his tenants are missionaries and any money they give goes straight to his church, the "I am the Alpha and the Omega" church on Vance Jackson. [Posted by Kathy Shaw at 09:44 PM]
    • Priest pleads innocent to embezzlement charge [Werra] > $US240,000
       The Detroit Free Press, www.freep.com/news/statewire/sw102988_20040820.htm , AP, August 20, 2004
       PAW PAW, Mich. (AP) -- A Roman Catholic priest accused of embezzling more than $240,000 from two Van Buren County churches pleaded not guilty.
       The Rev. Bogdon Werra turned himself in for arraignment Thursday morning, court officials said. A preliminary examination is scheduled for Sept. 21.
       If convicted, Werra, who served at St. John Bosco Parish in Mattawan and St. Margaret Mary Mission in Marcellus, could face up to 10 years in prison.
       Werra, 49, is free on a personal recognizance bond, the Kalamazoo Gazette reported Friday.
    • Priest charged with embezzlement turns self in [? 2004 Werra]
       WOOD, 5:58 p.m., August 20, 2004
       MICHIGAN: A Catholic priest from West Michigan who has been charged with embezzling money from churches he served has turned himself in.
       Reverend Bogdon Werra pled not guilty. He was arraigned on charges of embezzling more than $20,000.
       Werra is a former pastor at parishes in Mattawan and Marcellus. He resigned last month.
    • Diocese ex-CFO to get same job in Columbus -- although FBI and insurers are inquiring.
       Cleveland Plain Dealer, www.cleveland.com/news/plaindealer/index.ssf?/base/cuyahoga/10929944 68200422.xml ; by James F. McCarty, Friday, August 20, 2004
       COLUMBUS (OH): The deposed chief financial officer of the Cleveland Catholic Diocese has a new job as the next CFO of the Diocese of Columbus.
       Joseph Smith resigned from the Cleveland diocese in January under a cloud of suspicion, accused of accepting more than $750,000 from an accounting firm he had hired to work for the diocese.
       The FBI is investigating the payments, and the diocese's insurance company reportedly has filed a claim against Smith to recoup the money - neither of which apparently deterred the Columbus diocese from hiring him as its new finance director.
       A Cleveland diocesan official said the Columbus diocese was made aware of the criminal investigation, as well as the circumstances of Smith's leaving after more than 20 years of employment in the state's largest diocese.
       "No recommendation concerning employment was requested, and none was provided," said spokesman Bob Tayek, reading from a news release.
       Few people involved were willing to talk about Smith's hiring when contacted Thursday. [Posted by Kathy Shaw at 09:39 PM]
    • Columbus diocese hires man who quit previous job amid financial controversy [Smith] -- allegation accepted $750,000.
       Beacon Journal, www.ohio.com/mld/beaconjournal/news/state/9462533.htm?ERIGHTS=- 3310265525208997331 ohio::kashaw@peoplepc.com&KRD_RM= 3rrmsojkosqnksjjjjjjjjkjjp|Kathleen|Y ; Associated Press
       COLUMBUS, Ohio - A man who resigned as chief financial officer for the Cleveland Catholic Diocese amid financial controversy has been hired to supervise the finances of the Columbus Catholic Diocese.
       Joseph H. Smith, 47, of Avon Lake, near Cleveland, will become the diocese's finance director in October, said diocesan spokeswoman Robin Miller.
       Smith resigned from the Cleveland diocese in February after he was accused of accepting about $750,000 from an accounting firm he hired to work for the diocese. Smith has not been charged.
       Cleveland diocesan spokesman Robert Tayek said the Columbus diocese has been told that a federal investigation of Smith is ongoing.
       Special Agent Robert Hawk of the Cleveland FBI office would not comment on whether there is a probe of Smith.
       Miller said she does not know whether the Columbus diocese was told of the allegations. She referred questions about Smith's hiring to Bishop James A. Griffin, who was attending a meeting of bishops and unavailable for comment.
    • 12 Okija Priests Wanted - IGP Nigeria flag; Mooney's MiniFlags 
       AllAfrica.com ; http://allafrica.com/stories/200408200600.html , by Malachy Uzendu, August 20, 2004
       ABUJA, NIGERIA: Twelve priests of the Okija shrines in Anambra State are being trailed by police.
       They are wanted for failing to turn themselves in to the authorities even as 13 others who did, were arrested for questioning.
       The revelation came as fresh from Wednesday's fact-finding trip to the shrines in Ihiala council area of the state Inspector-General of Police (IGP) Mr. Tafa Balogun, went to brief President Olusegun Obasanjo on the incident.
       The President was reportedly shocked that several public functionaries had patronised the shrines.
       Also reportedly made available to the President were the registers of clients to the Ogwugwu shrines as well as a list of those whose deaths may have been linked to the place.
    The END of Newsitems Received Covering Other Than Child And/Or Sexual Abuse
    ANCHOR LIST (After reading an article, use Browser's "Back" button to return to Anchor List)
    * Ostrich = "Are Church heads buried in the sand?" Australian Church newspapers seem to have ceased reporting the disgraces in the Roman Catholic Church in the USA, reporting instead such items as world leaders' visits to Lourdes and Egypt. Have the ostriches hidden their heads in the sand? The defrocking of an Anglican Bishop and the disgrace of CEBS, and the fact that the RCC has a diocese going into Bankruptcy Part 11 administration, are among the more than 10 "dot-points." Western Australia, Aug 18,2004
    If the original heading or name of an article or newsitem is not used at the start of an entry, the original heading or name will be found elsewhere in the entry.
    Some clickable links are for network access only, so might not work for you.
    *** NOTICE: In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, this material is available here without profit to people who want to read it for research and educational purposes. If you quote from this, please check (if possible) and acknowledge the ORIGINAL source. ***
    To SEARCH only ONE WEBPAGE AT A TIME, you may use the built-in features of your own Browser.  With most systems press [Ctrl] + F.  This will cause a Find or Find/Replace dialogue box, or a Search/Replace box, to appear.  (With some old programmes, start by pressing [Ctrl] + [Shift] + F.  However, if your system requires it, click Edit, then click Find.)  Type in a keyword, and press [Enter], or click Find Next, or Find, or Search.
    To SEARCH all of This Site, use the special panel provided.
    ^ ^  CONTENTS 1   14  Translate  Links  Events  Books  HOME  v v
    < < Back  ^ ^  Bravehearts  Barnardo's-UK  CTA  Celibacy Crept  Non-marital  REFERENCES 51   91  Overview  Outreach  Books  "Fathers"  Religion  Submit  v v   Next > >
    Search for
    Impressed? LookSmart and get a Free Search Engine for your own Web Site
    WWW Search Engines: www.google.com  www.metacrawler.com  www.looksmart.com ; AVG Free Anti-Virus
    Background colour changer
                                 
    By courtesy of www.ctpc.org/nltr1202/pl1202.htm -- Be CAREFUL with your mouse cursor!
    Flag/s by courtesy of Mooney's Miniflags http://www.edwardmooney.com/miniflags and/or Aust. Nat. Flag Assn. http://www.flagaustnat.asn.au . Flags are miniaturised, and where necessary, various images are adjusted by Jasc Paint Shop Pro.
    Hived off with Microsoft® WordPad© on 08 May 2004, first entries transferred on 16 Aug 04, first CSAT Id No. 005851, spellchecked with Ms Word© (regional spellings and grammar retained where applicable) on 10 Dec 04, last modified on 02 Jul 06
    Composed with monitor screen of 800 x 600 pixels, High Colour (16 bit)
    Translations: http://babelfish.altavista.com/  www.tranexp.com/  www.alis.com/  http://lingvo.org/traduku
    Doc. 238 +:   URL = http://www.multiline.com.au/~johnm/ethics/ethcont93.htm